Researched comparison
Best HPC Backup Software
Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.
Key takeaways
- HPC backup must handle large parallel file systems, fast-changing scratch data, and long-term archives, which is a different job from backing up office computers.
- NAKIVO and MSP360 cover virtualised and physical nodes at $2.50 per workload per month, while Zmanda Pro charges $5.99 per workload per month with flat pricing across renewals.
- Commvault Cloud publishes SaaS prices from $58.50 per TB per month for file and object backup, which makes it easy to budget for large research datasets.
- Bacula Enterprise and Storware publish no list price, so expect a quote, and compare the five-year cost rather than the first-year price.
- A 3-2-1 setup keeps three copies of research data on two media types, with one copy offsite, and tape remains the cheapest long-term copy for cold archives.
Contents
Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.
Comparison at a glance
Comparison
| Tool | Best for | Price range | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Veeam Backup and Replication | VM and physical backup for clusters | quote only | Free trial (30 days) |
| NAKIVO Backup and Replication | VM and NAS backup for research servers | $2.50 per workload/month | Free trial (15 days) |
| MSP360 Backup | Backup to your own cloud or local storage | $2.50 per workload/month | Free trial (15 days) |
| Commvault Cloud | SaaS backup with published per-TB pricing | $58.50 per TB/month | Free trial (30 days) |
| Bacula Enterprise | HPC, defence, and research environments | quote only | Free trial (30 days) |
| Zmanda Pro | Flat per-workload pricing for mixed estates | $5.99 per workload/month | Free trial (14 days) |
| Storware Backup and Recovery | Open virtualisation and OpenStack backup | quote only | Free trial (60 days) |
| HYCU | SaaS backup for cloud and on-premises workloads | quote only | Free trial (14 days) |
Ranked by tier
VM and physical backup for clusters
Veeam Backup and Replication
Veeam Backup and Replication is the most widely used backup platform for virtualised infrastructure, and it fits an HPC centre that runs its login nodes, schedulers, and storage heads as VMs. It backs up VMware, Hyper-V, and Nutanix VMs, physical Windows and Linux servers, and NAS file shares, with instant VM recovery that can bring a failed node back in minutes. Changed block tracking keeps daily backups fast even when the protected data runs into hundreds of terabytes. For HPC work, the NAS and file-share backup matters most, since the research data usually lives on a parallel file system rather than on a VM disk. Veeam can protect that shared store and copy it to a second location, with deduplication and compression that cut the storage needed for large datasets. Backup copies can be made immutable on supported storage, so a ransomware attack on the cluster cannot rewrite the backup.
Pros:
- Fast image-level backup with instant VM recovery
- supports immutable backup copies
Cons:
- No published list price for the full platform
- the console assumes storage and virtualisation skill
Price: quote only
Free plan: Free trial (30 days)
Website: veeam.com
Best for: VM and physical backup for clusters
VM and NAS backup for research servers
NAKIVO Backup and Replication
NAKIVO Backup and Replication is the lower-cost way to protect the virtualised and shared parts of an HPC estate. It backs up VMware, Hyper-V, and Nutanix VMs, physical Windows and Linux servers, and NAS file shares, with instant VM recovery that can bring a failed server back in minutes. The licence costs $2.50 per workload per month, which keeps the price predictable as the centre adds nodes. For research work, the NAS backup matters most. Many centres keep the live dataset on a large NAS or a parallel file system fronted by a NAS head, and a VM-only tool cannot protect that shared store. NAKIVO copies the NAS data to a second location, with deduplication and compression that cut the storage needed for large files. It also supports immutable backup copies on supported storage, so a ransomware attack on the file server cannot rewrite the backup.
Pros:
- Fast VM backup with instant recovery
- backs up NAS devices and file shares directly
Cons:
- No backup for bare-metal HPC compute nodes on the entry licence
- the interface assumes server knowledge
Price: $2.50 per workload/month
Free plan: Free trial (15 days)
Website: nakivo.com
Best for: VM and NAS backup for research servers
Backup to your own cloud or local storage
MSP360 Backup
MSP360 Backup fits an HPC centre that wants to choose its own storage instead of renting space from the backup vendor. The agent backs up servers and VMs to Backblaze B2, Wasabi, Amazon S3, or a local NAS, and the licence costs $2.50 per workload per month. A centre that already has a Wasabi or B2 account can keep storage costs low, since Wasabi charges $7.99 per TB per month and B2 charges $6.95 per TB per month. The backup itself is capable. MSP360 supports full disk images, file-level backup, and backup for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, so one agent can cover a login node, a file server, and the cloud mail in one policy. Retention and versioning are configurable, and the agent can run pre- and post-backup scripts, which helps a centre that needs to pause a job scheduler before a file is copied.
Pros:
- Works with Backblaze B2, Wasabi, AWS, and other storage
- image and file backup in one agent
Cons:
- You pay for storage separately, so the total cost is harder to predict
- setup needs a storage account first
Price: $2.50 per workload/month
Free plan: Free trial (15 days)
Website: msp360.com
Best for: Backup to your own cloud or local storage
SaaS backup with published per-TB pricing
Commvault Cloud
Commvault Cloud is the enterprise option with published prices, which makes it easy to budget for large research datasets. The SaaS pricing page lists file and object backup from $58.50 per TB per month, database backup from $90 per TB per month, and VM backup at $102.49 per 10-pack per month. A centre that protects 20 TB of file data can estimate $1,170 a month, or $14,040 a year, before volume discounts that apply above 50 TB. The platform is built for large estates. It covers VMs, physical servers, databases, NAS, and cloud workloads from one console, with application-aware recovery for Oracle and SAP that can restore a single tablespace or data file. Commvault Cleanroom supports isolated recovery testing, which matters when a centre must prove that a backup can be restored without reintroducing malware. The SaaS model also removes the need to run a backup server, which suits a centre with a small operations team.
Pros:
- Published SaaS prices for file, object, and database backup
- strong application-aware recovery
Cons:
- The per-TB price adds up fast past 50 TB
- self-managed software is sold by quote
Price: $58.50 per TB/month
Free plan: Free trial (30 days)
Website: commvault.com
Best for: SaaS backup with published per-TB pricing
HPC, defence, and research environments
Bacula Enterprise
Bacula Enterprise is built for the environments this article is about. The vendor describes it as backup and recovery for demanding enterprise, HPC, defence, government, and research environments, and it protects physical, virtual, container, database, SaaS, and cloud workloads from one centrally managed platform. That breadth matters for a centre that runs a mix of bare-metal compute nodes, virtualised services, and databases. The licensing model is the main attraction for large datasets. Bacula Enterprise charges by the number of protected endpoints and the support level, not by the volume of data protected, so a centre that grows from 100 TB to 500 TB does not see the licence cost grow with it. Tape support is built in, which keeps long-term archives cheap, since tape remains the lowest-cost medium for cold data. The platform also supports disk, object storage, and cloud targets, so a centre can keep a fast disk copy for recent restores and a tape copy for the archive.
Pros:
- Built for HPC centres with tape and long retention
- licensing is not based on data volume
Cons:
- No published list price
- the setup needs staff who know backup architecture
Price: quote only
Free plan: Free trial (30 days)
Website: baculasystems.com
Best for: HPC, defence, and research environments
Flat per-workload pricing for mixed estates
Zmanda Pro
Zmanda Pro is the predictable option for a mixed HPC estate. The price is $5.99 per workload per month, flat across renewals, and a workload is one protected instance, whether that is a VM, a physical server, a database, or a Microsoft 365 seat. The vendor publishes a worked example of $19,128 in year one for 100 workloads and 500 Microsoft 365 users on the Business plan, with a five-year total locked at $81,294. That kind of fixed pricing makes budgeting simple for a centre that plans years ahead. The coverage is broad. Zmanda Pro protects VMs, physical servers, databases, NAS file shares, and Microsoft 365 from one console, with a Linux backup server and true cross-platform support. The backup can go to disk, cloud, or Zmanda Cloud Storage, which is priced at $20,340 a year for 250 TB with no egress fees. That storage option suits a centre that restores often and wants to avoid per-GB download charges.
Pros:
- Flat $5.99 per workload per month with no renewal increase
- covers VMs, servers, databases, and Microsoft 365
Cons:
- No native tape support
- the entry plan lacks 24/7 support unless upgraded
Price: $5.99 per workload/month
Free plan: Free trial (14 days)
Website: zmanda.com
Best for: Flat per-workload pricing for mixed estates
Open virtualisation and OpenStack backup
Storware Backup and Recovery
Storware Backup and Recovery is the open-platform option for an HPC centre that runs more than VMware. It supports VMware, Hyper-V, XCP-ng, Citrix, Red Hat OpenShift, Red Hat Virtualization, Oracle Linux Virtualization Manager, Azure Stack, Nutanix AHV, Scale Computing, Verge.io, and multiple OpenStack distributions, with agentless backup through the hypervisor APIs. A centre that is moving from VMware to OpenStack can back up both under one licence and restore VMs directly into OpenStack. The licensing is flexible. Storware offers per-VM, per-host, per-CPU, or per-TB licensing, with perpetual or subscription models, and one licence covers all the platforms in the estate. That flexibility suits a centre whose mix of platforms changes over time, since the licence does not force a single billing model. The vendor also offers a 60-day free trial, which is longer than most rivals and gives a centre time to test a restore properly.
Pros:
- Covers 13 or more virtualisation platforms under one licence
- flexible per-VM, per-host, or per-TB licensing
Cons:
- No published list price
- smaller vendor with less third-party coverage than the largest rivals
Price: quote only
Free plan: Free trial (60 days)
Website: storware.eu
Best for: Open virtualisation and OpenStack backup
SaaS backup for cloud and on-premises workloads
HYCU
HYCU is the SaaS option for an HPC centre that wants backup without running a backup server. It protects SaaS applications, cloud workloads, and on-premises VMs and servers from a cloud console, with policy-based backup and point-in-time restore. A centre with a small operations team can set a policy once and let the service run, without patching or scaling a backup server of its own. The coverage is broad. HYCU backs up Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, Salesforce, and other SaaS apps, plus VMware, Nutanix, and cloud workloads on AWS and Azure. That breadth suits a centre whose research data is spread across a cluster, a cloud bucket, and a SaaS app, since one policy can cover all three. The restore is self-service for common cases, so a researcher can recover a deleted file without waiting for the operations team.
Pros:
- SaaS delivery with no backup server to run
- covers SaaS apps, cloud, and on-premises workloads
Cons:
- No published list price
- the per-user pricing for some modules is hard to compare with per-TB rivals
Price: quote only
Free plan: Free trial (14 days)
Website: hycu.com
Best for: SaaS backup for cloud and on-premises workloads
How we choose
How we choose
We compared vendor pricing pages, product docs, and feature lists for backup tools that fit HPC work, then kept the eight that cover the full range from a small research cluster to a large centre with tape archives. We checked the starting price on each vendor pricing page and used quote only where no public price is listed. We favoured tools with NAS and parallel file system cover, immutable backup copies, tape support, and pricing that scales with the estate, because those are the features that decide whether research data can be recovered after a failure. We did not test any product hands-on, and we did not rank tools by review scores. The order below follows the size of centre each tool fits best, from a small cluster up to a large research estate.
Buyers guide
Start with a count of what you actually protect. List every login node, compute node, storage head, NAS, and cloud account that holds research data, then add up the storage used. A centre that thinks it has 50 TB of data often finds 200 TB once scratch space and old project archives are counted. That total decides whether a per-workload plan or a per-TB plan costs less. Check the retention and the restore speed on the plan you would buy, not the top plan. A centre that needs a 10 TB dataset back in under four hours needs a local copy or a fast cloud restore, not a tape archive that takes a day to recall. Ask the vendor for a restore time for a dataset the size of your largest project. Test a restore before you commit. Pick a real dataset of at least 100 GB, delete a copy on a test node, and restore it from the backup. Time the restore and check that every file opens and the checksums match. A backup that restores slowly or skips files is worse than no backup, because it gives a false sense of safety. Confirm the tool covers your file system and your storage. Some tools cannot back up a parallel file system directly and need a NAS head or an agent on the storage node. Ask whether the tool supports your file system, your scheduler, and your tape library before you sign. Use the table below to match your centre size to a starting point, then confirm the price on the vendor page before you buy.
Frequently asked questions
How much backup storage does an HPC centre need?
A small research cluster with 20 nodes usually holds 10 to 20 TB of live data, while a large centre can hold 500 TB or more once scratch space and archives are counted. Count the live datasets, the scratch space, and the archives you still open, then add 50 percent for growth over two years. Tape is the cheapest medium for archives you rarely open.
Can backup software protect a parallel file system?
Some tools can back up a parallel file system directly, while others need a NAS head or an agent on the storage node. Veeam, NAKIVO, and Bacula Enterprise all document NAS and file-share backup, and MSP360 can back up a file share to cloud storage. Ask the vendor whether your file system is supported before you buy, and test a backup of a real dataset.
Is tape still useful for HPC backup?
Yes, for long-term archives that are rarely opened. Tape costs far less per TB than disk or cloud for cold data, and a tape copy stored offsite covers fire, flood, and ransomware. Bacula Enterprise supports tape natively, while cloud-first tools like Zmanda Pro do not, so a centre that needs tape should check that feature first.
What is the 3-2-1 backup rule for HPC centres?
The rule keeps three copies of research data on two different media types, with one copy offsite. For a centre, that usually means the live data on the cluster storage, a copy on disk or cloud, and a copy on tape or in a second site. If one copy fails, two remain, and the offsite copy covers fire, flood, and theft.
How often should an HPC centre test a restore?
Test a restore every quarter at minimum, and after any change to the backup setup. Pick a different dataset each time, restore it to a test node, and check the file checksums to confirm the data is intact. A yearly test is too rare, since a broken backup job can run unnoticed for months.
How long does a full restore take for a large dataset?
A 10 TB dataset restores in about 4 hours over a 10 Gbps link if the storage can keep up, and in about 28 hours over a 1 Gbps link. Tape recall adds hours or days depending on the library. Ask the vendor for a restore time for a dataset the size of your largest project, and test it before you commit.