Researched comparison

Best Tape Backup Software for Small Business

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Veeam Backup and Replication is the top pick for most small businesses with tape because it writes native tape backups with GFS retention, manages tape libraries without extra modules, and restores single files or machines from tape. Firms that want the lowest cost should look at Bareos, and firms that want a simple tape tool should look at NovaBACKUP.

Key takeaways

  • Tape is still the cheapest way to keep years of backups offline, because LTO cartridges cost far less per TB than disk or cloud.
  • Veeam is the top pick for tape because native tape support, GFS retention, and library management are built in.
  • NovaBACKUP Server at 399.95 dollars per year is the cheapest listed commercial tape tool in this comparison.
  • Commvault, Veritas Backup Exec, Arcserve, and Bacula Enterprise publish no list price, so budget them only after a written quote.
  • Free tools such as Bareos and Amanda handle tape well, but they need a technical admin to configure and monitor.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Veeam Backup and ReplicationNative tape backup with GFS retentionquote onlyFree trial (30 days)
CommvaultEnterprise tape libraries and deduplication$90 per TB per monthFree trial (30 days)
Veritas Backup ExecTape backup for Windows serversquote onlyFree trial (60 days)
Arcserve UDPTape plus image backup for SMB serversquote onlyFree trial (30 days)
NovaBACKUPSimple low-cost tape backup$399.95 per yearFree trial (14 days)
RetrospectTape backup for small offices$49 one-time licenceFree trial (30 days)
Bacula EnterpriseTape libraries at scalequote onlyNo
BareosFree open-source tape backup$0Yes
AmandaFree tape changer backup$0Yes

Ranked by tier

1

native tape backup with GFS retention

Veeam Backup and Replication

Veeam Backup and Replication writes backups directly to tape with grand-father-father-son retention, manages tape libraries and standalone drives without extra modules, and catalogues tape contents so a single file can be found and restored years later. It backs up VMware and Hyper-V virtual machines, physical servers, NAS file shares, and cloud workloads, and it can stage a backup on disk for fast restores before copying it to tape for long-term storage.

The vendor publishes no list prices on its current pricing page, so a small business must request a quote, and the sales process is heavier than the self-serve signup cheaper tools offer. The platform also needs a Windows or Linux backup server to run on, which adds a machine to maintain, and the feature set is far larger than a five-person firm needs.

Pros:

  • native tape support with GFS retention and library management built in
  • instant VM recovery from disk or tape

Cons:

  • no public list price, and the platform needs a backup server to run on

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: veeam.com

Best for: native tape backup with GFS retention

2

enterprise tape libraries and deduplication

Commvault

Commvault backs up servers, virtual machines, databases, and cloud workloads to tape with deduplication and compression that cut the number of cartridges needed, and it manages tape libraries across more than one site from a single console. It tracks every tape, every copy, and every retention rule, so an auditor can trace a file from a server to a cartridge and back.

The limit is cost and weight: 90 dollars per TB per month adds up quickly for a firm with 10 TB of data, and the platform needs trained staff to configure libraries, media pools, and retention policies correctly. It is built for firms with strict compliance duties and large tape libraries, not for a five-person office with one tape drive.

Pros:

  • deduplication and compression cut tape use sharply
  • manages large tape libraries across sites

Cons:

  • per-TB pricing gets expensive fast, and the platform is heavy for a very small team

Price: $90 per TB per month

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: commvault.com

Best for: enterprise tape libraries and deduplication

3

tape backup for Windows servers

Veritas Backup Exec

Veritas Backup Exec backs up Windows servers, virtual machines, and applications to tape, disk, and cloud, with support for LTO drives, tape libraries, and autoloaders that small businesses actually buy. It offers granular restore for Exchange, SQL Server, and Active Directory, deduplication to cut tape use, and bare-metal recovery for failed servers. The interface is built for Windows admins, and the 60-day trial is the longest in this comparison, which gives a team time to test tape jobs properly.

The vendor publishes no list price, so a small business must request a quote before it can budget, and third-party listings vary widely, so they should not be used for planning. Backup Exec is Windows focused, so a firm with Linux servers needs a second tool or a different product. It is a good fit for a Windows-only small business that wants a proven tape tool with a long track record and a simple console.

Pros:

  • long history with tape drives and libraries
  • simple interface for Windows server backup

Cons:

  • no public list price, and the product is Windows focused

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (60 days)

Website: veritas.com

Best for: tape backup for Windows servers

4

tape plus image backup for SMB servers

Arcserve UDP

Arcserve Unified Data Protection backs up Windows and Linux servers, virtual machines, and cloud workloads with image-based backup, and it can copy backup images to tape for long-term offline storage. Its assured recovery feature boots a backup image in a test environment to prove it works, which catches corrupt backups before a real disaster. Arcserve also sells appliances that combine the software with hardware, which suits a firm that wants one box to buy and one vendor to call.

The vendor publishes no list price, so a small business must request a quote, and the sales process is heavier than the self-serve signup cheaper tools offer. The console is less polished than Veeam, and documentation is thinner, so a team without IT staff may need help at setup. For a small business that wants image backup plus tape in one product, Arcserve is a solid mid-range option that is simpler than Commvault.

Pros:

  • image-based backup with tape copy and assured recovery testing
  • simple appliance option

Cons:

  • no public list price, and the console is less polished than Veeam

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: arcserve.com

Best for: tape plus image backup for SMB servers

5

simple low-cost tape backup

NovaBACKUP

NovaBACKUP Server backs up Windows servers to tape drives and libraries, local disk, and the cloud, with a simple interface that a small business owner can learn in an afternoon. The Server Agent lists at 399.95 dollars per year and includes 250 GB of cloud storage, which is the cheapest listed commercial tape price in this comparison. Backups are scheduled and incremental, restores are granular to a single file, and the product includes setup help plus one year of support and upgrade protection.

The limit is scale: the included cloud storage is only 250 GB, so a firm with large data needs a bigger plan or a separate cloud account, and the interface is simpler than Veeam or Commvault, so advanced features such as deduplication and multi-site library management are thinner. Support is ticket based, and response times are slower than phone support.

Pros:

  • cheapest listed commercial tape tool here
  • supports tape drives and libraries with a simple interface

Cons:

  • cloud storage is limited to 250 GB on the Server plan, and support is ticket based

Price: $399.95 per year

Free plan: Free trial (14 days)

Website: novabackup.com

Best for: simple low-cost tape backup

6

tape backup for small offices

Retrospect

Retrospect backs up Windows, Mac, and Linux computers to tape drives, disk, and cloud storage, with ransomware protection, disaster recovery, and support for more than 20 cloud providers. The Solo edition lists at 49 dollars for a one-time licence covering one computer, which is the cheapest entry price in this comparison, and the Desktop edition covers five networked clients for 169 dollars.

The limit is that tape libraries and larger environments need the Desktop or Server editions, so the 49-dollar Solo price does not buy library support, and the interface looks dated next to Veeam or Acronis. The perpetual licence is a plus for firms that dislike subscriptions, but the annual support and maintenance fee is extra if the firm wants updates and help.

Pros:

  • perpetual licence with no subscription
  • supports tape drives, disk, and cloud from one console

Cons:

  • tape libraries need the higher Desktop or Server editions, and the interface looks dated

Price: $49 one-time licence

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: retrospect.com

Best for: tape backup for small offices

7

tape libraries at scale

Bacula Enterprise

Bacula Enterprise backs up Windows, Linux, and Mac systems, virtual machines, and databases to tape libraries, disk, and cloud, with support for autochangers, barcode tracking, and multi-site tape management. It offers deduplication, encryption, and granular restore, and it is built for firms that run many tape drives across more than one site. The enterprise edition adds a graphical console, professional support, and certified plugins that the free community edition does not include.

The vendor publishes no list price, so a small business must request a quote, and the sales process is aimed at larger firms, which can make a small quote slow to arrive. There is no self-serve free plan for the enterprise edition, though the community edition is free and open source. For a small business with one tape drive, Bacula Enterprise is more than needed, but for a firm with a real tape library it is a proven choice.

Pros:

  • built for large tape libraries with autochangers
  • strong deduplication and multi-site support

Cons:

  • quote-only pricing, and the community edition needs technical skill to run

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: baculasystems.com

Best for: tape libraries at scale

8

free open-source tape backup

Bareos

Bareos is a free open-source backup tool forked from Bacula, and it backs up Windows, Linux, and Mac systems to tape libraries, disk, and cloud storage, with a web console for managing jobs, media, and restores. It supports autochangers, barcode labels, deduplication, and encryption, and it can run backup jobs across more than one site. Because it is free, it suits a technical owner who wants enterprise tape features without a license fee, and the code is openly available to inspect.

The limit is support: there is no vendor help without a commercial subscription, so a failed restore is the admin problem to solve, and setup needs real technical skill, including configuring tape devices and storage daemons by hand. Documentation is good but assumes backup knowledge, so a first-time admin should expect a learning curve. For a firm with a technical owner and a tape library, Bareos is the strongest free option.

Pros:

  • free and open source
  • full tape library and autochanger support with a web console

Cons:

  • no vendor support without a commercial subscription, and setup needs technical skill

Price: $0

Free plan: Yes

Website: bareos.com

Best for: free open-source tape backup

9

free tape changer backup

Amanda

Amanda, from Zmanda, is a free open-source backup tool that backs up Windows, Linux, and Mac clients to tape changers, disk, and cloud storage, with a scheduler that spreads backup load across the night so no single job runs too long. It supports tape rotation, labelling, and verification, and it has protected servers in universities and small businesses for decades.

The limit is the interface: Amanda is configured through text files, with no modern graphical console in the free edition, and the learning curve is steep for a first-time admin. There is no vendor support without the commercial Zmanda edition, and restores need command-line work. For a technical owner who wants a simple, proven tape backup tool and does not mind text configuration, Amanda is a reliable free choice.

Pros:

  • free and open source
  • built-in tape changer support and scheduling across many clients

Cons:

  • command line configuration, with no modern graphical console in the free edition

Price: $0

Free plan: Yes

Website: zmanda.com

Best for: free tape changer backup

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and feature lists for tools that write backups to tape, and we checked what each tool restores, which tape hardware it supports, and what it charges. We favoured tools with native tape support, library management, and a published price, and we noted where a vendor hides its price instead of guessing a figure.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Check that the tool supports your tape drive or library model, because not every product works with every autoloader. Check restore speed: tape restores are slow, so confirm the tool can stage a recent backup on disk for fast recovery. Check retention: confirm GFS rotation and off-site vaulting are included, not extra modules. Check media costs: LTO cartridges, cleaning tapes, and drive maintenance add to the software price.

Frequently asked questions

Is tape backup still worth it for a small business?

Yes, tape is still the cheapest way to keep years of backups offline, because LTO cartridges cost far less per TB than disk or cloud, and a tape sitting on a shelf cannot be encrypted by ransomware. Tape is slow to restore, so it suits long-term archive and disaster recovery rather than daily restores.

How long do LTO tapes last?

LTO tape makers rate cartridges for 30 years of archival storage when kept cool, dry, and away from magnets, and most firms plan on 10 to 15 years in practice. The risk is not the tape wearing out but the drive becoming obsolete, because an LTO-9 drive cannot read tapes older than two generations back.

What is GFS retention in tape backup?

GFS stands for grand-father-father-son, and it is a rotation scheme that keeps daily backups for a week, weekly backups for a month, and monthly backups for a year or longer. It gives a firm many restore points without keeping every daily tape forever.

Can I restore a single file from tape?

Yes, every managed tool in this article catalogues tape contents, so an admin can search for one file and restore it without reading the whole tape. The restore is slower than disk because the tape must load and seek to the right spot, so a single file can take minutes rather than seconds.

How many tapes does a small business need?

A firm with 2 TB of data needs at least 4 to 6 LTO tapes for a basic rotation, because each tape holds about 12 TB native on LTO-9 but the firm needs separate tapes for daily, weekly, and monthly sets plus spares.

What is LTFS and do I need it?

LTFS, or Linear Tape File System, lets a tape appear as a disk drive so files can be dragged onto it like a USB stick, and it is free and open. It is useful for moving large files between sites, but it is not a backup tool on its own because it has no scheduling, versioning, or catalog.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides