Researched comparison
Best Attack Surface Management Software for Business
Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.
Censys is the top pick for most teams that need attack surface management, because it scans the whole internet and shows every exposed asset, certificate, and service tied to your organisation. UpGuard Breach Risk is the better buy for small teams, starting at $1,667 per month billed annually with vendor risk included.
Key takeaways
- Attack surface management finds everything internet-facing that belongs to your organisation, from domains and subdomains to open ports, expired certificates, and leaked credentials.
- The market splits in two: scanning tools such as Censys and Shodan show you raw exposure, while ratings platforms such as SecurityScorecard, BitSight, and RiskRecon turn that exposure into a score you can track and share.
- UpGuard is the only vendor here with a published starting price for its attack surface product, at $1,667 per month billed annually for Breach Risk, and the rest are quote only.
- A free tier or free account exists at Shodan and UpGuard, which lets a small team start mapping exposure before spending.
- Before you sign, confirm how often scans run, whether remediation workflows are included, and how the platform handles assets you do not recognise.
Contents
Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.
Comparison at a glance
Comparison
| Tool | Best for | Price range | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Censys | Internet-wide asset discovery and exposure | quote only | No |
| UpGuard Breach Risk | Small teams wanting ASM plus vendor risk | $1,667 per month | Yes |
| SecurityScorecard | Security ratings for third parties and self | quote only | No |
| BitSight | Enterprise security ratings and benchmarking | quote only | No |
| RiskRecon | Vendor risk ratings from Mastercard | quote only | No |
| Palo Alto Cortex Xpanse | Large estates with attack surface and response | quote only | No |
| Shodan | Raw internet exposure search for technical teams | quote only | Yes |
Ranked by tier
internet-wide asset discovery and exposure
Censys
Censys is the deepest discovery tool in this comparison, and it is the top pick for teams that want to know what is actually exposed. The platform scans the public internet continuously, collecting data on hosts, certificates, services, and software versions, and it ties that data back to organisations so a team can see every asset that carries its name, including the ones nobody in IT remembers buying. Forgotten subdomains, test servers, and cloud buckets show up in the same inventory as production systems, which is where most external breaches start.
The data quality is the reason security teams choose it. Certificate transparency logs, banner data, and service fingerprints let a team confirm whether a port is really open, which software version is running, and whether a certificate has expired, instead of relying on a guessed inventory. That evidence feeds remediation directly: an engineer gets a specific host, a specific service, and a specific fix, rather than a generic warning.
What Censys does not cover is the packaged answer. There is no published list price, no free tier, and the platform returns data rather than a verdict, so a team needs the skill and the time to turn findings into fixes. A ratings platform is simpler for a team that wants a score to share with a board or a customer. For a security team that wants the fullest possible picture of its external exposure, though, no other tool here scans as widely or as often.
Pros:
- scans the whole internet continuously
- rich host and certificate data
Cons:
- pricing only by quote
- raw data needs a team to turn it into action
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: censys.com
Best for: internet-wide asset discovery and exposure
small teams wanting ASM plus vendor risk
UpGuard Breach Risk
UpGuard Breach Risk is the most accessible attack surface product in this comparison, and it is the only one with a published starting price. Breach Risk starts at $1,667 per month billed annually, and the wider Vendor Risk platform starts at $1,750 per month, with a free tier that covers up to five vendors. That transparency matters for a small team: it can budget the purchase, try the free tier, and know what the first year costs before a sales call. A 14-day free trial is available on the lower tiers.
The product continuously maps an organisation's external attack surface, scanning domains, IP addresses, exposed services, and email security settings, and it turns findings into a risk rating that a team can track over time. Because it sits inside the UpGuard platform, the same intelligence also powers vendor risk monitoring, so a team can watch its own exposure and its suppliers' exposure from one console.
What UpGuard does not cover is the depth of a dedicated scanning platform. Its discovery is narrower than Censys, and the higher tiers, Professional, Corporate, and Enterprise, are priced by quote, so a large programme still ends in a sales process. The platform is strongest for mid-market teams that need attack surface visibility and vendor risk together. For a team that only needs deep internet scanning, Censys sees more. For a small team that needs both, UpGuard is the practical buy.
Pros:
- published pricing from $1,667 per month
- free tier for up to 5 vendors
Cons:
- ASM is one module in a wider vendor risk platform
- higher tiers need a quote
Price: $1,667 per month (billed annually)
Free plan: Yes
Website: upguard.com
Best for: small teams wanting ASM plus vendor risk
security ratings for third parties and self
SecurityScorecard
SecurityScorecard is the best-known security ratings platform, and it is the pick when the audience for the result is outside the security team. The platform scans an organisation's internet-facing footprint and turns the findings into a letter-grade rating across factors such as network security, DNS health, patching cadence, and endpoint security. That rating is a shared language: a procurement team can compare vendors, a board can track a trend, and a customer can ask for a score without reading a technical report.
Continuous monitoring is the other strength. Ratings update as new findings appear, and the platform alerts the team when a score drops or a new risk emerges, such as an exposed service or a leaked credential. The same view covers the organisation itself and its vendors, so a team can watch third-party risk in the same place it watches its own.
What SecurityScorecard does not cover is raw scanning depth. A rating is a summary, and a team that wants the full host and certificate data behind the score will need a scanning tool as well. Pricing is by quote only, and the platform is priced for enterprise and mid-market teams. For a team that must report third-party risk to a board, a regulator, or a customer, the rating model is the point. For a team that only needs to find its own exposed assets, a scanner is more direct.
Pros:
- widely recognised security ratings
- continuous monitoring of vendors and self
Cons:
- pricing only by quote
- ratings are a summary, not a full scan
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: securityscorecard.com
Best for: security ratings for third parties and self
enterprise security ratings and benchmarking
BitSight
BitSight is the enterprise counterpart to SecurityScorecard, with a large ratings dataset and a strong position in insurance and finance. The platform rates organisations on externally observable security performance, covering botnet infections, spam propagation, patching, and configuration, and it benchmarks each rating against peers in the same sector. That benchmarking is the reason insurers and large enterprises use it: a rating gains meaning when it can be compared with the sector average and tracked over time.
The platform also supports third-party risk management at scale, with continuous monitoring of thousands of vendors and workflows for questionnaires, remediation, and reporting. Cyber insurance underwriting is a major use case, since underwriters use the ratings to price risk. The data is gathered externally, so a vendor needs no agent and no integration to be rated.
What BitSight does not cover is the hands-on fix. A rating shows where a team stands, but turning that into a remediation plan needs the raw findings behind it, and the platform is less direct than a scanner for that work. Pricing is by quote only, and the platform is aimed at enterprise buyers. For a large organisation that must benchmark itself, manage vendors at scale, or answer an insurer, it is a strong choice. For a small team that needs to find exposed assets, it is more than required.
Pros:
- large ratings dataset with benchmarking
- strong in insurance and finance
Cons:
- pricing only by quote
- ratings need context to act on
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: bitsight.com
Best for: enterprise security ratings and benchmarking
vendor risk ratings from Mastercard
RiskRecon
RiskRecon, part of Mastercard, is built for teams that manage risk across a large vendor portfolio. The platform continuously assesses the security posture of third parties from externally observable data, covering domains, certificates, patching, and known vulnerabilities, and it prioritises findings by risk so a team can focus on the vendors that matter most. The Mastercard backing brings a large dataset and a long view of vendor behaviour, which suits financial services teams that already work inside the Mastercard ecosystem.
The workflow is the strength. RiskRecon does not just produce a score: it maps findings to vendors, tracks remediation over time, and lets a team compare a vendor against its peers. Custom risk criteria let a team weight the factors that matter to its own regulators and customers.
What RiskRecon does not cover is deep self-monitoring. The platform is aimed at vendor risk first, and a team that wants to map its own attack surface in detail will find the self view thinner than a dedicated scanner. Pricing is by quote only, and there is no free tier. For a team whose main attack surface problem is its suppliers, it is a strong fit. For a team whose main problem is its own forgotten assets, start with a scanner.
Pros:
- Mastercard backing with large vendor dataset
- risk-prioritised findings
Cons:
- pricing only by quote
- self-monitoring is secondary to vendor ratings
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: riskrecon.com
Best for: vendor risk ratings from Mastercard
large estates with attack surface and response
Palo Alto Cortex Xpanse
Cortex Xpanse is Palo Alto Networks attack surface management product, and it is the pick for large estates that want discovery tied directly to response. The platform maps the external attack surface continuously, finding unknown assets, misconfigurations, and exposures, and it connects those findings to the Cortex XSOAR automation layer, so a risky exposure can trigger a response workflow without waiting for a manual ticket. That link from discovery to action is what separates it from the ratings platforms, which show a score but leave the fix to the team.
The discovery engine is built for scale. It handles large and changing estates, including cloud assets that appear and disappear quickly, and it attributes assets to business units so the right team gets the finding.
What Cortex Xpanse does not cover is the standalone buyer. Pricing is by quote only, and the full value depends on the Cortex platform, so a team that does not run Palo Alto gets only part of the benefit. Deployment and tuning need Palo Alto expertise, and small teams will find the platform more than they need. For an enterprise already standardised on Palo Alto, it is a natural fit. For anyone else, the platform commitment is the price of entry.
Pros:
- attack surface discovery tied to Cortex response
- strong automation
Cons:
- pricing only by quote
- full value needs the Cortex platform
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: paloaltonetworks.com
Best for: large estates with attack surface and response
raw internet exposure search for technical teams
Shodan
Shodan is the search engine for the internet of things and exposed services, and it is the most direct tool in this comparison for a technical team. A free account lets anyone search for exposed devices, open ports, and banners across the internet, and the results show exactly what an attacker would see: which services are listening, which software versions are running, and which devices have default credentials. For a team that wants to check its own exposure quickly, that directness is hard to beat.
The data covers industrial control systems, cameras, databases, and servers, which makes Shodan useful beyond the usual web estate. A team can monitor its own IP ranges for new exposures, track specific services, and set alerts when something changes.
What Shodan does not cover is the managed answer. There is no remediation workflow, no vendor risk module, and no rating to share with a board, so a team must turn raw results into action itself. Enterprise features, including larger API access and monitoring, are priced by quote. For a technical team that wants the rawest possible view of exposure at no cost, it is the place to start. For a team that needs reporting and workflows, the managed platforms here are a better fit.
Pros:
- free account for basic searches
- the rawest view of internet exposure
Cons:
- no managed remediation workflow
- enterprise features need a quote
Price: quote only
Free plan: Yes
Website: shodan.io
Best for: raw internet exposure search for technical teams
How we choose
How we choose
We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and feature lists for each tool, checking how often scans run, how findings are prioritised, and whether remediation workflows are included. We treated published list prices as the only prices we would state as fact, and marked everything else as quote only. UpGuard is the only vendor here that publishes a starting price for its attack surface product. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not count review counts or analyst scores.
Buyers guide
- Confirm how often scans run and how quickly new assets appear in the inventory, since a weekly scan misses short-lived cloud assets.
- Ask how the platform attributes assets you do not recognise.
- Check whether remediation workflows, ticketing, and retesting are included or licensed separately.
- Ask how the quote scales as you add domains, IP ranges, and vendors.
- Confirm what happens to scan history and findings if you leave, and whether export is included.
- Run a pilot against your own domains and one vendor portfolio before signing, and measure false positives for at least two weeks.
Frequently asked questions
What is attack surface management?
Attack surface management is the continuous discovery, inventory, and monitoring of everything internet-facing that belongs to your organisation. It finds domains, subdomains, IP addresses, open ports, certificates, and cloud assets, including the ones nobody in IT remembers, and it flags exposures such as unpatched services, misconfigurations, and leaked credentials before an attacker finds them.
How is attack surface management different from vulnerability scanning?
Vulnerability scanning tests known systems for known flaws, while attack surface management first finds the systems themselves, including unknown and forgotten assets. A vulnerability scanner can only test what you tell it about, so attack surface management answers the earlier question: what do we actually have exposed to the internet, and what has changed since last week.
Do small businesses need attack surface management?
A small business with a handful of domains can start with a free Shodan account or the UpGuard free tier and get a real picture of its exposure in an afternoon. A managed platform becomes worth the cost when the estate grows across cloud accounts and subdomains, or when a customer or regulator asks for evidence of continuous external monitoring.
What is a security rating?
A security rating is a score, usually a letter grade or a number, that summarises an organisation's externally observable security posture. Ratings platforms such as SecurityScorecard and BitSight calculate it from factors such as patching, DNS health, and botnet activity, and the score is used to compare vendors, benchmark against peers, and report risk to boards and insurers.
How much does attack surface management cost?
Published prices in this comparison start with a free account at Shodan and a free tier at UpGuard, with UpGuard Breach Risk starting at $1,667 per month billed annually. The other platforms are quote only, and enterprise attack surface management typically runs into five figures a year, depending on the size of the estate and the number of vendors monitored.
Can attack surface management find cloud assets?
Yes, the better platforms discover cloud assets as they appear, including storage buckets, virtual machines, and serverless endpoints, and they track changes over time. The key question to ask is how often the scan runs, since a weekly scan can miss a short-lived test server that an attacker finds within hours of it appearing.