Researched comparison

Best Breach and Attack Simulation Software for SMBs

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Picus Security is the top pick for small businesses because it runs continuous breach and attack simulation against MITRE ATT&CK techniques, gives clear remediation guidance, and offers a free trial. It gives a small team a way to prove whether its security controls work, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $30,000 per year, below the other platforms here.

Key takeaways

  • Breach and attack simulation replays real attacker techniques in a safe way, so a firm can learn whether its controls detect and block them before a real attack.
  • Picus, Cymulate, AttackIQ, SafeBreach, Pentera, Horizon3.ai NodeZero, and XM Cyber are all quote only, so a small business should expect a sales process and an enterprise-level contract.
  • OpenAEV, MITRE Caldera, and Infection Monkey are free and open source, which makes them realistic choices for a small business with no BAS budget.
  • A simulation tool tests controls, it does not replace a human penetration test, so a firm should still run a manual test each year.
  • A tool works best when it connects to the SIEM and the ticketing system, so findings turn into fixes instead of unread reports.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Picus SecuritySmall teams that need continuous control validationQuote onlyFree trial
CymulateSmall teams that need validation across many vectorsQuote onlyFree trial
AttackIQSmall teams that need ATT&CK coverage reportingQuote onlyNo
SafeBreachSmall teams that need a large attack playbookQuote onlyNo
PenteraSmall teams that need autonomous penetration testingQuote onlyNo
Horizon3.ai NodeZeroSmall teams that need autonomous pentestingQuote onlyNo
XM CyberSmall teams that need attack path mappingQuote onlyNo
OpenAEVSmall teams that need free attack simulationFree community editionYes, free community edition
MITRE CalderaSmall teams that need free adversary emulationFree open sourceYes, free open source
Infection MonkeySmall teams that need free breach simulationFree open sourceYes, free open source

Ranked by tier

1

Small teams that need continuous control validation

Picus Security

Picus Security runs continuous breach and attack simulations that test whether firewalls, endpoint tools, and email controls actually detect and block real attacker techniques. The platform maps results to MITRE ATT&CK, shows which controls failed, and gives mitigation guidance a small team can follow without a large security staff.

The limits are real. Picus does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $30,000 per year, which is a large line item for a small business. A free trial lets a team test the platform, but the tool still needs a security owner who reads the results and fixes what fails. For a small business that can fund a commercial BAS platform, Picus is the most accessible choice in this list.

Pros:

  • Continuous validation against MITRE ATT&CK
  • clear remediation guidance
  • strong detection-engineering integrations

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • enterprise-level cost
  • needs a security owner to act on results

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial

Website: picussecurity.com

Best for: Small teams that need continuous control validation

2

Small teams that need validation across many vectors

Cymulate

Cymulate runs continuous security validation across the full attack kill chain, including email, web gateway, endpoint, and data exfiltration, so a small team can see which vector an attacker would use first. The platform includes breach and attack simulation, attack surface checks, and exposure validation in one console. A free trial lets a team test the simulations before it talks to sales.

The limits are real. Cymulate does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $7,000 per month for up to 1,000 endpoints, which is far beyond most small business budgets. The platform is also complex, with many modules that need setup before the results become useful. For a small business that wants broad vector coverage and can fund it, Cymulate is a strong choice.

Pros:

  • Validates email, web, endpoint, and data exfiltration vectors
  • continuous assessments
  • strong reporting

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • high entry cost
  • complex for a very small team

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial

Website: cymulate.com

Best for: Small teams that need validation across many vectors

3

Small teams that need ATT&CK coverage reporting

AttackIQ

AttackIQ validates security controls by running attack emulations mapped to MITRE ATT&CK, and it reports coverage gaps in a way a small team can explain to leadership. The platform offers Flex for on-demand testing, Ready for managed testing, and Enterprise for full control, so a team can choose how much it runs itself.

The limits are real. AttackIQ does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $40,000 per year, which is a large commitment for a small business. The platform also needs staff time, because someone must run the exercises, read the coverage reports, and fix the gaps. For a small business that wants ATT&CK coverage reporting and can fund it, AttackIQ is a solid choice.

Pros:

  • Strong MITRE ATT&CK coverage reporting
  • purple team exercises
  • flexible deployment options

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • high entry cost
  • needs staff time to run exercises

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: attackiq.com

Best for: Small teams that need ATT&CK coverage reporting

4

Small teams that need a large attack playbook

SafeBreach

SafeBreach runs automated attack simulations from a playbook of more than 30,000 curated scenarios mapped to MITRE ATT&CK, using a SaaS console with on-prem simulators. The platform covers hybrid environments, integrates tightly with SIEM tools, and prioritizes remediation by business risk. It also supports continuous validation, so controls are tested again after each fix.

The limits are real. SafeBreach does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $50,000 per year, which is the highest in this list. The platform is built for enterprise buyers, so a small business should expect a long sales process and a contract that may not fit a small budget. For a firm that needs the largest attack playbook, SafeBreach is a strong option.

Pros:

  • Large playbook of over 30,000 attack scenarios
  • strong SIEM integrations
  • hybrid simulation modes

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • high entry cost
  • enterprise focus

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: safebreach.com

Best for: Small teams that need a large attack playbook

5

Small teams that need autonomous penetration testing

Pentera

Pentera runs autonomous penetration tests that safely exploit real attack paths, including credential theft, lateral movement, and privilege escalation, then shows exactly how an attacker would reach critical assets. The platform suits small teams that want proof of exploitability, not just a list of possible flaws. It also gives remediation steps in priority order, so a small team can fix the most dangerous path first.

The limits are real. Pentera does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its entry cost near $100,000 per year, which is far beyond most small business budgets. The tests also run against live systems, so a team needs change control and a maintenance window before it starts. For a firm that needs autonomous pentesting and can fund it, Pentera is a strong option.

Pros:

  • Autonomous penetration testing
  • exploits real paths
  • clear remediation steps

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • high entry cost
  • needs change control for live tests

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: pentera.io

Best for: Small teams that need autonomous penetration testing

6

Small teams that need autonomous pentesting

Horizon3.ai NodeZero

Horizon3.ai NodeZero is an autonomous penetration testing platform that finds and safely exploits attack paths in a network, then reports the findings with proof of each exploit. The platform sets up fast compared with a manual test, and it runs on a schedule, so a small team can test after every major change instead of once a year. The reports show the exact path an attacker would take.

The limits are real. NodeZero does not publish a list price, and third-party guides put its cost in the mid-market range, well above the free tools in this list. The platform also needs staff to fix what it finds, because a report alone does not close a path. For a small business that wants autonomous pentesting without a full BAS suite, NodeZero is a solid choice.

Pros:

  • Autonomous pentesting with proof of exploit
  • fast setup
  • clear attack path reports

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • mid-market pricing
  • needs staff to fix findings

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: horizon3.ai

Best for: Small teams that need autonomous pentesting

7

Small teams that need attack path mapping

XM Cyber

XM Cyber graphs attack paths from a breach point to critical assets, which shows a small team which combinations of flaws an attacker would chain together. The platform covers hybrid environments, including on-prem, cloud, and identity systems, and it prioritizes fixes by how much risk each one removes.

The limits are real. XM Cyber does not publish a list price, and the yearly license is based on network size, so a firm must go through sales to learn the cost. The platform is built for enterprise buyers, so a small business should expect a quote process and ask what the entry tier includes. For a firm that needs attack path mapping, XM Cyber is a solid choice.

Pros:

  • Attack path graphing from breach point to critical assets
  • strong prioritization
  • hybrid coverage

Cons:

  • Quote only, with no published price
  • enterprise focus
  • yearly license based on network size

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: xmcyber.com

Best for: Small teams that need attack path mapping

8

Small teams that need free attack simulation

OpenAEV

OpenAEV combines attack simulation, exposure tracking, and crisis exercises in one platform, and its community edition is free, which makes it the most capable free BAS option in this list. The platform runs attack simulations, tracks exposure over time, and supports crisis exercises. The Enterprise edition is quote only and adds support and extra features.

The limits are real. The community edition is self-hosted, so a small team needs a server and time to set it up, and the community is smaller than the ones behind Caldera or the commercial platforms. A team should also check which attack techniques the community edition covers, because some features need the Enterprise edition. For a small business that wants free attack simulation, OpenAEV is a strong choice.

Pros:

  • Free community edition
  • attack simulation plus exposure tracking
  • crisis exercise support

Cons:

  • Enterprise edition is quote only
  • smaller community than the big platforms
  • self-hosted setup

Price: Free community edition

Free plan: Yes, free community edition

Website: openaev.com

Best for: Small teams that need free attack simulation

9

Small teams that need free adversary emulation

MITRE Caldera

MITRE Caldera is a free, open source adversary emulation platform built by MITRE, the organization behind the ATT&CK framework. The platform runs automated red team operations that emulate real adversaries, and it is flexible enough for a skilled technician to build custom attack chains. It costs nothing to download.

The limits are real. Caldera needs technical skill to install, configure, and run, and there is no vendor support when something breaks. The reporting is basic compared with the commercial platforms, so a team must build its own reports for leadership. For a small business with a skilled technician and no budget for BAS, Caldera is a strong choice.

Pros:

  • Free and open source
  • built by MITRE
  • flexible adversary emulation

Cons:

  • Needs technical skill to run
  • no vendor support
  • reporting is basic

Price: Free open source

Free plan: Yes, free open source

Website: caldera.mitre.org

Best for: Small teams that need free adversary emulation

10

Small teams that need free breach simulation

Infection Monkey

Infection Monkey is a free, open source breach and attack simulation tool that tests whether malware can spread through a network by simulating an infection. The tool maps how far an infection would travel, shows which machines are reachable, and produces a clear report a small team can read. It is simple to run.

The limits are real. Infection Monkey covers fewer attack techniques than the commercial platforms, and there is no vendor support, so a team must rely on community help when something breaks. The reporting is basic, and the tool does not test email or web vectors the way Cymulate does. For a small business that wants a free first test of lateral movement, Infection Monkey is a solid choice.

Pros:

  • Free and open source
  • simple breach simulation
  • clear infection maps

Cons:

  • Limited attack techniques
  • no vendor support
  • basic reporting

Price: Free open source

Free plan: Yes, free open source

Website: infectionmonkey.com

Best for: Small teams that need free breach simulation

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and feature lists for ten breach and attack simulation tools that fit small business use. We checked whether each tool runs real attack techniques, maps results to MITRE ATT&CK, publishes its price, gives remediation guidance, and connects to a SIEM. We did not test any tool hands-on, and we did not count vendor marketing claims as evidence. Where a vendor hides its price, we say quote only and name the third-party guide figure where one exists.

Our full method

Buyers guide

  • Confirm the price in writing, because every commercial tool in this list is quote only and the guide figures are third-party estimates, not vendor prices.
  • Check which attack vectors are covered, because some tools test email and web while others only test endpoints.
  • Ask how simulations run in production, since a safe simulation must not break live systems or lock out real users.
  • Confirm the MITRE ATT&CK coverage, because a tool that only tests a few techniques leaves gaps a real attacker can use.
  • Start with a free tool such as OpenAEV or Caldera if the budget is zero, and move to a commercial platform when the team can fund it.

Frequently asked questions

What is breach and attack simulation?

Breach and attack simulation, or BAS, runs safe, automated attacks against a firm own systems to test whether its security controls detect and block them. The simulations use real attacker techniques mapped to MITRE ATT&CK, such as phishing, credential theft, and lateral movement. A firm that runs BAS learns which controls fail before a real attacker finds the same gap.

How is BAS different from a penetration test?

A penetration test is a manual, point-in-time exercise run by a human tester, while BAS is automated and continuous, so it can run every week instead of once a year. BAS tests whether controls work, while a penetration test also finds new flaws a scanner would miss.

How much does breach and attack simulation cost for a small business?

The commercial platforms are quote only, and third-party guides put Picus near $30,000 per year, AttackIQ near $40,000 per year, SafeBreach near $50,000 per year, and Cymulate near $7,000 per month. Pentera guides put its cost near $100,000 per year. A small business with no budget can start with OpenAEV, MITRE Caldera, or Infection Monkey, which are free.

Are there free breach and attack simulation tools?

Yes. OpenAEV has a free community edition, MITRE Caldera is free and open source, and Infection Monkey is free and open source. These tools need technical skill to run, and their reporting is basic compared with the commercial platforms, but they let a small business test its controls without spending anything. A team should start with one of them if the budget is zero.

How often should a small business run attack simulations?

A small business should run simulations at least once a month, and again after every major change, such as a new firewall rule, a new cloud service, or a new endpoint tool. Continuous platforms such as Picus and Cymulate can run weekly or daily.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides