Researched comparison

Best Email Security Software for Small Business

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the top pick for most small businesses because it costs $2 per user each month, adds Safe Links and Safe Attachments to Microsoft 365 mail, and needs no extra gateway. Teams that need stronger BEC defence should also compare Proofpoint Essentials and Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection before they decide.

Key takeaways

  • Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the cheapest published starting point at $2 per user each month, and it is already included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium.
  • Five of the eight tools in this guide publish no list price, so ask for a written quote at your own user count before you compare them.
  • API tools such as Abnormal, IRONSCALES and Avanan need no MX record change, while gateway tools route mail through a separate filter.
  • Hornetsecurity is the only other tool here with a published starting price, at 2.75 euros per user each month for its Business tier.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Microsoft Defender for Office 365Microsoft 365 teams$2 per user/month (billed annually)No
Proofpoint EssentialsBEC defence for small teamsQuote onlyFree trial (30 days)
Mimecast Advanced Email SecurityGateway security plus archivingQuote onlyNo
Barracuda Email ProtectionQuick setup and managed portalQuote onlyFree trial (30 days)
Hornetsecurity 365 Total ProtectionMicrosoft 365 teams, euro pricing2.75 euros per user/monthFree trial (30 days)
Abnormal SecurityTargeted BEC defenceQuote onlyNo
IRONSCALESPhishing response and trainingQuote onlyNo
AvananAPI inbox defenceQuote onlyFree trial (30 days)

Ranked by tier

1

Microsoft 365 teams that want native protection

Microsoft Defender for Office 365

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 sits inside the mail flow that small businesses already use, so there is no separate gateway to route mail through and no MX record change to plan. Plan 1 adds Safe Links, which checks links at click time, and Safe Attachments, which opens attachments in a sandbox before delivery. Anti-phishing policies add impersonation checks for senders and domains.

The main limit is scope. Plan 1 covers Microsoft 365 mail, SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams, but it does not add the investigation and hunting tools that larger security teams rely on after an incident. Those sit in Plan 2, which costs $5 per user each month when bought on its own, or comes with Microsoft 365 E5. Plan 1 is already included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium, so a team on that plan pays nothing extra for it.

Pros:

  • Native Microsoft 365 fit
  • Safe Links and Safe Attachments included

Cons:

  • Plan 2 investigation tools cost more

Price: $2 per user/month (billed annually)

Free plan: No

Website: microsoft.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 teams that want native protection

2

Small teams that want strong BEC defence

Proofpoint Essentials

Proofpoint Essentials is the small-business edition of a vendor with a long history in email security, and it targets the attacks that cost small firms the most, namely business email compromise and credential phishing. It filters inbound mail for malicious links and attachments, flags impersonation attempts, and adds a layer on top of Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace mail. The 30-day trial gives a team time to test it on real mail before signing a contract.

The drawback is price transparency. Proofpoint does not publish a list price for Essentials, so a buyer must request a quote and compare it with the published prices in this guide. That step is worth taking when BEC is the main worry, because Proofpoint has spent years tuning detection for finance teams and executives who receive payment-change requests and invoice fraud. Ask for the per-user price at your own user count, and confirm whether the quote covers outbound mail or only inbound filtering.

Pros:

  • Long track record against BEC and phishing
  • API and gateway deployment options

Cons:

  • No list price on the vendor site

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: Small teams that want strong BEC defence

3

Teams that want gateway security plus archiving

Mimecast Advanced Email Security

Mimecast Advanced Email Security combines a cloud gateway with archiving and continuity, so one service can filter mail, keep a searchable archive for compliance, and keep users working when the primary mail service is down. It checks links and attachments before delivery, blocks impersonation, and adds targeted threat protection for spear phishing. For a small firm in a regulated trade, the archive matters as much as the filter, because it supports retention rules and eDiscovery without a second product.

The main drawback is that Mimecast publishes no per-user price, so a buyer must go through a quote and cannot compare it directly with the $2 Defender Plan 1 figure in this guide. The quote will vary with user count, archiving needs and contract length. A buyer should ask for the price of the email security tier on its own, then ask what archiving and continuity add, so the comparison stays honest.

Pros:

  • Gateway security, archiving and continuity in one service
  • strong URL and attachment checks

Cons:

  • No public per-user price

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Teams that want gateway security plus archiving

4

Small teams that want a managed portal and quick setup

Barracuda Email Protection

Barracuda Email Protection is a cloud service that filters mail for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, using AI checks on intent, identity and content to catch phishing, malware and account takeover attempts. It connects without an MX record change, so a small team can be running in minutes, and it re-checks messages after delivery when a link or attachment turns malicious later. A single console covers quarantine, release and remediation across mailboxes, and the 30-day trial lets a team test detection on its own mail.

The drawback is price transparency. Barracuda does not publish a list price for Email Protection on its own site, so a buyer must request a quote and cannot compare a headline figure with the published prices in this guide. Higher tiers add backup and archiving, and those are also quote based, so a team that needs retention should ask for the full bundle price in the same quote.

Pros:

  • Multi-tenant portal for managed service providers
  • quick deployment with no MX change

Cons:

  • No list price on the vendor site
  • premium tiers with backup and archiving are quote based

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: barracuda.com

Best for: Small teams that want a managed portal and quick setup

5

Microsoft 365 teams that want clear euro pricing

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection is built for Microsoft 365, and its Business tier starts at 2.75 euros per user each month, which makes it one of the few tools in this guide with a published price a buyer can check without a sales call. It filters spam, malware and phishing, rewrites suspicious links, sandboxes attachments, and adds email encryption plus archiving and signatures. DMARC reporting helps a small firm see who sends mail under its domain and stop spoofed messages.

The main limits are currency and tiers. Prices are published in euros, so a buyer outside the euro area must convert the figure and check whether the quote adds tax or regional fees. Backup and compliance features sit in higher tiers, with Enterprise at 4.95 euros per user each month and Enterprise Backup at 7.70 euros, so a team that needs backup should budget for the higher tier from the start.

Pros:

  • Clear published pricing in euros
  • spam, malware and phishing filtering plus encryption

Cons:

  • Prices in euros, backup and compliance sit in higher tiers

Price: 2.75 euros per user/month

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: hornetsecurity.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 teams that want clear euro pricing

6

Teams facing targeted BEC and account takeover

Abnormal Security

Abnormal Security connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through an API, so there is no MX record change and no gateway to route mail through. It studies how people in a firm normally write, who they write to, and what tone they use, then flags messages that break that pattern, which is how it catches business email compromise and account takeover attempts that carry no malicious link or attachment. The platform can remove a malicious message from every mailbox after delivery.

The main drawback is cost transparency. Abnormal publishes no list price and offers no free tier, so a small team must request a quote and a demo before it can judge value. That puts it out of reach for some very small firms, and the sales-led process takes more time than buying a tool with a published price. A buyer should ask for the per-user price at its own user count and confirm whether the quote covers inbound, internal and outbound mail.

Pros:

  • API-based, no MX change
  • behavioural AI against BEC

Cons:

  • No public price and no free tier

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: abnormal.ai

Best for: Teams facing targeted BEC and account takeover

7

Teams that want fast phishing response and training

IRONSCALES

IRONSCALES is an AI email security platform for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace that works inside the mailbox through an API, with no MX record change and deployment measured in minutes. It uses AI agents to anticipate attacks, investigate messages that staff report, and turn that same research into phishing simulations and training for the people most likely to be targeted. That combination of prevention, response and training suits a firm with no dedicated security staff.

The main limits are price and scope. IRONSCALES publishes no list price, so a buyer must request a quote, and the platform is focused on phishing rather than acting as a full gateway replacement. A team that needs gateway filtering, archiving and continuity in one service should pair it with another tool or pick a bundle instead. A buyer should ask for the per-user price at its own user count and confirm whether simulation and training are included in the quote.

Pros:

  • One-click phishing incident response
  • simulation and training included

Cons:

  • No public price
  • focused on phishing, not a full gateway replacement

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ironscales.com

Best for: Teams that want fast phishing response and training

8

Teams that want API inbox defence with no MX change

Avanan

Avanan, now part of Check Point Harmony Email Security, connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through an API and inspects mail before it reaches the inbox, without any MX record change. It uses AI engines and threat intelligence to block phishing, malware and business email compromise, and it extends the same checks to Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, Slack and other collaboration tools. Data loss prevention, DMARC authentication, security awareness training and archiving are available in the wider platform.

The main drawback is the buying path. Avanan publishes no list price, and buying follows enterprise sales, so a small team should expect a quote and a demo rather than a self-serve checkout. That is a poor fit for a firm that wants to buy online in an afternoon, but it suits a team that wants a guided setup and a platform that covers more than mail. A buyer should ask for the per-user price at its own user count and confirm which collaboration apps the quote covers.

Pros:

  • API-based inbox defence, no MX change
  • prevention before the inbox

Cons:

  • No public price
  • buying follows enterprise sales

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: checkpoint.com

Best for: Teams that want API inbox defence with no MX change

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation and feature lists for eight email security tools that serve small businesses, and we checked each price on the vendor site on 15 November 2026. Where a vendor published a starting price, we used that figure. Where a vendor published no list price, we wrote quote only rather than using a third-party listing. We gave weight to phishing and BEC protection, deployment effort, Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace fit, archiving and compliance features, and the availability of a trial. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not accept vendor claims about detection rates at face value, so this guide compares published facts and documented limits instead of test results.

Our full method

Buyers guide

  • Confirm whether the price covers all mailboxes or only some, and whether the quote changes with user count or contract length.
  • Check deployment: does the tool need an MX record change, or does it connect through an API with no mail flow change.
  • Ask what happens after delivery: can the tool remove a malicious message from every mailbox, or only block it before delivery.
  • Confirm archiving, retention and eDiscovery cover your compliance needs, and check where data is stored.
  • Test the trial on real mail, and count how many phishing messages reach the inbox during the trial period.
  • Check the admin console: can one person manage policies, quarantine and reports without extra training.
  • Confirm support hours and response times, because a small team has no spare staff when mail stops working.

Frequently asked questions

Do small businesses need email security beyond Microsoft 365?

Microsoft 365 includes baseline Exchange Online Protection, which covers spam and known malware, but it does not stop targeted phishing and business email compromise on its own. Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments and anti-phishing policies for $2 per user each month. Teams that face invoice fraud or executive impersonation should add that layer or a specialist tool.

What is the cheapest email security software for a small business?

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the cheapest published starting point in this guide at $2 per user each month, and it is already included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium. Hornetsecurity Business is next at 2.75 euros per user each month. The other tools publish no list price, so a small team must request quotes before it can compare them fairly.

Should a small business pick a gateway or an API tool?

A gateway filters mail before delivery and suits teams that want one control point for all mail, while an API tool works inside the mailbox and suits teams that want fast setup with no MX record change. API tools can also remove a message after delivery, which helps when a threat turns malicious later. Many small teams start with a gateway or with Defender Plan 1, then add an API tool for BEC.

Does email security stop business email compromise?

No tool stops every BEC attempt, because the most convincing messages carry no link and no attachment. The best defence combines sender authentication such as DMARC, impersonation checks, behavioural analysis of how people normally write, and staff training on payment-change requests. Tools such as Abnormal, Proofpoint and IRONSCALES focus on that behavioural layer, while Defender Plan 1 adds anti-phishing policies.

How long does setup take for a small team?

API tools such as Abnormal, IRONSCALES and Avanan connect in minutes with no MX record change, while gateway tools need DNS changes and more planning. Defender Plan 1 is a policy change inside Microsoft 365, so a team can turn it on in an afternoon. Allow a week for a trial, because a short test on real mail shows more than a demo, and use that time to check quarantine and reporting.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides