Researched comparison

Best Email Security Software

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the top pick for most small teams because it costs $2 per user per month, covers phishing, malicious links and attachments natively inside Microsoft 365, and needs no extra gateway. Teams that want deeper BEC defence and a second layer outside Microsoft should look at Proofpoint Essentials or Abnormal Security instead.

Key takeaways

  • Email is still the most common entry point for phishing, business email compromise, and ransomware, so the gateway or API layer in front of the inbox carries real weight.
  • Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the cheapest starting point at $2 per user per month, and it is already included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and E3.
  • Proofpoint, Mimecast, Abnormal Security, IRONSCALES and Avanan do not publish list prices, so budget on a quote and compare per-user totals at your actual seat count.
  • Barracuda Email Protection Advanced lists at $5.20 per user per month and Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection Business lists at 2.75 euros per user per month.
  • No single tool covers every attack, so pair the email layer with DMARC, DKIM and SPF records, plus user reporting and a second check on payment requests.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Microsoft Defender for Office 365Microsoft 365 teams wanting native protection$2 per user/month (billed annually)No
Proofpoint EssentialsSmall teams wanting proven gateway filteringquote onlyFree trial (30 days)
Mimecast Advanced Email SecurityArchiving and continuity with email securityquote onlyNo
Barracuda Email ProtectionSmall businesses wanting a clear entry price$5.20 per user/monthFree trial (30 days)
Hornetsecurity 365 Total ProtectionMicrosoft 365 teams in Europe2.75 euros per user/monthFree trial (30 days)
Abnormal SecurityAI-led BEC and account takeover defencequote onlyNo
IRONSCALESFast phishing response for small IT teamsquote onlyNo
AvananAPI-based inbox defence without MX changesquote onlyFree trial (30 days)

Ranked by tier

1

Microsoft 365 teams wanting native email protection

Microsoft Defender for Office 365

Defender for Office 365 is the email security layer built into Microsoft 365, and Plan 1 is the entry point at $2 per user per month when billed annually. It adds Safe Links, which checks links at click time, Safe Attachments, which detonates files in a sandbox before delivery, and anti-phishing policies that cover impersonation of users and domains. Plan 1 is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and, since July 2026, in Microsoft 365 E3 and Office 365 E3, so many teams already have it without a separate line item.

Plan 2 costs $5 per user per month and adds Threat Explorer, automated investigation and response, attack simulation training, and priority account protection. It is included in Microsoft 365 E5. The main limit is that Defender is a single-vendor layer, so a Microsoft outage or a threat that slips past Microsoft detection has no independent second check. Teams that want defence in depth often pair it with an API-based tool that inspects mail after delivery.

Pros:

  • Native inside Microsoft 365 with no extra gateway
  • Safe Links and Safe Attachments included in Plan 1

Cons:

  • Plan 2 investigation tools cost more
  • weaker as a second layer because it shares the same Microsoft stack

Price: $2 per user/month (billed annually)

Free plan: No

Website: microsoft.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 teams wanting native email protection

2

Small teams wanting proven gateway filtering

Proofpoint Essentials

Proofpoint Essentials is the small-business line of one of the longest established email security vendors, and it filters mail through a cloud gateway before it reaches the inbox. The Business tier covers spam and virus filtering with a quarantine console, Advanced adds URL and attachment defence plus impersonation protection, and Professional adds encryption, email continuity and archiving. Reseller lists put Business near $3.93, Advanced near $5.37 and Professional near $8.14 per user per month, but Proofpoint publishes no list price, so confirm with a quote.

The strength of Essentials is the detection engine behind it, which draws on threat intelligence from a very large installed base and covers supplier impersonation and targeted phishing as well as commodity spam. Essentials is migrating toward 365 Total Protection, with no public end date set. A small team buying today should ask the reseller which platform the quote covers, how long the Essentials price is held, and what migration looks like before signing a multi-year term.

Pros:

  • Long track record against BEC and phishing
  • tiered plans from basic filtering to DLP and archiving

Cons:

  • No list price on the vendor site, so budgeting needs a reseller quote
  • enterprise features sit in higher tiers

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: Small teams wanting proven gateway filtering

3

Archiving and continuity with email security

Mimecast Advanced Email Security

Mimecast Advanced Email Security treats email security, archiving and business continuity as one platform rather than three separate purchases. Mail passes through the Mimecast cloud gateway, where multi-vector detection checks URLs, attachments and impersonation signals, and the same platform can archive every message for compliance retention and keep email working during a Microsoft 365 outage.

Mimecast publishes no per-user price, and third-party guides put security-only pricing near $3 to $4 per user per month, rising to $7 to $10 for the full bundle with archiving and continuity. Those are estimates, so the only reliable figure is a quote for your seat count and chosen tier. The main trade-off is cost and complexity: Mimecast is a strong fit for regulated teams that need long retention and continuity, but a small team that only needs phishing protection will find cheaper options here. Ask for the price of the security tier alone before accepting a bundle quote.

Pros:

  • Combines gateway security, archiving and continuity in one contract
  • strong URL and attachment sandboxing

Cons:

  • No public per-user price
  • the full bundle is priced for mid-size and larger buyers

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Archiving and continuity with email security

4

Small businesses wanting a clear entry price

Barracuda Email Protection

Barracuda Email Protection is the most approachable option on this list for a small business that wants a clear starting price and room to grow. The Advanced tier lists at $5.20 per user per month and covers gateway and API-based inbox defence, AI-driven detection of business email compromise and account takeover, and a multi-tenant portal that suits managed service providers. Premium adds Microsoft 365 backup for Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive, Teams and Entra ID, while Premium Plus adds domain fraud protection with DMARC, security awareness training and cloud archiving. The tiered structure lets a team start with protection alone and add backup or training later without changing vendors.

The published price only covers the Advanced tier, so Premium and Premium Plus need a quote. For a team that wants one vendor for email security and Microsoft 365 backup, Barracuda is a strong shortlist candidate.

Pros:

  • Published entry price with a multi-tenant portal
  • Advanced tier includes AI BEC and account takeover detection

Cons:

  • Premium tiers that add backup and archiving are quote based
  • smaller brand presence than Proofpoint or Mimecast

Price: $5.20 per user/month

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: barracuda.com

Best for: Small businesses wanting a clear entry price

5

Microsoft 365 teams in Europe

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection is a Microsoft 365 email security suite from a German vendor, and it is a natural fit for European teams that want a vendor inside the EU data boundary. The Business tier lists at 2.75 euros per user per month and covers spam and malware filtering, phishing protection and threat defence for Exchange Online. Enterprise, at 4.95 euros per user per month, adds more advanced threat protection and controls, while Enterprise Backup, at 7.70 euros per user per month, adds Microsoft 365 backup, and a Compliance and Awareness tier at 11 euros per user per month adds archiving and training. The published euro pricing makes budgeting simple for EU buyers, though US teams should convert at the current rate before comparing with dollar-priced rivals.

The limit is that the entry tier is email security only, so backup, archiving and awareness training each need a higher tier or a separate tool. Check where mail data is processed and stored, confirm the data processing agreement covers your jurisdiction, and test quarantine with a small pilot group first.

Pros:

  • Clear published pricing in euros
  • Business tier covers spam, malware and phishing for Microsoft 365

Cons:

  • Prices are listed in euros, so dollar cost moves with exchange rates
  • backup and compliance sit in higher tiers

Price: 2.75 euros per user/month

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: hornetsecurity.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 teams in Europe

6

AI-led BEC and account takeover defence

Abnormal Security

Abnormal Security takes a different approach from gateway vendors: it connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through an API and inspects mail after delivery, learning the normal communication patterns of each user, vendor and partner. That behavioural model is aimed squarely at business email compromise, vendor fraud, account takeover and socially engineered attacks that carry no malicious link or attachment and therefore pass traditional filters. When it spots an anomaly, such as a supplier asking for a changed bank account from an unusual address, it can remove the message, warn the recipient or hold it for review.

Abnormal publishes no price and offers no free tier, so every buyer goes through a sales quote shaped by mailbox count and modules. The main limit is that it is a second layer, not a gateway, so it does not replace spam and malware filtering at the edge. A team should ask for a proof of concept on its own live mail, check how many messages the AI quarantines in the first two weeks, and confirm the price includes both inbound and internal mail analysis.

Pros:

  • API-based deployment with no MX change
  • behavioural AI targets BEC, vendor fraud and account takeover

Cons:

  • No public price and no free tier
  • built for larger teams, so small buyers may face minimums

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: abnormal.ai

Best for: AI-led BEC and account takeover defence

7

Fast phishing response for small IT teams

IRONSCALES

IRONSCALES is an AI-first email security platform built for teams that need to react fast when a phishing message reaches the inbox. It combines gateway filtering with API-based inbox defence, and its standout feature is incident response: when one user reports a phishing email, the platform can remove the same message from every other inbox in the company with one click, then scan for other users who clicked the link. It also includes phishing simulation and security awareness training, so the same console covers both the technical filter and the human layer.

IRONSCALES publishes no list price, so the cost is a quote based on mailbox count and the modules chosen. The other limit is scope: IRONSCALES is strongest on phishing and BEC, so teams that need deep archiving, data loss prevention or continuity should pair it with another tool or pick a broader platform. Ask for a trial on live mail, measure how many phishing messages it catches that Defender missed, and confirm whether simulation and training are included in the quoted tier or charged separately.

Pros:

  • One-click incident response removes phishing from every inbox at once
  • simulation and training included

Cons:

  • No public price
  • the platform is focused on phishing, so it is not a full gateway replacement

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ironscales.com

Best for: Fast phishing response for small IT teams

8

API-based inbox defence without MX changes

Avanan

Avanan, now sold as Check Point Harmony Email and Collaboration, protects Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace through an API connection rather than a gateway, so deployment needs no MX record change and no mail flow rerouting. It inspects messages after they reach the inbox, which lets it catch phishing, malware and BEC attempts that passed the native filter and the gateway.

Avanan publishes no list price, and third-party guides put the tiers near $3 to $5 per user per month for Essentials, $5 to $8 for Advanced and $7 to $10 for Premium, but those are estimates and the only reliable figure is a quote. The main advantage is the deployment model: because nothing changes in mail flow, a pilot can run alongside the existing gateway without risk to delivery, and the team can measure the extra catch rate before committing. The limit is that Avanan is a second layer, so it does not replace the gateway or native filter. A team should run the trial for at least two weeks, count the extra threats it removes, and confirm the quote covers every collaboration app it uses.

Pros:

  • Deploys through API with no MX change
  • inspects mail after delivery so it catches what the gateway missed

Cons:

  • No public price
  • owned by Check Point, so the buying process follows enterprise sales

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: checkpoint.com

Best for: API-based inbox defence without MX changes

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation and plan pages for each tool, and we checked what each plan actually includes before listing a price. Where a vendor publishes no list price we wrote quote only instead of repeating a third-party estimate as a fact. We looked at deployment model, because gateway, API and native layers behave differently, and at coverage of phishing, BEC, malicious links and attachments. We also checked free plans, trial availability and whether archiving, backup or training are bundled or charged separately. We did not test any product hands-on and we did not run live phishing simulations. Prices were checked on 13 November 2026 and vendors can change them, so confirm the current figure on the vendor page before you buy.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Check whether the tool deploys as a gateway, an API layer or a native add-on, because a gateway change touches mail flow and needs a maintenance window, while an API layer can run in monitor mode first. Test the quarantine and release workflow with real users, because a filter that blocks legitimate invoices costs more than the subscription. Confirm DMARC, DKIM and SPF are set to at least quarantine, since no filter can fix a domain that attackers can spoof freely. Ask how the tool handles internal mail and collaboration apps, because BEC often moves laterally inside the tenant. Finally, check the data processing agreement and where mail content is stored, especially for teams under GDPR or handling client data.

Frequently asked questions

Is Microsoft Defender for Office 365 enough on its own?

For many small teams it is a solid starting point, because Plan 1 covers Safe Links, Safe Attachments and anti-phishing at $2 per user per month, and it is included in Business Premium and E3. It is still a single-vendor layer, so teams that handle large payments by email or that have suffered a BEC attempt often add an API-based second layer to catch what Microsoft misses.

What is the difference between a gateway and an API-based email security tool?

A gateway sits in front of the inbox and filters mail before delivery, which needs an MX record change and a maintenance window. An API-based tool connects to the mailbox after delivery and inspects messages already in the inbox, so it can run in monitor mode without touching mail flow. Many teams run both, because the gateway blocks commodity threats and the API layer catches targeted BEC.

Why do so many email security vendors hide their prices?

Enterprise email security is usually priced per mailbox with volume, term and module discounts, so vendors prefer a sales conversation to a public rate card. That makes budgeting harder, but it also means the first quote is rarely the final price. Ask for the price of the security tier alone, confirm what is bundled, and compare per-user totals at your actual seat count.

Does email security replace DMARC, DKIM and SPF?

No, it does not. DMARC, DKIM and SPF are DNS records that stop attackers from spoofing your domain, while email security filters the messages that reach your inbox. A team needs both. Set DMARC to at least quarantine, publish SPF for every service that sends as your domain, and check the DMARC reports monthly for unauthorised senders.

Should a small team buy archiving and backup with email security?

It depends on the compliance duty. Regulated teams that must retain mail for years should buy archiving, and every team should have Microsoft 365 backup somewhere, because Microsoft does not back up deleted mail beyond its retention window. If the email security bundle includes backup or archiving, compare its price with a standalone backup tool before accepting it.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides