Researched comparison
Best Extended Detection and Response Software
Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.
Palo Alto Networks Cortex XDR is the top pick for small SaaS teams that need detection across endpoint, network, and cloud, because it correlates all three into one incident view. Microsoft Defender XDR is the value pick for Microsoft 365 shops, included in E5 at $60 per user per month.
Key takeaways
- Palo Alto Cortex XDR leads for cross-domain correlation, joining endpoint, network, and cloud events into one incident.
- Microsoft Defender XDR is the value pick for Microsoft 365 shops, included in E5 at $60 per user per month.
- SentinelOne Complete brings XDR at a published $179.99 per endpoint per year, with autonomous response included.
- XDR only earns its price when the team connects at least two data sources, because a single source is just EDR with a new name.
Contents
Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.
Comparison at a glance
Comparison
| Tool | Best for | Price range | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Palo Alto Networks Cortex XDR | Endpoint, network, and cloud correlation | quote only | No |
| CrowdStrike Falcon XDR | Falcon shops adding cross-domain detection | quote only | No |
| Microsoft Defender XDR | Microsoft 365 shops | $60 per user/month | No |
| SentinelOne Singularity XDR | Autonomous response across domains | $179.99 per endpoint/year | No |
| Trend Micro Vision One | Multi-layer detection with email and cloud | quote only | No |
| Sophos XDR | Small fleets adding network and cloud data | quote only | No |
| Trellix XDR | EDR plus network and cloud correlation | quote only | No |
Ranked by tier
Endpoint, network, and cloud correlation
Palo Alto Networks Cortex XDR
Palo Alto Networks Cortex XDR is the most complete cross-domain platform in this list, and it earns the top pick on correlation depth. Endpoint events are joined with network traffic and cloud activity, so a phishing email, a malicious download, and a cloud login from a new location appear as one incident with a timeline, rather than three alerts in three queues. The analytics engine scores incidents and suppresses low-value noise, which is the feature a small team feels first, because the daily alert count drops to a number one person can read.
The platform covers Windows, macOS, and Linux endpoints, and it pairs with the Palo Alto firewall and Prisma Cloud where a team already runs them, which deepens the network and cloud data. The cost is scope: Cortex XDR is sold as a platform, and a team that only wants endpoint detection will pay for network and cloud modules it does not use. Pricing is quote only and usually tied to endpoints and data volume. Ask for the endpoint, network, and cloud modules to be named separately in the quote, and budget a week for the first responders to learn the console.
Pros:
- Correlates endpoint, network, and cloud data into one incident
- analytics rank incidents and cut noise
Cons:
- No public price
- the platform buy is bigger than EDR alone, and the console needs training
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: paloaltonetworks.com
Best for: Endpoint, network, and cloud correlation
Falcon shops adding cross-domain detection
CrowdStrike Falcon XDR
CrowdStrike Falcon XDR extends the Falcon platform beyond the endpoint, correlating endpoint telemetry with identity, cloud, and third-party data through connectors. A team already running Falcon Enterprise for EDR can add the XDR module without deploying a second agent, and the same console shows the cross-domain incident view. The Falcon platform publishes per-device prices for its endpoint tiers, at $59.99 for Go, $99.99 for Pro, and $184.99 for Enterprise per device per year, but the XDR module itself is sold by quote.
The fit depends on the starting point. A Falcon shop gets XDR with the least new deployment, while a team without Falcon faces a platform buy that starts with the endpoint agent and adds the module on top. The third-party connectors matter: identity data from Okta or Entra ID, email data, and cloud data from AWS or Azure widen the incident view beyond the endpoint. Ask for a written quote that separates the Falcon Enterprise base from the XDR module, and confirm which connectors are included.
Pros:
- Builds on the Falcon agent and console teams already know
- third-party data connectors extend correlation
Cons:
- No public price for the XDR module
- the Falcon tiers below Enterprise are prevention, not detection
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: crowdstrike.com
Best for: Falcon shops adding cross-domain detection
Microsoft 365 shops
Microsoft Defender XDR
Microsoft Defender XDR is the value pick for any team already on Microsoft 365, because it is included in Microsoft 365 E5 at $60 per user per month, and E5 also includes Defender for Endpoint Plan 2, which lists standalone at $5.20 per user per month. The XDR portal joins signals from Defender for Endpoint, Defender for Office 365, Defender for Identity, and Defender for Cloud Apps, so a phishing email, a risky sign-in, and a malicious process on the endpoint appear as one incident with a shared timeline.
The correlation is strongest inside the Microsoft estate, which is the point and the limit: a team running Google Workspace, Slack, or AWS beside Microsoft 365 will find the third-party coverage thinner, and the connectors for those sources need configuration. The portal is a single place for investigation, hunting, and response, and automated investigation can contain a device or revoke a session without waiting for an analyst. Confirm whether the team holds E5 already, because the incremental cost is then zero, and check the connector list for the non-Microsoft tools the team runs.
Pros:
- Included in Microsoft 365 E5
- joins Defender for Endpoint, Office 365, Identity, and Cloud Apps in one portal
Cons:
- No free plan
- correlation is strongest inside Microsoft 365, and third-party data needs connectors
Price: $60 per user/month (Microsoft 365 E5)
Free plan: No
Website: microsoft.com
Best for: Microsoft 365 shops
Autonomous response across domains
SentinelOne Singularity XDR
SentinelOne Singularity XDR builds on the Singularity platform, and its entry point is the Complete tier at $179.99 per endpoint per year, which includes full EDR, XDR, rollback, and the Purple AI assistant. The platform correlates endpoint telemetry with cloud, identity, and network data, and the Storyline engine links events into an attack chain that spans domains. The autonomous response that defines SentinelOne on the endpoint extends to the wider incident, containing threats without waiting for an analyst.
For a small team the published price is the advantage: the XDR tier is named and priced, unlike most rivals that quote the module separately. The limit is data ingestion: the breadth of the XDR view depends on which cloud, identity, and network sources are connected, and those connectors can be a separate part of the deal. Purchases go through partners, so ask for a written partner quote that names the Complete tier and the connected data sources. Confirm whether the quote covers the cloud security modules or only the endpoint and XDR tiers.
Pros:
- Published per-endpoint price
- autonomous response and rollback extend beyond the endpoint
Cons:
- No free plan
- XDR breadth depends on the tier, and data ingestion beyond the endpoint is a separate conversation
Price: $179.99 per endpoint/year (Singularity Complete)
Free plan: No
Website: sentinelone.com
Best for: Autonomous response across domains
Multi-layer detection with email and cloud
Trend Micro Vision One
Trend Micro Vision One is a multi-layer detection platform that joins endpoint, email, network, and cloud telemetry into one workbench, with risk insights that rank findings by the exposure they represent. The email layer matters for SaaS teams, because phishing is still the most common entry point, and Vision One ties a malicious email to the endpoint and cloud activity that follows it. The platform also covers cloud workloads and containers, which suits teams running production in AWS or Azure.
The breadth is also the buying problem: Vision One is a platform with many modules, and a small team needs help scoping which ones to buy, because the quote can include email, cloud, and network layers the team does not need yet. Pricing is quote only. Ask for the modules to be named in the quote, and confirm whether the email security layer is included or a separate Trend Micro product. The workbench is capable but takes training, so plan a first week of guided triage.
Pros:
- Joins endpoint, email, network, and cloud layers
- risk insights rank the findings that matter most
Cons:
- No public price
- the platform is broad, so small teams need help scoping the right modules
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: trendmicro.com
Best for: Multi-layer detection with email and cloud
Small fleets adding network and cloud data
Sophos XDR
Sophos XDR extends the Sophos endpoint platform with data from the Sophos Firewall, email security, and cloud workloads, so a team already running Sophos Central can add cross-domain detection without a new vendor. The XDR console shows detections across the connected sources in one timeline, and the Sophos Managed Detection and Response service can watch the queue for teams without analysts. The product suits small fleets that want XDR without an enterprise platform buy.
The limit is correlation depth. Sophos XDR joins fewer data sources than Palo Alto or Microsoft, and the analytics are lighter, so a team with a complex cloud estate will find the incident view thinner. The XDR tier sits above the base endpoint product, so the quote needs to name it. Pricing is quote only. Ask for a combined quote for the XDR tier and the managed service, and confirm which Sophos products feed the XDR console in the quote.
Pros:
- Builds on Sophos Central and the firewall data a team may already hold
- managed detection is available
Cons:
- No public price
- correlation depth is lighter than Palo Alto or Microsoft, and the XDR tier is a step up
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: sophos.com
Best for: Small fleets adding network and cloud data
EDR plus network and cloud correlation
Trellix XDR
Trellix XDR joins endpoint, network, and cloud telemetry into one console, and it is the natural route for teams consolidating legacy McAfee and FireEye products, which Trellix combined. The platform correlates detections across those domains, and the threat intelligence feed adds context to the incidents it surfaces. For a team that already runs Trellix endpoint products, the XDR layer arrives without a second agent deployment.
The product line has been through consolidation, so the sales conversation should cover the roadmap, the console the team will use, and the support tier. Pricing is quote only and sold through partners. A small team should ask for the XDR scope in writing, naming the endpoint, network, and cloud modules separately, because the platform can be quoted as a bundle that includes capability the team does not need. Test the console with a real incident timeline before committing, since the investigation workflow is where XDR earns its price.
Pros:
- Joins endpoint, network, and cloud telemetry
- the console suits teams consolidating legacy McAfee and FireEye tools
Cons:
- No public price
- the product line has been through consolidation, so roadmap questions belong in the sales call
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: trellix.com
Best for: EDR plus network and cloud correlation
How we choose
How we choose
We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and feature lists for seven extended detection and response tools, and we checked which domains each one connects, whether the vendor publishes a price, and whether the correlation is automatic or manual. Microsoft Defender XDR is included in Microsoft 365 E5 at $60 per user per month, and SentinelOne Complete at $179.99 per endpoint per year includes XDR, both checked against vendor pricing information today. The other five are quote only, so we compared correlation depth and deployment effort instead. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not accept vendor claims about detection rates or customer counts at face value. Check current price on the vendor site before you buy, because XDR quotes change with endpoints and connected data sources.
Buyers guide
Connect at least two data sources before you judge an XDR tool, because a single source is EDR with a new name and the correlation is the product. Ask the vendor to name the connected sources in the quote, since identity, email, and cloud connectors are often separate lines. Check data retention across domains, because an incident timeline needs history from every source. Confirm who watches the queue, and add a managed service to the budget when the team has no analyst.
Frequently asked questions
What is extended detection and response software?
Extended detection and response software joins telemetry from endpoints, networks, email, identity, and cloud into one incident view, so an analyst sees the full attack path instead of separate alerts. It correlates a phishing email with the malicious process it launched and the cloud login that followed, then offers response actions across those domains. For a small SaaS company it cuts triage time by showing one incident where EDR would show five alerts.
How is XDR different from EDR?
EDR watches endpoints only, while XDR adds network, email, identity, and cloud data to the same incident view. A phishing email that drops malware on a laptop and then logs into a cloud app is one EDR alert, one email alert, and one cloud alert, while XDR shows it as one incident with a timeline. XDR costs more and needs more data sources connected, so a team with one domain to watch should buy EDR and add XDR later.
Do I need XDR if I already have EDR?
A team needs XDR when alerts from different domains arrive separately and the team spends time joining them by hand. If the team runs Microsoft 365, the jump to Defender XDR is often free inside E5, so the cost is configuration rather than a new licence. If the team runs a single stack with one EDR tool and few alerts, EDR alone is enough, and XDR can wait until the alert volume justifies it.
Why do most XDR vendors hide their prices?
XDR vendors price by endpoint count, by connected data sources, and by data volume, and those inputs vary so much that a public list price would mislead most buyers. A team connecting two sources pays far less than a team connecting six, and a quote that includes the managed service costs more than the platform alone. SentinelOne is the exception here, with Complete published at $179.99 per endpoint per year, and Microsoft publishes E5 at $60 per user per month.
How many data sources should XDR connect?
Connect at least two sources beyond the endpoint, usually email and identity, because those two cover the most common attack paths for a SaaS company. Add cloud workload data next if production runs in AWS or Azure, and network data after that. Each source adds correlation value and ingestion cost, so connect the sources that match the team's real attack surface rather than every connector the vendor offers.