Researched comparison

Best Merchant Marketing Software Compared

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

Key takeaways

  • Four tools here have a free tier: Omnisend for 250 contacts, Klaviyo for 250 profiles, Mailchimp for 250 contacts, and Yotpo Reviews for up to 50 monthly orders.
  • Mailchimp Essentials at $13 a month is the cheapest entry plan for email at 500 contacts, and Omnisend Standard at $16 a month is next.
  • Klaviyo Email at $20 a month covers 500 profiles and 5,000 emails, and SMS is an add-on, so the bill rises with every channel you add.
  • Loyalty is the expensive part: Smile.io Growth starts at $199 a month, Yotpo Loyalty starts at $199 a month, and LoyaltyLion sells by quote.
  • Mailchimp bills by contact count, including unsubscribed contacts, so a list with many inactive contacts costs more than the headline rate suggests.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
OmnisendEmail and SMS for Shopify storesFree; Standard $16 per monthYes
KlaviyoEmail and SMS with deep segmentationFree; Email $20 per monthYes
MailchimpSimple email marketing at scaleFree; Essentials $13 per monthYes
YotpoReviews and loyalty in one platformFree; Reviews from $15 per monthYes
Smile.ioPoints and VIP loyalty programsGrowth $199 per monthNo
PrivyPop-ups, email, and SMS for storesEmail from $30 per monthFree trial (15 days)
LoyaltyLionLoyalty and referrals for larger storesquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

email and SMS for Shopify stores

Omnisend

Omnisend Free costs $0 a month and covers 250 contacts, 500 emails a month, 500 web push notifications, and 24/7 support, with no credit card required. Standard costs $16 a month for 500 contacts and covers 6,000 emails a month, unlimited web push notifications, and free migration, with the page showing $11.20 a month for the first three months with 30 percent off. Pro costs $59 a month for 2,500 contacts and covers unlimited emails, SMS from $0.007 per message, and the full AI agent set, including forms, dynamic content, a product recommender, and personalized sending time. A custom plan is quoted for large contact lists.

Omnisend fits a Shopify or BigCommerce store that wants email, SMS, and web push in one place. The free plan is enough to test real campaigns, and the per-contact pricing means a small store pays little. The drawback is the intro pricing: the $11.20 rate lasts three months, then the bill rises to $16, and SMS is priced per message on top of the plan, so a store that sends many texts should model the SMS cost before choosing Pro.

Pros:

  • free plan covers 250 contacts and 500 emails a month with no credit card required
  • Standard includes 6,000 emails a month for 500 contacts
  • SMS starts at $0.007 per message

Cons:

  • Standard is $11.20 a month only for the first three months with 30 percent off, then $16
  • Pro at $59 a month is the tier that adds SMS at scale
  • account experts start at $400 a month

Price: Free; Standard $16 per month

Free plan: Yes

Website: omnisend.com

Best for: email and SMS for Shopify stores

2

email and SMS with deep segmentation

Klaviyo

Klaviyo Free costs $0 and covers up to 250 active profiles and 500 emails a month, plus $5 of Composer usage, $5 of mobile messages, social marketing, reviews for 50 orders a month, a Customer Hub, a Customer Agent with 10 resolutions, and a helpdesk with 10 tickets. The Email plan costs $20 a month for 500 active profiles and covers 5,000 emails a month, campaigns and flows, segmentation, and A/B testing. The Marketing plan lists $25 a month, with a limited-time offer of $1 for the first month for up to 5,000 active profiles, and adds social marketing, reviews with no order limit, and a Customer Hub for 500 profiles. A custom plan is quoted above 150,000 active profiles.

Klaviyo fits a store that segments hard: purchase history, browsing, and predicted value drive the flows, and the email and SMS tools share one profile. The drawback is the add-on model: SMS, the Customer Agent, and the helpdesk are add-ons on the Email plan, so the $20 headline covers email only, and the bill rises with active profiles, so a growing list means a higher tier even if sends stay flat.

Pros:

  • free plan covers 250 active profiles and 500 emails a month
  • Email plan adds A/B testing and 5,000 emails a month
  • strong segmentation and flows for ecommerce

Cons:

  • SMS and MMS are add-ons, not included
  • the Marketing plan lists $25 a month but the first month is a $1 promotion
  • prices rise with active profiles, not with sends

Price: Free; Email $20 per month

Free plan: Yes

Website: klaviyo.com

Best for: email and SMS with deep segmentation

3

simple email marketing at scale

Mailchimp

Mailchimp Free costs $0 for up to 250 contacts and up to 500 sends a month, with a daily maximum of 250, one seat, and one audience. Essentials costs $13 a month for 500 contacts and covers up to 10 times the contact count in sends, 3 seats, 3 audiences, and A/B testing. Standard costs $20 a month for 500 contacts and covers up to 12 times the contact count in sends, 5 seats, 5 audiences, and up to 200 automation flows. Premium costs $350 a month for 10,000 contacts and covers up to 15 times the contact count in sends, unlimited seats and audiences, multivariate testing, and phone support. A 14-day trial is available on Essentials and Standard.

Mailchimp fits a store that wants the simplest email tool with the widest integration list. The setup is fast, the templates are strong, and the free plan is enough for a new store. The drawback is billing: Mailchimp charges for subscribed, unsubscribed, and non-subscribed contacts, so a list with 30 percent inactive contacts still bills at the full tier, and the free plan was cut in February 2026, so a store that outgrows 250 contacts moves to a subscription sooner than older guides suggest.

Pros:

  • free plan for up to 250 contacts and 500 sends a month
  • Essentials at $13 a month is the cheapest entry price here
  • 300-plus integrations and a 14-day trial on Essentials and Standard

Cons:

  • the free plan was cut in February 2026 from 500 contacts and 1,000 sends
  • billing counts unsubscribed contacts
  • Premium starts at $350 a month with no band below 10,000 contacts

Price: Free; Essentials $13 per month

Free plan: Yes

Website: mailchimp.com

Best for: simple email marketing at scale

4

reviews and loyalty in one platform

Yotpo

Yotpo Reviews and UGC has a limited free plan for up to 50 monthly orders, and subscription plans start at $15 a month. Yotpo Loyalty and Referrals has a full free plan, and subscription tiers start at $199 a month. Yotpo Discover, for AI visibility, is custom-priced around the store's goals. Pricing for reviews and loyalty scales with the store's monthly order volume, and each product page has a slider that shows the matching plan and price for a given order count. A bundle that combines reviews and loyalty costs less than buying each product separately.

Yotpo fits a store that wants reviews and loyalty from one vendor. The review widgets, seller ratings, and AI display features drive conversion, and the loyalty program sits on the same customer data. The drawback is the order-volume model: a store with a busy month pays more, and the loyalty tiers start at $199 a month, so a small store should start with the free plans and check the slider for its real order volume before committing.

Pros:

  • Reviews and UGC has a free plan for up to 50 monthly orders
  • Loyalty and Referrals has a full free plan
  • pricing scales with monthly order volume, not with contacts

Cons:

  • Reviews pricing rises with order volume, so a busy store pays more
  • Loyalty tiers start at $199 a month
  • Premium, enterprise, and Discover plans are custom-quoted

Price: Free; Reviews from $15 per month

Free plan: Yes

Website: yotpo.com

Best for: reviews and loyalty in one platform

5

points and VIP loyalty programs

Smile.io

Smile.io Growth costs $199 a month on monthly billing and covers 2,500 monthly orders, unlimited integrations, 25 specialized reports, a VIP program, a Loyalty Hub, fully embedded loyalty, and performance benchmarks. Smile Plus costs $999 a month on annual billing and covers 7,500 monthly orders, 30-plus reports, a migration and launch plan, quarterly program monitoring, priority support, and API access. Smile Enterprise is custom-priced for retailers with more than $40 million in annual revenue, with unlimited monthly orders and custom reports. Extra orders cost $20 per 100 on Growth and $5 per 100 on Plus.

Smile.io fits a Shopify or BigCommerce store that wants a points, referral, and VIP program without building one. Customers earn points in-store through Shopify POS, redeem them at checkout, and see their status in the Loyalty Hub. The drawback is the entry price: $199 a month is the cheapest plan on the current pricing page, with no free tier, so a small store should compare Yotpo Loyalty, which has a free plan, before committing to Smile.io.

Pros:

  • Growth covers 2,500 monthly orders with a VIP program and a Loyalty Hub
  • works with Shopify POS and BigCommerce
  • SOC 2 Type II audited in May 2026

Cons:

  • no free plan on the current pricing page
  • Growth is $199 a month, so the entry price is high
  • extra orders cost $20 per 100 on Growth

Price: Growth $199 per month

Free plan: No

Website: smile.io

Best for: points and VIP loyalty programs

6

pop-ups, email, and SMS for stores

Privy

Privy Email starts at $30 a month based on mailable contacts, with unlimited email sends, email and SMS campaigns, advanced pop-up design and targeting, email and SMS automations, advanced targeting and segmentation, third-party integrations, and advanced reporting. The plan includes 250 free SMS credits, and extra SMS credits are an add-on. A 15-day free trial is available with no credit card required, and there is no annual contract. Pop-ups and displays only is a separate option priced by monthly page views, with templates, landing pages, embedded forms, A/B testing, spin-to-win, cart savers, and exit intent pop-ups.

Privy fits a store that wants list growth and email in one tool. The pop-ups capture emails, the email tool sends unlimited campaigns, and the SMS add-on covers text without a second vendor. The drawback is the pricing unit: the bill follows mailable contacts, so a store with a large list pays more even if it sends little, and pop-ups are priced separately by page views, so a high-traffic store should check both prices.

Pros:

  • email starts at $30 a month with unlimited sends and no annual contract
  • 250 free SMS credits included
  • 15-day free trial with no credit card required

Cons:

  • no free plan, only a 15-day trial
  • pricing follows mailable contacts, so a large list costs more
  • pop-ups and displays are priced separately by page views

Price: Email from $30 per month

Free plan: Free trial (15 days)

Website: privy.com

Best for: pop-ups, email, and SMS for stores

7

loyalty and referrals for larger stores

LoyaltyLion

LoyaltyLion is a loyalty and referral platform sold by quote, built for Shopify and BigCommerce stores. The platform covers points, referrals, VIP tiers, and rewards, with integrations across the ecommerce stack. Pricing is custom and follows store size and order volume, and the vendor publishes no figures, so the only way to get a price is a sales conversation. There is no free plan, and onboarding and support are part of the quoted package.

LoyaltyLion fits a larger store that wants a loyalty program shaped around its own tiers and rewards. The platform suits merchants that have outgrown a simple points tool and need custom rules, integrations, and reporting. The drawback is the quote: without a published price, a buyer cannot compare LoyaltyLion with Smile.io or Yotpo Loyalty until the sales call is done, and a small store should get the entry figure in writing before investing time in a demo.

Pros:

  • loyalty and referral programs built for Shopify and BigCommerce
  • custom pricing follows store size and order volume
  • dedicated onboarding and support on higher tiers

Cons:

  • no published price, so budgeting needs a sales conversation
  • no free plan
  • the quote depends on store size, so small stores may find the entry price high

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: loyaltylion.com

Best for: loyalty and referrals for larger stores

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, plan documentation, and feature lists for seven merchant marketing platforms, and we checked the headline prices against the vendor pages on 11 November 2026. Omnisend, Klaviyo, Yotpo, Smile.io, and Privy prices come from their pricing pages, opened today. Mailchimp prices come from mailchimp.com/pricing as checked in October 2026, since today's crawl of the page returned the plan structure without the tier figures. LoyaltyLion publishes no price and sells by quote. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not score the tools with numbers. We favoured tools with published prices, a free tier or trial where one exists, and clear email, SMS, reviews, or loyalty features. We left out tools that sell only advertising or only analytics. Prices are in US dollars and exclude tax unless the vendor states otherwise. Check the live pricing page before you buy, because merchant software pricing changes often.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Start with the billing unit, because it decides the real cost: Omnisend, Klaviyo, and Mailchimp charge by contacts or profiles, Yotpo and Smile.io charge by monthly orders, and Privy charges by mailable contacts. Next, check what counts toward the tier: Mailchimp bills unsubscribed contacts, and Klaviyo bills active profiles, so a list with many inactive contacts costs more than the headline rate suggests. Then check the channel: SMS is an add-on on Klaviyo and Privy, and a per-message cost on Omnisend, so model the SMS volume before choosing a plan. Then check the free tier limits: Omnisend, Klaviyo, and Mailchimp all cap the free tier at 250 contacts or profiles, and Yotpo Reviews caps it at 50 monthly orders. Finally, check the loyalty entry price: Smile.io starts at $199 a month, Yotpo Loyalty starts at $199 a month, and LoyaltyLion is quoted, so a small store should start with a free loyalty plan.

Frequently asked questions

Which merchant marketing tool is cheapest?

Mailchimp Essentials at $13 a month for 500 contacts is the cheapest entry plan here, and Omnisend Standard at $16 a month is next. For a free start, Omnisend, Klaviyo, and Mailchimp all cover 250 contacts or profiles, and Yotpo Reviews covers up to 50 monthly orders. A store with 500 contacts pays $13 to $20 a month for email, before SMS or loyalty costs.

Do I need separate tools for email and loyalty?

No, for most stores. Omnisend and Klaviyo cover email and SMS, and Yotpo covers reviews and loyalty in one platform, so a store can run email, SMS, reviews, and loyalty from two tools. Smile.io and LoyaltyLion cover loyalty only, so they pair with an email tool such as Klaviyo or Omnisend. A store should pick the email tool first, then add the loyalty tool that integrates with it.

What is the difference between Klaviyo and Omnisend?

Klaviyo Email costs $20 a month for 500 profiles and 5,000 emails, with deep segmentation and flows, and SMS is an add-on. Omnisend Standard costs $16 a month for 500 contacts and 6,000 emails, with SMS from $0.007 per message on Pro. Klaviyo suits a store that segments hard and wants the deepest flows; Omnisend suits a store that wants email, SMS, and web push in one place at a lower entry price.

Which tool is best for reviews?

Yotpo Reviews and UGC is the strongest fit, with a free plan for up to 50 monthly orders and subscription plans from $15 a month, plus seller ratings and AI display features. Klaviyo also includes reviews for 50 orders a month on its free plan and with no order limit on the Marketing plan, but reviews are a side feature there, not the core product. A store that lives on reviews should start with Yotpo.

Can I switch merchant marketing tools later?

Yes, but the cost varies. Contacts, segments, and templates can move, and Omnisend offers a free 5-day migration, while other vendors offer migration help on higher tiers. Flows, automations, and loyalty points do not move cleanly, so a store should export its lists and flows regularly and check whether loyalty points transfer before switching. A trial is the safest way to test a new tool with real data.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides