Researched comparison

Best NYDFS Compliance Software for Financial Firms

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Secureframe is the top pick for most small firms because it publishes a $7,500 starting price, maps controls to 23 NYCRR 500, automates evidence collection, and bundles policy templates, risk assessment and vendor review in one contract. Vanta and Drata suit teams that already run SOC 2 or ISO 27001 in the same platform.

Key takeaways

  • 23 NYCRR 500 covers banks, insurers, lenders and other firms licensed by the New York Department of Financial Services, and it requires a written cybersecurity program, a CISO, risk assessments, MFA, encryption and 72-hour breach notice.
  • Secureframe is the top pick for most small firms because it publishes a $7,500 yearly starting price and maps controls to the regulation out of the box.
  • Vanta, Drata, Sprinto, Scrut and 6clicks price by quote, so get written quotes on the same scope before you compare totals.
  • Strike Graph starts at $21,500 a year, which suits larger teams that need a full GRC system rather than a first audit.
  • CyberArrow lists NYDFS Regulation 500 in its framework library and starts at $11,000 a year, while 6clicks suits advisors and multi-entity teams.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
SecureframeSmall financial firms that want a published price and guided setupFrom $7,500 per yearNo
VantaTeams that already run SOC 2 or ISO 27001 in Vantaquote onlyNo
DrataTeams that want deep automation and a large integration catalogquote onlyNo
SprintoSmall teams that want fast setup across several frameworksquote onlyNo
6clicksAdvisors and multi-entity teams that want a full GRC platformquote onlyFree trial
CyberArrowFirms that want NYDFS content with automation and a virtual CISOFrom $11,000 per yearNo
Strike GraphLarger teams that want a risk-first GRC systemFrom $21,500 per yearYes

Ranked by tier

1

Small financial firms that want a published price and guided setup

Secureframe

Secureframe is the top pick for most small firms facing NYDFS because it makes the first year concrete. The Fundamentals plan starts at $7,500 per year and covers one framework, which is enough for a firm that needs NYDFS alone. The platform maps controls to the sections of 23 NYCRR 500, and evidence collection runs from integrations with cloud providers, identity tools and HR systems, which cuts the manual gathering that fills most NYDFS programs.

The platform also bundles the pieces the regulation demands. Policy templates cover the written cybersecurity policy, the risk assessment module supports the annual risk assessment, and vendor risk management supports the third-party service provider policy. A named compliance manager helps during setup, and the Trust Center shares your security posture with partners and examiners.

The audit is sold separately through a partner network, and penetration testing is a separate cost. The AWS Marketplace listing shows $7,500 for platform access plus $7,500 for the first framework, so ask for the full first-year total in writing. Fundamentals also caps AI questionnaire responses at 100 a year and Trust Center document requests at 15 a year.

Pros:

  • Publishes a $7,500 yearly starting price
  • maps controls to 23 NYCRR 500
  • guided setup with a named compliance manager

Cons:

  • Fundamentals includes one framework, so each extra framework adds cost
  • SSO and SCIM connections start on the Complete plan

Price: From $7,500 per year

Free plan: No

Website: secureframe.com

Best for: Small financial firms that want a published price and guided setup

2

Teams that already run SOC 2 or ISO 27001 in Vanta

Vanta

Vanta is the strongest choice for a financial firm that already runs SOC 2 or ISO 27001 in Vanta, because NYDFS controls map onto work the team has already done. The platform monitors controls continuously across cloud, identity and device integrations, and it flags drift as soon as a control stops passing. Cross-framework mapping means evidence gathered for SOC 2 can count toward NYDFS where the control language matches, which shortens the second audit cycle. That reuse is the main reason to pick Vanta when a firm already holds another certification.

Vanta covers the NYDFS duties that map to control monitoring. It tracks MFA enrollment, encryption settings, access reviews and patch status, and it keeps an audit trail of control changes. Risk management supports the annual risk assessment, vendor risk supports the third-party service provider policy, and questionnaire automation helps answer due diligence requests from banks and partners.

Vanta publishes no list price, and buyer data puts small-team contracts in a wide range, so compare written quotes on the same headcount and framework scope. Trust Center and vendor risk management cost extra, which pushes the total above the core platform quote. A firm that only needs NYDFS gets less value than one that consolidates three or four frameworks in one place.

Pros:

  • Large integration catalog with continuous control monitoring
  • cross-framework mapping reuses evidence across standards

Cons:

  • No published price, so every figure comes from a sales quote
  • Trust Center and vendor risk management are add-ons

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: vanta.com

Best for: Teams that already run SOC 2 or ISO 27001 in Vanta

3

Teams that want deep automation and a large integration catalog

Drata

Drata suits a financial firm that wants automation to do the heavy lifting. The platform connects to more than 180 tools, pulls evidence on a schedule, and tests controls continuously, so the compliance team sees failures the day they happen rather than at audit time. Access reviews, personnel onboarding and offboarding, and policy attestation run inside the same system, which matches the NYDFS duties around access privileges and the written cybersecurity policy. The control library maps to 23 NYCRR 500, and the risk register supports the annual risk assessment.

Auditors can review evidence, request items and track remediation inside the platform, which shortens the audit cycle. The platform supports multiple frameworks at once, so a firm that adds SOC 2 or ISO 27001 later can reuse the same evidence and controls.

Drata publishes no price, and buyer data puts entry contracts for small teams in a wide range, so the only reliable figure is a written quote for your headcount and framework count. The audit and penetration testing are separate fees, so the platform quote is only part of the first-year total. Check which integrations are included in the quoted tier, because some connectors sit behind higher plans.

Pros:

  • Deep automation with more than 180 integrations
  • strong access review and personnel tracking features

Cons:

  • No published price
  • audit fees are separate and add a large cost on top of the platform

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: drata.com

Best for: Teams that want deep automation and a large integration catalog

4

Small teams that want fast setup across several frameworks

Sprinto

Sprinto fits a small financial firm that wants to move fast. Setup is measured in days rather than weeks, with prebuilt checks that map to NYDFS and to frameworks a firm is likely to add next, such as SOC 2 and ISO 27001. The dashboard shows control status in one place, and automated evidence collection pulls from cloud and identity tools, with nudges to owners when a task is due.

Sprinto covers the NYDFS duties that come down to control hygiene. It monitors MFA, encryption, access reviews and patching, and it keeps records that support the audit trail requirement. The risk assessment module supports the annual risk assessment, and the vendor management module supports the third-party service provider policy. Policy templates give a small firm a starting point for the written cybersecurity policy, and version history shows when each policy was approved and attested.

Sprinto publishes no list price, so get a written quote and compare it against Vanta and Drata on the same scope. The integration catalog is smaller than the two leaders, so confirm your core tools are supported before signing. Sprinto is also a younger platform, with fewer auditor relationships in some regions.

Pros:

  • Fast setup with prebuilt checks for many frameworks
  • clear dashboards for control status

Cons:

  • No published price
  • integration catalog is smaller than Vanta or Drata

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: sprinto.com

Best for: Small teams that want fast setup across several frameworks

5

Advisors and multi-entity teams that want a full GRC platform

6clicks

6clicks is a full GRC platform rather than a single-framework tool, which makes it a good fit for advisors, MSPs and firms with several entities. The hub and spoke model lets a parent team run one hub and give each client or business unit its own spoke, with shared content and separate environments. The content library covers more than 100 frameworks, and the risk, audit, compliance and vendor modules sit in one system, so a team can run the NYDFS program, the risk register and the vendor review without buying three tools.

For NYDFS, 6clicks supports the risk assessment, control mapping, audit management and third-party review that the regulation requires. There are no per-user, per-module or per-framework charges, and implementation and support are included. Hailey AI, the built-in assistant, helps draft assessments and summarize control gaps.

The vendor pricing page opened on 13 November 2026 shows no dollar figures, so the only reliable number is a written quote. Third-party listings report a starting figure near $4,800 a year, but that figure is unverified against the vendor page and conflicts with other listings, so do not budget on it. Support is run from Australia, so confirm response times for your working hours before signing.

Pros:

  • Full GRC platform with risk, audit and vendor management in one place
  • hub and spoke model for multi-entity teams

Cons:

  • Vendor pricing page shows no dollar figures, so every price comes from a quote
  • support hours skew to Australian time zones

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial

Website: 6clicks.com

Best for: Advisors and multi-entity teams that want a full GRC platform

6

Firms that want NYDFS content with automation and a virtual CISO

CyberArrow

CyberArrow is the only tool in this guide that names NYDFS Regulation 500 on its own site as a supported framework, which makes it a natural shortlist pick for a firm that wants NYDFS content out of the box. The platform automates evidence collection and control implementation for more than 50 standards, and the vendor states that it automates up to 90 percent of the work involved in implementation and certification. Auditor pre-approved document templates speed up policy writing, and a virtual CISO is available through chat for questions that need an expert answer.

The platform covers continuous monitoring, automated evidence collection and audit readiness, with more than 60 integrations, and it carries the audit through the platform with partner auditors. That matters for a firm that wants certification in weeks rather than months. The vendor also offers security awareness training, which supports the personnel security side of the regulation.

The vendor comparison page lists a price of $11,000, but the main pricing page does not publish a figure, and third-party listings report lower numbers, so get the figure in writing and ask what is included. The integration catalog, at more than 60 tools, is smaller than Vanta or Drata, so confirm your stack is covered. CyberArrow is headquartered in Dubai with offices in the US, UK, Europe and the Middle East.

Pros:

  • Lists NYDFS Regulation 500 in its framework library
  • automates up to 90 percent of implementation work
  • virtual CISO chat support

Cons:

  • Price is not published on the main pricing page
  • integration catalog is smaller than Vanta or Drata

Price: From $11,000 per year

Free plan: No

Website: cyberarrow.io

Best for: Firms that want NYDFS content with automation and a virtual CISO

7

Larger teams that want a risk-first GRC system

Strike Graph

Strike Graph is built for organizations that need a long-term GRC system rather than a first-audit tool. The pricing page lists Certify from $21,500 per year and Scale from $35,000 per year, with Enterprise priced by quote. The risk-first model starts from the risk register and ties controls and evidence to each risk, which matches the way NYDFS expects a firm to run its annual risk assessment and then build controls around it. Cross-framework mapping reuses controls across standards, and the AI assistant helps draft and test controls.

A free Launch plan lets a small team explore the interface before committing, and Certify includes one Tier 1 framework, unlimited risks, controls and evidence, more than 50 cloud integrations and an audit workbook export. That bundle suits a firm with a compliance lead that wants a system that scales to several frameworks and entities. The Trust Center is included at all tiers, unlike Vanta where it is an add-on.

At $21,500 a year, Strike Graph costs about three times the Secureframe entry point, and additional frameworks cost $2,000 to $8,000 each, so a multi-framework program adds up fast. Audit fees are set by the auditor and sit outside the subscription. A small firm that only needs NYDFS should weigh whether the risk-first system is worth the premium over a cheaper first-audit tool.

Pros:

  • Publishes a $21,500 yearly Certify starting price
  • risk-first model with cross-framework mapping
  • free Launch plan

Cons:

  • Entry price is high for small firms
  • additional frameworks cost $2,000 to $8,000 each
  • audit fees are separate

Price: From $21,500 per year

Free plan: Yes

Website: strikegraph.com

Best for: Larger teams that want a risk-first GRC system

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation and framework libraries, and we checked each price on the vendor site on 13 November 2026. We favored tools that publish a price, map controls to 23 NYCRR 500, automate evidence collection and support the risk assessment, vendor review and audit trail the regulation requires. We did not test any product hands-on. Prices change, so confirm every figure with a written quote before you sign.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Ask each vendor for the full first-year total in writing, including the platform fee, each framework, the audit, penetration testing and any add-ons. Confirm that NYDFS Regulation 500 is in the framework library and that the control mapping covers the sections your firm must meet, including the extra duties for Class A companies if your firm qualifies. Check that your cloud, identity and HR tools are supported, and ask which integrations sit behind higher tiers.

Confirm the audit trail and evidence retention match the regulation, and check how the platform handles the 72-hour breach notification clock and the 24-hour extortion payment notice. Ask who owns the risk assessment template and whether the vendor supplies a CISO reporting pack for the board. Check renewal caps, exit terms, data export and support hours. A short trial or a guided demo with your own control list is the fastest way to see whether the mapping fits.

Frequently asked questions

Does NYDFS apply to my firm?

NYDFS Regulation 500 applies to a person or entity operating under a license, registration, charter, certificate, permit, accreditation or similar authorization under the New York Insurance Law, Banking Law or Financial Services Law. That covers banks, insurers, lenders, mortgage servicers, brokers and money transmitters. Check your license type against the rule, because exemptions exist for very small firms and for firms with no New York business.

What is the 72-hour rule?

A covered entity must notify the Superintendent of Financial Services within 72 hours of a cybersecurity event that requires notice, and the amended rule adds a 24-hour notice for an extortion payment. The notice goes through the NYDFS portal, and the clock starts when the firm determines an event occurred. A tool helps by keeping the audit trail, incident log and evidence that support the notice and the follow-up filing.

Do I need a CISO for NYDFS?

Yes, the regulation requires a qualified individual to oversee the cybersecurity program, and that person can be an employee, an affiliate or a third-party service provider. The CISO must report to the board or senior governing body at least once a year. A compliance platform does not replace the CISO, but it gives the CISO the control status, risk register and evidence needed for that report.

Can one tool cover NYDFS and SOC 2 together?

Yes, most platforms in this guide map one set of controls to several frameworks, so evidence gathered for NYDFS can count toward SOC 2 where the control language matches. Secureframe, Vanta, Drata, Sprinto and Strike Graph all support multi-framework programs. Ask the vendor to show the overlap before you buy, because the share of reused controls varies by framework pair.

How long does NYDFS readiness take with a tool?

A small firm with a clean cloud stack can reach audit readiness in 4 to 12 weeks with a tool, depending on how many controls already pass and how fast policies are approved. Firms with legacy systems, manual processes or many third parties take longer. The platform shortens evidence collection, but policy approval, access reviews and penetration testing still need people and time.

Sources

Byline: Tierlyn Editorial Team

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides