Researched comparison

Best PCI Compliance Software for SaaS Payment Companies

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

Key takeaways

  • Your SAQ type follows how you handle card data. SAQ A fits a fully outsourced payment page, SAQ A-EP fits e-commerce with a direct post, SAQ D fits companies that store, process, or transmit card data, and a Report on Compliance fits Level 1 merchants and service providers.
  • None of the eight tools in this guide replaces a Qualified Security Assessor or an Approved Scanning Vendor. Budget assessor and scan fees on top of the software subscription.
  • Only Strike Graph publishes a price on its own pricing page today. Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, Sprinto, Thoropass, Scrut, and Carbide all ask for a quote, so get the PCI line item in writing before you sign.
  • Start with scope, not with features. Map the cardholder data environment and confirm the SAQ type with your acquirer before you compare plans.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
VantaSAQ A, A-EP, and D tracking beside SOC 2quote onlyNo
DrataFull PCI DSS framework with control testsquote onlyNo
SecureframeGuided PCI work for first-time filersquote onlyNo
SprintoFirst PCI audit with guided helpquote onlyNo
Strike GraphRisk-first PCI program with published pricing$35,000 per yearYes
ThoropassPCI SAQ-A with an in-house audit teamquote onlyNo
ScrutLow entry cost PCI program for small teamsquote onlyNo
CarbidePCI work with expert services attachedquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

SAQ A, A-EP, and D tracking beside SOC 2

Vanta

Vanta tracks PCI DSS 4.0 work next to SOC 2 and ISO 27001 in one workspace. Its PCI coverage documents SAQ A, SAQ A-EP, SAQ D for merchants and service providers, and Report on Compliance paths. Evidence flows in from cloud accounts, identity providers, code repositories, and HR systems through more than 400 integrations, and automated tests check controls on an hourly cadence. That cadence helps a payment company spot drift between filings instead of finding it during audit week.

The limit to plan around is scope. Vanta does not act as your QSA, and ASV scans are a separate cost, so a Level 1 merchant still hires an assessor and a scanning vendor. PCI can sit as an added framework rather than part of the base plan, which changes the quote. Ask for the PCI line item in writing and confirm whether vendor risk management is included.

Pros:

  • More than 400 integrations pull evidence from cloud and identity systems
  • PCI DSS 4.0 coverage for SAQ A, A-EP, D, and ROC paths

Cons:

  • ASV scans cost extra and sit outside the platform
  • PCI is an added framework, so the base plan may not cover it

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: vanta.com

Best for: SAQ A, A-EP, and D tracking beside SOC 2

2

Full PCI DSS framework with control tests

Drata

Drata covers the full PCI DSS framework rather than a single SAQ path, which suits a SaaS payment company that also needs SOC 2 or ISO 27001. Controls are pre-mapped across frameworks, so one piece of evidence can support several requirements, and automated tests check cloud configuration, access, and device posture on a continuous basis. The platform scopes requirements by SAQ type and shows the full set of about 280 requirements for the Report on Compliance path, which gives a Level 1 team a clear view of the work ahead.

The trade-off is cost structure. Drata sells its platform fee and each framework as separate line items, so a PCI program costs more than a single-framework SOC 2 program. The vendor pricing page lists plans without prices, so the only way to get a firm number is a quote. Ask how the fee changes with a second framework and confirm that QSA and ASV fees sit outside the subscription.

Pros:

  • PCI DSS sits among more than 20 frameworks with pre-mapped controls
  • automated tests run against cloud and identity systems

Cons:

  • Pricing is quote based and framework fees add up
  • audit fees are separate from the subscription

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: drata.com

Best for: Full PCI DSS framework with control tests

3

Guided PCI work for first-time filers

Secureframe

Secureframe pairs automation with people, which helps a first-time filer that has no compliance lead on staff. The platform collects evidence from cloud and identity systems, holds policies and personnel tasks such as background checks and security training, and maps controls across SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, PCI DSS, and GDPR. A named compliance expert walks the team through scoping, gap closure, and audit preparation, which shortens the learning curve for a small SaaS team filing PCI for the first time.

The cost of that guidance is time and a quote-only price. Teams report 40 to 60 hours of internal work to get the platform running, and the vendor pricing page shows package names without prices. Before you commit, ask which package includes PCI DSS and ask for the renewal price in the first contract, since a low first-year quote can rise when a second framework is added.

Pros:

  • In-house compliance experts guide the first filing
  • policy and personnel tasks sit in the same workspace

Cons:

  • Setup can take 40 to 60 hours of internal time
  • pricing is quote based with no public list price

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: secureframe.com

Best for: Guided PCI work for first-time filers

4

First PCI audit with guided help

Sprinto

Sprinto positions itself as a guided path to a first audit, with PCI DSS among more than 25 frameworks that are automated out of the box and more than 200 further frameworks digitised for use. Evidence collection runs through more than 300 integrations, and the platform includes risk management, vendor risk, policy management, and a trust center in its plans. Each plan includes one framework of your choice, so a SaaS payment company can start with PCI DSS and add SOC 2 later without moving to a new tool.

The limits are caps and opacity. AI questionnaire automation is capped at 20 per year on both plans, and role-based access controls need the Growth plan, so a team that answers many security questionnaires should check those caps first. The vendor site shows no prices, so the quote is the only firm number. Ask for the PCI framework fee as a separate line and confirm that audit fees sit outside the subscription.

Pros:

  • PCI DSS is one of more than 25 automated frameworks
  • more than 300 integrations feed evidence into the platform

Cons:

  • AI questionnaire automation is capped at 20 per year on both plans
  • pricing is quote based with no public list price

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: sprinto.com

Best for: First PCI audit with guided help

5

Risk-first PCI program with published pricing

Strike Graph

Strike Graph is the one vendor in this guide that publishes prices on its own pricing page, which makes budgeting far simpler. The page lists Certify from $21,500 per year and Scale from $35,000 per year, and it places PCI DSS in the Tier 2 framework group. An additional Tier 2 framework costs $3,000 per year on Scale, so a PCI program on Scale starts at $35,000 per year before audit fees. The platform organises work around risks, controls, and evidence, with AI help for control testing and audit workbook export.

The catch is the tier boundary. Certify covers Tier 1 frameworks only, so PCI DSS is not included there, and a team that buys Certify expecting PCI coverage will need to move up to Scale. Strike Graph arranges outside QSAs and ASVs rather than supplying them in house, so assessor and scan fees stay separate. Confirm the Tier 2 add-on price in the quote and confirm that the PCI DSS version in the content matches the version your acquirer expects.

Pros:

  • PCI DSS is a Tier 2 framework with a stated add-on price
  • Scale plan starts at $35,000 per year on the vendor pricing page

Cons:

  • Entry Certify plan covers Tier 1 frameworks only, so PCI needs Scale or higher
  • audit fees are separate from the subscription

Price: $35,000 per year

Free plan: Yes

Website: strikegraph.com

Best for: Risk-first PCI program with published pricing

6

PCI SAQ-A with an in-house audit team

Thoropass

Thoropass combines compliance software with an audit practice under one roof, which appeals to a SaaS payment company that wants fewer vendors to manage. The software tracks controls, evidence, and audit tasks, while the audit side can carry out the assessment work for frameworks such as SOC 2 and PCI DSS SAQ-A. That pairing can cut handoff delays between the platform team and the assessor, since both sides work from the same evidence set and the same task list.

The trade-off is that price follows audit scope. A SAQ-A filing for a small merchant costs far less than a Report on Compliance for a Level 1 service provider, and the vendor does not publish a price list, so the quote is the only firm number. Ask whether the quote covers the software and the audit together or prices them apart, and ask what happens to the price if scope grows mid-year, for example when a new payment flow is added.

Pros:

  • Thoropass pairs software with its own audit practice
  • PCI DSS SAQ-A is a named offering

Cons:

  • Pricing is quote based and audit scope drives the final figure
  • the platform suits teams that want audit help, not a self-serve tool only

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: thoropass.com

Best for: PCI SAQ-A with an in-house audit team

7

Low entry cost PCI program for small teams

Scrut

Scrut takes a flat approach to pricing that small teams often prefer. Every plan includes all core features, modules, and frameworks, with no limits based on users or usage, and no per-framework fee. That matters for PCI, since several rivals charge a separate fee for each framework on top of a platform fee. The platform covers more than 70 frameworks, including PCI DSS, SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, and GDPR, with automated evidence collection, continuous control monitoring, policy templates, and a risk register.

The limit is transparency. Scrut does not publish a pricing page and quotes each customer after a demo, so a buyer cannot compare a list price before the sales call. Published list prices from marketplace listings are higher than the quotes some buyers report, so ask for a direct quote and get it in writing. Confirm that the quote includes onboarding and confirm that audit and penetration test fees sit outside the subscription.

Pros:

  • All core features, modules, and frameworks are included in each plan
  • no per-framework fee

Cons:

  • No public pricing page, so every quote needs a demo
  • audit fees are separate from the subscription

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: scrut.io

Best for: Low entry cost PCI program for small teams

8

PCI work with expert services attached

Carbide

Carbide combines a platform with a services team, which suits a SaaS payment company that wants hands-on help through the audit cycle. The platform supports secure configuration checks, policy development, and automated evidence collection for core PCI DSS requirements, with real-time alerts and continuous monitoring of the cardholder data environment. More than 100 technical integrations feed evidence into the platform, and the Carbide Academy resources give the team reference material between filings.

The limit is that the service layer is part of the value and part of the cost. Carbide does not publish a price on its own site, so the quote is the only firm number, and a buyer should ask how much of the quote is software and how much is services. Confirm which PCI DSS requirements the automated checks cover and confirm whether the services hours renew each year or expire at the end of the first audit cycle.

Pros:

  • Continuous cloud monitoring with alerts on drift
  • expert services team supports the audit cycle

Cons:

  • Pricing is quote based
  • the service layer adds cost beyond the software subscription

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: carbide.com

Best for: PCI work with expert services attached

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and framework lists for PCI DSS 4.0, and we checked each vendor pricing page on 2026-11-11. Only Strike Graph published a price on its own pricing page, at $35,000 per year for the Scale plan that includes a Tier 2 framework such as PCI DSS, with Certify from $21,500 per year. Vanta, Drata, Secureframe, Sprinto, Thoropass, Scrut, and Carbide all show quote-based pricing on their own pages, so this guide lists them as quote only rather than repeating a third-party estimate as a vendor price. We gave weight to SAQ coverage, to continuous control monitoring, to evidence automation, and to whether audit and ASV scan fees sit inside or outside the subscription. We did not claim hands-on use of any tool.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Confirm your SAQ type with your acquirer before you sign, since the wrong SAQ wastes months of work. Map the cardholder data environment and list every system, vendor, and payment flow that touches card data, including test environments and logs. Ask each vendor which PCI DSS version its content follows, since PCI DSS 4.0 and 4.0.1 differ in places, and ask how the content is updated when the standard changes. Check Requirements 6.4.3 and 11.6.1 for payment page scripts, since several platforms track the requirement but do not monitor scripts in the browser, so you may still need a separate script security tool. Confirm whether ASV scans are included and who books the scan. Check vendor risk management for Requirement 12.8, since a payment company must manage service providers that touch card data. Finally, ask for the renewal price in the first contract and ask what triggers a price rise, such as headcount growth or a second framework.

Frequently asked questions

Which SAQ type does a SaaS payment company file?

It depends on how card data flows through your systems. A fully outsourced payment page usually files SAQ A, an e-commerce site with a direct post usually files SAQ A-EP, and a company that stores, processes, or transmits card data usually files SAQ D. Level 1 merchants and service providers file a Report on Compliance instead. Confirm the type with your acquirer before you start, since the wrong SAQ wastes months of work.

Does PCI compliance software replace a QSA?

No. These tools organise evidence, run control tests, and track remediation, but they do not carry out the assessment. A Qualified Security Assessor still validates scope, tests controls, and signs the Report on Compliance for Level 1 merchants and service providers. Smaller merchants still need an Approved Scanning Vendor for quarterly scans where the requirement applies. Budget assessor and scan fees apart from the software subscription.

How much do ASV scans cost?

Scan prices vary by asset count and vendor. A small scope can start at $185 per year for one asset from some scanning vendors, while a larger estate with many public IP addresses costs more. Quarterly scans are required where Requirement 11.3.2 applies, so multiply the per-scan price across the year. Ask the scanning vendor what is included, such as remediation re-scans, before you compare prices.

What is the difference between SAQ D and a Report on Compliance?

SAQ D is a self-assessment questionnaire for merchants and service providers that store, process, or transmit card data but fall below Level 1 volume thresholds. A Report on Compliance is an on-site assessment by a Qualified Security Assessor for Level 1 merchants and service providers, with formal testing of every applicable requirement. The Report on Compliance costs more and takes longer, and it ends with an assessor-signed report and Attestation of Compliance.

How long does a first PCI DSS filing take?

A small SAQ A filing with a narrow scope can take 2 to 4 weeks when evidence is already in order and the payment flow is fully outsourced. A SAQ D filing usually takes 6 to 12 weeks, since more controls need evidence and remediation. A Level 1 Report on Compliance often takes 3 to 6 months, including scoping, remediation, and the on-site assessment. Start scoping early, since late fixes to network segmentation most often delay a filing.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides