Researched comparison

Best Phishing Simulation Software for Small Business

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

KnowBe4 is the top pick for most small businesses because it pairs a large library of realistic phishing templates with short training modules and clear reporting on who clicked, who reported, and who needs more coaching. A team that wants a lighter option can start with Hoxhunt, but KnowBe4 covers training, simulation, and reporting in one place.

Key takeaways

  • Phishing simulation works only when the training that follows a failed click is short, specific, and given at once, not a month later.
  • KnowBe4 leads because its template library, training content, and reporting are built for teams without a dedicated security trainer.
  • Proofpoint and Mimecast suit firms that already use those vendors for email security, because the simulation data joins the email data in one console.
  • Cofense and Infosec IQ suit teams that want deep template control and detailed reporting on repeat clickers.
  • Every vendor in this category prices by seat and contract length, so get a written quote for your exact headcount before you compare.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
KnowBe4All-in-one training and simulationquote onlyNo
Proofpoint Security AwarenessFirms already on Proofpoint emailquote onlyNo
Mimecast Awareness TrainingFirms already on Mimecast emailquote onlyNo
Cofense PhishMeDeep template controlquote onlyNo
Infosec IQDetailed reporting on repeat clickersquote onlyNo
Terranova SecurityShort, focused training modulesquote onlyNo
HoxhuntLight, behaviour-led trainingquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

All-in-one training and simulation

KnowBe4

KnowBe4 is the most widely used security awareness platform, and its strength is the size of its content library. The platform ships with thousands of phishing templates that copy real attacks, from fake invoice emails to fake password reset notices, and it pairs each simulation with short training videos that explain what the employee missed. When someone clicks a simulated phish, the platform can assign the right training module at once, which is the moment the lesson sticks.

For a small business, the reporting is the part that earns the price. KnowBe4 tracks click rates, report rates, and repeat clickers across the whole company and per department, so an IT lead can see whether the finance team needs more coaching than the sales team. The platform also supports automated campaigns that run on a schedule, so a team of one can keep simulations running all year without building each campaign by hand.

The main limit is pricing. KnowBe4 sells four tiers, Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Diamond, and the price depends on seat count and contract length. The vendor does not publish a single list price, so small teams need a quote. Ask for the per-user annual price at your exact headcount, confirm which tier includes the template library you need, and check whether the price rises at renewal.

Pros:

  • Largest template and training library
  • clear per-user reporting

Cons:

  • No public price, and the full platform can be more than a small team needs

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: knowbe4.com

Best for: All-in-one training and simulation

2

Firms already on Proofpoint email

Proofpoint Security Awareness

Proofpoint Security Awareness builds its simulations from the real threats that Proofpoint sees across its email customer base, so the templates reflect the attacks that are actually reaching inboxes. The platform includes training modules, phishing simulations, and reporting on user behaviour, and it can target training at the people who face the most risk, such as staff who handle wire transfers or who have clicked before.

For a firm that already uses Proofpoint for email security, this tool has a clear edge, because the simulation results sit next to the real email threats the same people received. An IT lead can see whether the staff who clicked a simulated phish also received real phishing emails that week, which shows whether the training is aimed at the right people.

The drawback is the same as with most enterprise vendors. Proofpoint does not publish prices, and the platform is priced for firms that buy the wider email security suite. A small business that does not use Proofpoint email will find the standalone price hard to justify. Ask for a quote that covers training and simulation only, and confirm how the tool handles staff who use personal devices.

Pros:

  • Shares data with Proofpoint email security
  • strong threat-led templates

Cons:

  • No public price, and the best value needs the wider Proofpoint platform

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: Firms already on Proofpoint email

3

Firms already on Mimecast email

Mimecast Awareness Training

Mimecast Awareness Training uses short, focused videos that staff can finish in a few minutes, which suits small firms where no one has an hour for a training course. The platform sends simulated phishing emails, tracks who clicks and who reports, and assigns the matching video at once. The training covers the common attacks that target small firms, including invoice fraud, fake login pages, and malicious attachments.

The fit is strongest for firms that already use Mimecast for email security, because the awareness data joins the email threat data in the same console. That link lets an IT lead see which real threats reached the inbox and whether the staff who received them had finished the matching training. For a team that already pays for Mimecast, adding awareness training is a smaller step than buying a separate platform.

The limit is pricing and scope. Mimecast does not publish prices for awareness training, and the catalogue is narrower than KnowBe4. Ask for a per-user annual quote, confirm how many simulations are included each year, and check whether the videos are available in the languages your staff speak.

Pros:

  • Short video training that staff finish
  • simulation data joins Mimecast email data

Cons:

  • No public price, and the catalogue suits teams already on Mimecast

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Firms already on Mimecast email

4

Deep template control

Cofense PhishMe

Cofense PhishMe is built for teams that want to design their own simulations rather than use a fixed library. The template builder lets an admin copy a real phishing email the company received, change the links, and send it as a simulation, which makes the test feel real to staff. The platform tracks clicks, reports, and repeat offenders in detail, and it can feed the results into a security orchestration tool so that repeat clickers get extra coaching automatically.

For a small business with an IT lead who has time to build scenarios, PhishMe gives more control than any other tool in this guide. A team can simulate the exact attacks its sector faces, such as fake supplier invoices for a finance team or fake delivery notices for a logistics team, which makes the training feel relevant instead of generic.

The drawback is the setup effort. PhishMe expects an admin who will build templates and run campaigns, and small teams without that time will get less from it. Cofense does not publish prices. Ask for a quote at your headcount, confirm how many templates are included, and check whether onboarding help is included in the first year.

Pros:

  • Very flexible template builder
  • strong reporting on repeat clickers

Cons:

  • No public price, and setup takes more time than simpler tools

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: cofense.com

Best for: Deep template control

5

Detailed reporting on repeat clickers

Infosec IQ

Infosec IQ combines phishing simulation, security awareness training, and reporting in one platform. The training library covers phishing, social engineering, and compliance topics, and the platform can run automated campaigns that adapt to each employee, sending harder simulations to staff who keep passing and extra coaching to staff who keep clicking. The reporting shows click rates by department, by role, and over time, which helps an IT lead prove that the programme is working.

The automation is the main draw for a small team. Once the campaign rules are set, Infosec IQ can run simulations, assign training, and send reminders without daily attention, which suits a firm where one person owns security alongside other duties. The platform also includes a free phishing security test that a team can use before buying, which gives a baseline click rate to measure against.

The limit is pricing. Infosec IQ does not publish prices, and the cost depends on seat count and contract length. Ask for a written quote, confirm whether the price includes the full training library, and check how the platform handles staff who join or leave during the year.

Pros:

  • Strong reporting and automated campaigns
  • good training library

Cons:

  • No public price, and the interface takes a short while to learn

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: infosecinstitute.com

Best for: Detailed reporting on repeat clickers

6

Short, focused training modules

Terranova Security

Terranova Security focuses on short, focused training that fits into a working day. Its modules run a few minutes each and cover one topic at a time, such as spotting a fake login page or checking a sender address. The platform sends phishing simulations, tracks clicks and reports, and assigns the matching module to anyone who clicks, which keeps the loop between test and training tight.

For a small business, the short format matters, because staff are more likely to finish a three-minute module than a forty-minute course. Terranova also offers training in many languages, which suits firms with staff across more than one country. The reporting covers the basics well, including click rates, report rates, and completion rates by team.

The drawback is the size of the library. Terranova has fewer templates and modules than KnowBe4, so a team that wants a very wide range of scenarios may outgrow it. Terranova does not publish prices. Ask for a per-user quote, confirm the number of simulations per year, and check whether the training is available in every language your staff need.

Pros:

  • Short modules that staff actually finish
  • clear phishing simulation workflow

Cons:

  • No public price, and the library is smaller than the largest vendors

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: terranovasecurity.com

Best for: Short, focused training modules

7

Light, behaviour-led training

Hoxhunt

Hoxhunt takes a different approach from the rest of this list. Instead of fixed campaigns, it sends each employee simulations that adapt to their behaviour, getting harder as they improve and easier when they struggle. The platform is designed to run with very little admin work, which suits a small business where no one has hours each week to manage a training programme.

The strength is the behaviour model. Hoxhunt tracks how each person responds over months, not just whether they clicked once, and it builds a risk score that an IT lead can use to decide who needs more help. The simulations look like real phishing emails, including the kind that target specific roles, and the training that follows is short and tied to the exact mistake.

The limit is control and price. Teams that want to design their own templates will find Hoxhunt less flexible than PhishMe, and the vendor does not publish prices. Ask for a per-user annual quote, confirm how the risk scoring works, and check whether the platform supports the email system your firm uses.

Pros:

  • Adaptive simulations that adjust to each person
  • very light admin work

Cons:

  • No public price, and the approach suits teams that prefer automation to control

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: hoxhunt.com

Best for: Light, behaviour-led training

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and feature lists for each tool, and we checked which vendors publish a price and which require a sales call. We looked at the size of the template library, the length of the training modules, whether a failed click triggers training at once, and whether the reporting shows click rates, report rates, and repeat clickers by team. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not accept vendor claims about click-rate reduction without checking them against the vendor documentation. Prices in this guide come from vendor pages checked on 13 November 2026, and any tool with no public price is marked quote only.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Run a baseline simulation before you sign, because a vendor quote means little without knowing your current click rate. Ask each vendor how many simulations are included per year and whether extra campaigns cost more. Confirm that training is assigned at once when someone clicks, because a delay of days weakens the lesson. Check that the templates cover the attacks your sector faces, such as invoice fraud for finance teams and fake delivery notices for operations teams. Ask how the tool handles new joiners and leavers, and whether the price changes when headcount moves during the year. Get the renewal terms in writing, including whether the price rises after the first year. Finally, confirm that the reporting shows who reported a phish as well as who clicked, because a rising report rate is the clearest sign that training is working.

Frequently asked questions

How often should we send phishing simulations?

Most small businesses should send one simulation per month, because that pace keeps staff alert without turning the programme into a chore. Sending a simulation every week can breed resentment and teaches staff to expect the test, while sending one a quarter leaves too long between lessons for the training to stick.

What is a good click rate after training?

A new programme often starts with a click rate near 30 percent, and a mature programme should bring that below 5 percent within a year. The exact number matters less than the trend, so track the rate each month and watch whether it falls after each training cycle. A rate that stays flat for three months means the training is not landing.

Should we punish staff who click a simulated phish?

No, punishment makes staff hide mistakes instead of reporting them, which is the opposite of what you want. A failed click should trigger short training and a friendly note, not a formal warning. The goal is a culture where staff report a suspicious email quickly, because a fast report limits the damage from a real attack.

Do we need to tell staff that simulations are coming?

Yes, tell staff that simulations run as part of the security programme, but do not tell them when the next one arrives. Advance notice of the schedule ruins the test, while secrecy about the programme itself breeds distrust when someone discovers the simulation later. A short note at onboarding and a yearly reminder is enough.

How long should each training module be?

Short modules of three to five minutes work best for most staff, because they fit between tasks and get finished. Longer courses have a place for new joiners and for staff who handle money or sensitive data, but the core programme should stay short. If completion rates fall below 80 percent, the modules are too long.

Can phishing simulation replace email security filters?

No, simulation trains people while filters block attacks, and a small business needs both. A filter stops most phishing emails before they reach an inbox, and training catches the ones that slip through. Budget for both, and review the filter logs each month to see which attacks are reaching staff.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides