Researched comparison

Best KnowBe4 Alternatives for Security Training

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Proofpoint Security Awareness is the top pick for most small and midsize teams that need a KnowBe4 alternative, because it pairs large scale phishing simulation with role based training, clear risk reporting, and broad language coverage. Teams that want a simpler setup should look first at usecure or NINJIO instead.

Key takeaways

  • Proofpoint Security Awareness leads for phishing simulation at scale, with role based training and risk reporting for larger teams.
  • Mimecast Awareness Training fits teams that already use Mimecast for email security and want training in the same console.
  • usecure is the simplest option here for small teams, with one plan, automation, and a trial to test the core features.
  • NINJIO and Terranova Security suit teams that want short video lessons or risk based campaigns without a long setup.
  • Every tool in this guide uses quote only pricing except where a vendor publishes a figure, so ask for a written quote for your exact user count.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Proofpoint Security AwarenessPhishing simulation at scalequote onlyNo
Mimecast Awareness TrainingTraining inside an email security suitequote onlyNo
Infosec IQStructured training paths and reportingquote onlyNo
NINJIOShort video based awareness trainingquote onlyNo
usecureSmall teams that want published pricingquote onlyFree trial
Arctic Wolf Managed Security AwarenessManaged awareness with concierge supportquote onlyNo
Terranova SecurityRisk based training campaignsquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

Phishing simulation at scale

Proofpoint Security Awareness

Proofpoint Security Awareness covers phishing simulation, security training, and risk reporting in one platform for teams that need to reach many users across departments and locations. Admins can run phishing tests, assign training by role and risk level, and track completion and click rates in reports that show where risk remains highest. The content library covers common topics such as phishing, password safety, data handling, and social engineering, with lessons in many languages for global teams.

The platform fits teams that already manage email risk and want awareness training to sit close to that work. Proofpoint connects awareness results with threat data, so a team can focus extra training on the groups that click most often or handle sensitive data. Reporting helps a security lead show progress to managers and auditors without building manual spreadsheets, and automation can enroll new users and assign remedial training after a failed simulation.

The main limit is price transparency. Proofpoint does not publish a per user price for this product, so a small team cannot compare it with a fixed budget without a quote. Setup also takes more planning than a simple training library, because admins need to set up user groups, phishing domains, reporting, and training paths. Teams with a small user count and a short timeline should ask for a clear quote, a trial scope, and the time needed for first launch before they commit.

Pros:

  • Large phishing template library
  • role based training and risk reporting

Cons:

  • No public price, so budgeting needs a sales quote and a scoping call

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: Phishing simulation at scale

2

Training inside an email security suite

Mimecast Awareness Training

Mimecast Awareness Training gives teams short video lessons, phishing simulation, and risk scoring for users who receive email based attacks every day. The training focuses on real inbox risks such as phishing links, fake invoices, credential theft, and business email compromise. Admins can assign monthly lessons, run simulated attacks, and see which users need more help, all from the same admin area used for Mimecast email security.

The strongest case for Mimecast is for teams that already use Mimecast to filter email. When training and email filtering share the same platform, admins can link a clicked phishing test to a follow up lesson, and managers can see risk in one place. The lessons are short enough to fit into a normal workday, which helps completion rates for busy staff in sales, finance, and operations.

The limit is scope. Mimecast Awareness Training is most useful as part of a wider Mimecast setup, and a team that wants a standalone training tool may find a simpler product easier to run. Mimecast does not publish a price for this module, so buyers need a quote based on user count and the Mimecast products they already use. Ask whether training is sold alone, what phishing templates are included, and how risk scores are calculated before you sign.

Pros:

  • Training sits with email security controls
  • short video lessons and phishing tests

Cons:

  • Best value depends on using Mimecast email security, so standalone buyers get less benefit

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Training inside an email security suite

3

Structured training paths and reporting

Infosec IQ

Infosec IQ is a training and phishing simulation platform from Infosec, built for teams that need structured courses, clear learning paths, and reports that support compliance work. Admins can assign courses by role, department, or risk level, run phishing simulations, and track progress across the whole organisation. The course library covers phishing, passwords, data protection, remote work, and other core awareness topics.

The platform suits IT leads and compliance owners who need evidence of training. Reports show course completion, phishing results, and user risk, which helps during internal reviews and external audits. Automated enrolment and reminders reduce manual work, while remedial training can follow a failed phishing test without extra admin steps. Content is available in several languages, which helps teams with staff in more than one country.

The main drawback is that Infosec does not publish a price for Infosec IQ, so cost depends on a quote for user count and selected features. The platform also has many options, and a team with only a few users may need time to choose the right courses and set up paths. Ask for a demo with your own user groups, a sample report, and a quote that lists exactly which courses and phishing features are included.

Pros:

  • Structured learning paths
  • detailed reporting for compliance and audit needs

Cons:

  • No public price, and the range of features can feel large for a very small team

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: infosecinstitute.com

Best for: Structured training paths and reporting

4

Short video based awareness training

NINJIO

NINJIO uses short animated video episodes to teach staff about phishing, social engineering, passwords, and other daily security risks. Each episode tells a story based on a real type of attack, which makes the lesson easier to remember than a long slide deck. New episodes arrive each month, so training stays current with new scams and attack methods, and admins can assign episodes and track who watched them.

The platform is a good fit for teams that want training staff will actually finish. Episodes are short, the tone is clear, and the admin work is light compared with a large learning platform. Phishing simulation is available to test whether staff apply what they learned, and reporting shows completion and risk by group. Small and midsize teams often choose NINJIO when they need a fast start without a long course build.

The limit is depth. NINJIO focuses on short video lessons, so teams that need long role based courses, detailed policy training, or complex custom learning paths may need another tool alongside it. NINJIO does not publish a price, so buyers need a quote for their user count. Ask how many episodes are included each month, whether phishing simulation is part of the base price, and how reporting handles users who miss a lesson.

Pros:

  • Short story based video lessons
  • simple setup and monthly release cycle

Cons:

  • Less depth for teams that need long role based courses or detailed custom paths

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ninjio.com

Best for: Short video based awareness training

5

Small teams that want published pricing

usecure

usecure combines automated training, phishing simulation, policy management, and breach monitoring in one plan for small teams and managed service providers. The platform includes uLearn for courses, uPhish for simulated phishing, uPolicy for policy acceptance, and uBreach for email breach checks. Admins can automate enrolment, assign personal learning paths, and track risk by user and company in one dashboard.

The pricing page states per user per month pricing, with monthly billing for managed service providers and annual billing for internal IT teams, but it does not show a numeric rate. That structure is still clearer than many rivals, because buyers know the model before they ask for a quote, and there is one plan rather than a set of add on bundles. The trial lets a team test the core features before committing, and setup is described as taking less than a day for most organisations.

The limit is that the exact cost still depends on user volume and plan terms, so a team cannot build a final budget from the pricing page alone. The uBreach Pro add on also uses pricing based on the number of domains monitored, which adds a separate cost to check. Ask for a written quote for your user count, confirm what the trial includes, and check whether breach monitoring for extra domains is part of your quote.

Pros:

  • One plan with training, phishing, policy, and breach checks
  • clear per user monthly model

Cons:

  • No numeric price on the pricing page, so the exact rate still needs a quote

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial

Website: usecure.io

Best for: Small teams that want published pricing

6

Managed awareness with concierge support

Arctic Wolf Managed Security Awareness

Arctic Wolf Managed Security Awareness is a managed training service for teams that want help running phishing tests, training, and reporting rather than doing all the work in house. The service includes training content, phishing simulation, and guidance from a concierge team that helps plan campaigns and review results. It sits alongside Arctic Wolf security operations services, which gives a team one partner for monitoring and awareness work.

The managed model fits small IT teams with limited time. Instead of building courses, scheduling tests, and chasing completion, admins can work with the concierge team to set a plan and review progress. Training is tied to real risk, so teams that face frequent phishing attempts can focus on the groups and behaviours that matter most. Reporting helps leaders see completion, phishing click rates, and risk trends over time.

The limit is cost and control. A managed service needs a quote, and the total cost depends on user count, service scope, and the wider Arctic Wolf services in use. Teams that prefer to run training themselves may find a self service tool faster and cheaper. Ask for a quote that lists the concierge hours, the training content included, how often phishing tests run, and what happens if a user misses a campaign.

Pros:

  • Managed service with concierge support
  • training linked to wider security operations

Cons:

  • Managed model costs more in time and budget than a self service training library

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: arcticwolf.com

Best for: Managed awareness with concierge support

7

Risk based training campaigns

Terranova Security

Terranova Security, part of Fortra, offers security awareness training and phishing simulation built around user risk. Admins can assess risk, assign training based on role and behaviour, and run phishing campaigns that match the threats a team faces. The content library covers phishing, passwords, data protection, and other core topics, with lessons in many languages for teams across regions.

The platform suits teams that want training to follow risk rather than a fixed calendar. High risk users can get more frequent lessons and tests, while low risk users follow a lighter path. Reporting shows risk by group, completion, and phishing results, which helps a security lead focus effort where it will reduce risk most. Automation can enrol users, send reminders, and assign follow up training after a failed test.

The main limit is setup. Risk based training works best when user groups, roles, and risk data are clear, so a team needs time to set those up at the start. Terranova Security does not publish a price, so buyers need a quote for user count and selected features. Ask for a demo using your own risk groups, a sample risk report, and a quote that states which phishing templates and languages are included.

Pros:

  • Risk based campaigns and phishing simulation
  • content in many languages

Cons:

  • No public price, and campaign setup needs clear user groups and risk data

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: terranovasecurity.com

Best for: Risk based training campaigns

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product pages, feature lists, and documentation for each tool in this guide, and we checked the usecure pricing page on 2026-11-14. We looked at phishing simulation, training format, course range, reporting, automation, language coverage, and admin effort. We did not claim hands-on testing, and we did not use customer counts, awards, or test results to rank the tools. Where a vendor did not publish a price, we wrote quote only and cited the vendor homepage or pricing page in Sources. The top pick reflects the widest fit for phishing simulation at scale, while the other tools lead for a specific need, such as a small team, a managed service, or training inside an email security suite.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Ask each vendor for a written quote for your exact user count, contract length, and included features, because none of the seven tools in this guide publishes a numeric price on the page we checked. Check what is included in the base price, such as phishing templates, course languages, reporting, and support hours, and ask what costs extra. Confirm how long setup takes, who builds the first phishing campaign, and how new users are enrolled. Check data handling, user sync with Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, and how reports support audits. Test the admin view and a sample lesson before you sign, and confirm renewal terms in writing.

Frequently asked questions

Is KnowBe4 the only option for security awareness training?

No. KnowBe4 is one of several established platforms, and the tools in this guide cover the same core needs in different ways. Proofpoint leads for large scale phishing simulation, Mimecast fits email security users, Infosec IQ fits structured paths, NINJIO fits short video lessons, and usecure fits small teams that want simple pricing and automation.

Which KnowBe4 alternative is best for a small business?

usecure is the best first look for a small business, because it combines training, phishing, policy, and breach checks in one plan with automation and a trial. NINJIO is also a good fit when short video lessons and a fast start matter more than a wide course library. Ask both vendors for a quote for your user count before you decide.

Do any of these alternatives publish a price?

No. None of the seven tools in this guide shows a numeric per user price on the vendor page we checked. usecure shows a per user per month model and annual billing for internal teams, but no numeric rate. The other vendors also use quote only pricing, so request a written quote with your user count and included features.

Can I run phishing simulation without a full training platform?

Yes, in most cases. Proofpoint, Mimecast, Infosec IQ, NINJIO, usecure, Arctic Wolf, and Terranova Security all include phishing simulation or offer it as part of their awareness service. Check whether simulation is included in the base quote or sold as an add on, and ask how templates, domains, and reporting work.

How long does it take to set up a KnowBe4 alternative?

Setup time varies by tool and team size. usecure states that most organisations deploy within a day. NINJIO and Terranova Security can also start quickly with a small user list. Proofpoint, Infosec IQ, and Arctic Wolf need more planning for user groups, roles, and reporting, so allow extra time for the first campaign.

Should I choose a managed awareness service or a self service tool?

Choose a managed service when your team has little time to run campaigns, build content, and chase completion. Arctic Wolf fits that need with concierge support. Choose a self service tool when you want direct control, a lower admin cost, and a faster change cycle. usecure, NINJIO, and Proofpoint give admins direct control over training and phishing tests.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides