Researched comparison
Best Mimecast Alternatives for Email Security
Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.
Proofpoint is the top pick for most teams moving from Mimecast because it covers inbound phishing, impersonation, and outbound data loss in one managed email security platform, with clear policy controls and reporting that suit regulated small firms. Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is the best choice for teams already committed to Microsoft 365.
Key takeaways
- Proofpoint suits teams that want broad email security, compliance controls, and managed detection in one platform.
- Microsoft Defender for Office 365 fits Microsoft 365 shops that want email protection inside a suite they already license.
- Barracuda Email Protection suits teams that want layered filtering, domain protection, and backup in one vendor relationship.
- Abnormal Security, Avanan, Cofense, and IRONSCALES each suit a narrower need, from AI impersonation defense to phishing response and simulation.
- Every vendor in this guide except Microsoft asks for a quote, so compare deployment effort, admin time, and contract terms before you sign.
Contents
Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.
Comparison at a glance
Comparison
| Tool | Best for | Price range | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proofpoint | Enterprise email security and compliance | quote only | No |
| Microsoft Defender for Office 365 | Microsoft 365 shops | $12 per user/month (billed annually) | No |
| Barracuda Email Protection | Layered email and domain security | quote only | No |
| Abnormal Security | AI-based business email compromise defense | quote only | No |
| Avanan | Inline email security in cloud mail | quote only | No |
| Cofense | Phishing defense and response | quote only | No |
| IRONSCALES | AI phishing detection with self-learning | quote only | No |
Ranked by tier
enterprise email security and compliance
Proofpoint
Proofpoint protects email with filtering for spam, malware, phishing, and impersonation, and it adds controls for outbound mail that help a small firm limit accidental data loss. The platform inspects links and attachments, checks sender identity, and applies policy by user group, so a finance team can have stricter rules than a general office group. Proofpoint also supports email continuity and archiving in related products, which helps a team keep mail flowing during an outage and keep records for later review. The main strength for a Mimecast switch is breadth. A team can replace several point controls with one vendor, one console, and one set of policies, and the reporting gives an IT lead a clear view of blocked threats, quarantined mail, and user risk. That layered view helps catch attacks that pass a simple spam filter, such as a fake invoice from a lookalike domain or a payroll change request from a spoofed executive address. Ask for a written list of included modules, the renewal terms, and the support hours in the quote, and check how long it takes to release a blocked message and train a new admin.
Pros:
- Broad threat protection across inbound and outbound mail
- compliance and data loss controls for regulated teams
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- the full platform can take real admin time to tune
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: proofpoint.com
Best for: enterprise email security and compliance
Microsoft 365 shops
Microsoft Defender for Office 365
Microsoft Defender for Office 365 adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments, and anti-phishing policies on top of the baseline Exchange Online Protection that comes with Microsoft 365. Safe Links checks a link at the time of click, and Safe Attachments opens an attachment in a virtual environment before delivery, which helps stop malicious files that look clean at first scan. For a team that already lives in Outlook and Teams, that native fit removes the need for a separate mail gateway in many cases. Plan 2 adds Threat Explorer, automated investigation and response, and attack simulation training. Threat Explorer lets an admin search mail flow, find every copy of a malicious message, and remove it from mailboxes after delivery. Automated investigation can review a suspicious message, check related mail, and take action without waiting for a human to open each case. Pricing needs care. The Microsoft pricing page opened today lists Microsoft Defender Suite at $12 per user per month, billed annually, and that suite includes Defender for Office 365 Plan 2, with a requirement for Microsoft 365 E3 or a matching base plan. The same page does not list standalone Plan 1 and Plan 2 prices, so confirm the current standalone price with Microsoft or a licensing partner before budgeting, and check current price for the exact plan and term.
Pros:
- Native protection inside Microsoft 365 mail, Teams, and SharePoint
- investigation tools in Plan 2
Cons:
- Standalone Plan 1 and Plan 2 prices are not listed on the Microsoft pricing page checked today
- the best fit depends on the Microsoft 365 plan already in use
Price: $12 per user/month (billed annually)
Free plan: No
Website: microsoft.com
Best for: Microsoft 365 shops
layered email and domain security
Barracuda Email Protection
Barracuda Email Protection filters inbound mail for spam, malware, phishing, and spoofing, and it adds impersonation protection that checks sender behavior and domain use. The service can flag a message that claims to come from a chief executive or a supplier but arrives from an unusual domain or shows unusual writing patterns. That check helps a small firm that receives payment requests, invoice changes, and wire instructions by email, because those messages are the most common target for fraud. The platform suits teams that want one vendor for several email risks. In addition to gateway filtering, Barracuda offers incident response tools that can find and remove malicious mail after delivery, plus backup and archiving products that sit beside the security service. A team can therefore keep mail protection, mail backup, and mail records under one support contract, which can cut the number of vendors an IT lead must manage. Ask for a written module list, the retention period for backup and archiving if included, the support response time, and the contract length, and ask how fast a blocked invoice can be released.
Pros:
- Combines gateway filtering, impersonation defense, and domain fraud protection
- backup and archiving options in the same vendor family
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- the product family has several modules, so the quoted scope needs close reading
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: barracuda.com
Best for: layered email and domain security
AI-based business email compromise defense
Abnormal Security
Abnormal Security uses behavioral AI to learn how people in a company normally write, who they normally email, and which suppliers they normally pay. When a message breaks that pattern, the system can flag it as a possible business email compromise attempt, even if the message has no malicious link or attachment. That approach helps against plain-text fraud, such as a fake request to change bank details, a fake gift card request, or a fake invoice from a supplier the team knows. Those messages often pass a traditional spam filter because they contain no malware, so a behavior check adds a useful second layer. The platform also watches for account takeover, vendor fraud, and internal mail risks. Abnormal integrates with Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, and it works after mail delivery, so it can remove a malicious message from mailboxes and alert the people who received it. Ask for a written list of included modules, the time to value during a pilot, and the false positive rate the vendor expects in the first month.
Pros:
- Behavioral AI that learns normal sender patterns
- strong focus on impersonation and supplier fraud
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- the focus on inbound social engineering means a team may still need separate outbound controls
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: abnormalsecurity.com
Best for: AI-based business email compromise defense
inline email security in cloud mail
Avanan
Avanan, now part of Check Point, protects cloud mail by connecting through the Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace API, rather than by rerouting mail through a separate gateway. That design means mail flow stays direct, and the service can scan a message after delivery, quarantine it, and remove it from mailboxes if a later check finds a threat. For a small team that wants extra email security without changing mail records or adding a new mail hop, that API model is a practical fit. The service focuses on phishing, malware, and account takeover in cloud mail. It can flag a compromised account that starts sending spam, a malicious link in a shared document, or a phishing message that passed the built-in filter. The admin console shows quarantined mail, user risk, and incident history, and it lets an admin release a message, block a sender, or search for every copy of a threat across mailboxes. Ask for the price per user, the minimum user count, and the support level in the quote, and ask how long a scan takes after delivery and what happens during a Microsoft 365 outage.
Pros:
- Inline protection inside Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace mail
- API-based setup with no mail routing change
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- protection is tied to the cloud mail platform, so on-premises mail needs a different plan
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: avanan.com
Best for: inline email security in cloud mail
phishing defense and response
Cofense
Cofense combines phishing detection with a user reporting button, a phishing simulation program, and an incident response workflow. Staff can report a suspicious message with one click, and the platform can collect those reports, group similar messages, and help an admin find every copy in the company. That crowd-sourced signal helps catch phishing mail that slips past a filter, because a user often spots a strange request before a machine does. The simulation program sends test phishing mail, measures clicks and reports, and assigns training to the people who need it, which helps a team improve over time rather than relying on one training session. The detection side uses machine learning and human review to check reported mail, and the response side can quarantine or remove confirmed phishing mail from mailboxes. Ask for the price per user, the included modules, and the minimum term, and ask how long a reported message takes to reach a verdict and what training content is included for new staff.
Pros:
- Phishing detection plus user reporting and incident response in one workflow
- simulation and training for staff
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- the full value depends on staff reporting mail, so a team with low reporting rates will see less benefit
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: cofense.com
Best for: phishing defense and response
AI phishing detection with self-learning
IRONSCALES
IRONSCALES uses AI that learns the normal mail patterns for each user, including who they email, what they click, and how they write. When a message breaks that pattern, the system can flag it, quarantine it, or remove it from the mailbox, and it can learn from the admin decision to improve the next verdict. That self-learning approach helps against new phishing lures, because the system does not rely only on a fixed list of known bad senders or links. The platform includes a user reporting button, phishing simulation, and automated remediation. Staff can report a message with one click, and the system can search for similar messages across the company and remove them. Simulation lets an admin test staff with realistic phishing mail, measure who clicks and who reports, and assign training based on the result. Ask for the price per user, the minimum user count, and the modules in the quote, and ask how long the learning period lasts and what support is included during the first month.
Pros:
- Self-learning AI that adapts to each mailbox
- user reporting and automated remediation in one flow
Cons:
- Quote-only pricing makes early budgeting hard
- the AI needs time and mail volume to learn normal patterns, so early results may vary
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: ironscales.com
Best for: AI phishing detection with self-learning
How we choose
How we choose
We compared vendor pricing pages, product pages, and documentation for each tool in this guide, and we checked the feature list for inbound filtering, impersonation defense, link and attachment checks, post-delivery removal, and admin reporting. We looked for tools that serve small SaaS companies and professional firms, not only large enterprises, and we favored tools that work with Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, because that is where most small teams keep mail. We did not claim hands-on testing, and we did not use customer counts, awards, or test results to rank the tools. Where a vendor hides the price, we wrote quote only and told the reader to confirm the price in writing.
Buyers guide
Start with mail flow, not with a feature list. Confirm if the tool works as a gateway, as an API layer inside cloud mail, or as a post-delivery service, and confirm what happens to mail if the vendor service has an outage. Check the time to release a blocked invoice, the time to remove a malicious message from every mailbox, and the time to add an allow rule for a new supplier. Ask for the support hours, the response time for a phishing incident, and the person who will help during setup. Read the contract for the renewal price, the minimum term, and the cost to add users mid-term, and keep a copy of the quoted module list with the signed order.
Frequently asked questions
Is Proofpoint a good Mimecast replacement for a small firm?
Yes, for many small firms, because Proofpoint covers inbound phishing, impersonation, and outbound data loss in one platform, with policy controls by user group. The main trade is cost clarity, because pricing is quote only, and setup time, because the platform has many settings. Ask for a written module list and a pilot before you commit.
Does Microsoft Defender for Office 365 replace a separate email gateway?
It can, for many Microsoft 365 shops, because it adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments, and anti-phishing policies inside the mail service, plus investigation tools in Plan 2. A team that needs outbound data loss controls, archiving, or mail continuity may still need a second product. Check the Microsoft 365 plan already held before buying a separate add-on.
What is the difference between Abnormal Security and IRONSCALES?
Both use AI to spot phishing, but Abnormal focuses on behavioral patterns for business email compromise and supplier fraud, while IRONSCALES focuses on self-learning detection per mailbox, user reporting, and automated remediation. A team worried about fake payment requests may favor Abnormal, while a team that wants simulation and reporting may favor IRONSCALES.
How long does it take to switch from Mimecast to a new email security tool?
A simple API-based tool can start in days, while a gateway change can take one to three weeks, because mail records, policies, allow lists, and quarantine rules must move and be tested. Plan a parallel run, move one department first, and keep the old service active until the new tool has handled real mail for at least one full week.
Do I still need staff training if I buy an AI phishing tool?
Yes. AI can block many threats, but staff still receive plain-text fraud, new supplier requests, and unusual payment changes that a filter may miss. A short simulation program, a clear reporting button, and a regular reminder help staff report mail fast, and that reporting gives the tool more signals to learn from.
How do I compare quote-only email security prices fairly?
Ask each vendor for the same written scope, with user count, modules, support level, term, and renewal price listed in the same format. Then compare the cost per user per year, the time to set up, and the admin hours needed each week. A lower quote that omits incident response or archiving is not the same product as a higher quote that includes them.