Researched comparison

Best Proofpoint Alternatives for Email Security

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Mimecast is the best Proofpoint alternative for most teams because it pairs a cloud email gateway with archiving, continuity, and impersonation protection in one console. Microsoft 365 shops that want the lowest added cost should start with Defender for Office 365 Plan 1, while teams that need AI-led business email compromise defense should shortlist Abnormal Security.

Key takeaways

  • Mimecast leads for teams that want gateway protection plus archiving and continuity in one service.
  • Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is already included in Business Premium and E3, and the Defender Suite at $12.00 per user per month, billed annually, includes Plan 2.
  • Abnormal Security, Avanan, and IRONSCALES protect mail inside the mailbox through APIs instead of rerouting mail.
  • Every vendor except Microsoft hides list prices, so ask each vendor for a quote on the same user count and features before you compare totals.
  • Cofense adds the human side, with phishing simulation and fast removal of reported messages from every mailbox.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
MimecastEmail security with archivingquote onlyNo
Microsoft Defender for Office 365Microsoft 365 shops$12.00 per user/month (Defender Suite, includes Plan 2)Free trial (90 days)
Abnormal SecurityAI-based business email compromise defensequote onlyNo
Barracuda Email ProtectionLayered email and domain securityquote onlyNo
AvananInline email security in cloud mailquote onlyNo
CofensePhishing defense and responsequote onlyNo
IRONSCALESAI phishing detection with self-learningquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

Email security with archiving

Mimecast

Mimecast runs as a cloud email gateway in front of Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and filters inbound and outbound mail before it reaches the inbox. Its URL Protect service rewrites links and checks them at click time, while Attachment Protect opens files in a sandbox to catch malware that static scans miss. Impersonation protection watches for lookalike domains and display name spoofing, and the same console covers archiving and continuity, so mail stays searchable and reachable during an outage.

The archive is the feature that sets Mimecast apart from a gateway alone. Every message is stored with its attachments, and staff can search years of mail when a dispute, audit, or legal request arrives. Continuity keeps a webmail view running when Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace is down, so a small team can keep working. Admins manage policies, quarantine, and reporting from one dashboard instead of three separate products.

Mimecast fits teams that want one vendor for gateway filtering, archive, and continuity rather than three contracts. The limit to plan around is price transparency. Mimecast does not publish list prices, so a quote depends on user count, archive retention, and the tiers you select. Ask for the price of the full bundle, including archive storage and continuity, and confirm which features need the higher tier before you sign.

Pros:

  • Cloud gateway with archiving and continuity in one service
  • URL and attachment checks plus impersonation protection

Cons:

  • No public list price, so budgeting needs a vendor quote
  • some archive and continuity features sit in higher tiers

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Email security with archiving

2

Microsoft 365 shops

Microsoft Defender for Office 365

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is built into the Microsoft 365 platform, so there is no separate gateway to route mail through. Plan 1 adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments, anti-phishing policies, impersonation protection, and real-time detections on top of Exchange Online Protection. Plan 2 adds Threat Explorer, automated investigation and response, attack simulation training, and priority account protection. Plan 1 is included in Business Premium and in Microsoft 365 E3 and Office 365 E3, while Plan 2 is included in E5.

Microsoft no longer publishes standalone add-on prices for Plan 1 and Plan 2 on its pricing page. The published figure is the Defender Suite at $12.00 per user per month, billed annually, which includes Plan 2. Plan 1 is already included in Business Premium and E3, so many Microsoft 365 shops already have Safe Links and Safe Attachments without a second vendor. Admins work in the Microsoft Defender portal, where policies, quarantine, and alerts sit beside endpoint and identity signals.

The limit is scope. Defender for Office 365 protects mail inside Microsoft 365 services such as Exchange Online, SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams, and it is not a gateway for Google Workspace mail. The preset Standard and Strict policies are a sound start, but review them against your own sender lists and quarantine habits. Plan 2 only earns its price when someone uses Threat Explorer, automated investigation, and attack simulation regularly.

Pros:

  • Built into Microsoft 365 with no gateway to manage
  • Plan 1 included in Business Premium and E3

Cons:

  • Protects mail inside Microsoft 365 only, so it is not a gateway for Google Workspace mail
  • Plan 2 investigation tools need staff time to use well

Price: $12.00 per user/month (Defender Suite, includes Plan 2)

Free plan: Free trial (90 days)

Website: microsoft.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 shops

3

AI-based business email compromise defense

Abnormal Security

Abnormal Security connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through APIs and reads mail after it passes the native filters, so there is no change to mail routing and no gateway to manage. Its behavioral AI builds a profile of how each person, vendor, and partner normally writes, then flags messages that break the pattern. That design targets business email compromise, vendor email compromise, and account takeover, the attacks that pass spam filters because they carry no malware and no bad link.

When Abnormal flags a message it can remove it from the inbox, add a warning banner, or hold it for review. The console shows why a message scored as risky, which helps a small team explain a decision to a user. Because the product learns from your own mail, it keeps working when attackers change domains or wording.

Abnormal fits teams that already run Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and want a second layer aimed at social engineering. The limit is that it sits behind the native filters, so it does not replace them, and it does not archive mail or add continuity. Pricing is quote only, so ask how the quote scales with user count and which detection modules are included at each tier.

Pros:

  • API-based deployment with no change to mail routing
  • behavioral AI targets business email compromise and account takeover

Cons:

  • Sits behind the native filters, so it does not replace them
  • no archiving or continuity included

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: abnormalsecurity.com

Best for: AI-based business email compromise defense

4

Layered email and domain security

Barracuda Email Protection

Barracuda Email Protection combines a cloud gateway with AI phishing defense, incident response, and domain fraud protection. The gateway filters spam, malware, and phishing before mail reaches the inbox, and incident response tools search mailboxes for messages that slipped through so admins can remove them after delivery. Domain fraud protection covers DMARC reporting and brand impersonation for firms whose name is used in spoofed invoices.

The Total Email Protection bundle brings the gateway, incident response, archiving, and security awareness training under one license. Admins can run the service for Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, or on-premises mail, and the console includes quarantine, reporting, and policy controls. Confirm that a quote covers email protection only, since Barracuda also sells a separate data protection line.

Barracuda fits mid-size teams that want gateway filtering plus post-delivery cleanup without a separate incident response tool. The limit is tiering. Some of the stronger features, including full incident response and archiving, sit in the higher bundle, and the base gateway alone does not include them. Pricing is quote only, so ask for the bundle price at your user count and check what the base tier leaves out.

Pros:

  • Gateway filtering plus post-delivery incident response
  • domain fraud protection with DMARC reporting

Cons:

  • Stronger features such as full incident response and archiving sit in the higher bundle
  • base gateway alone does not include them

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: barracuda.com

Best for: Layered email and domain security

5

Inline email security in cloud mail

Avanan

Avanan, now part of Check Point, protects cloud mail through APIs instead of a gateway. It connects to Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, and tools such as Slack and Teams, then scans mail, files, and links inside the mailbox. Its anti-phishing engine uses natural language checks and sandbox detonation, and it can quarantine a message after delivery when a link turns malicious later. Deployment is quick because there is no change to mail flow.

Avanan also covers data loss prevention and malware in shared drives, which helps teams that share files through cloud storage. Admins see detections in one console and can set policies per group, so finance staff can get stricter attachment rules. The product works beside Microsoft Defender for Office 365, adding a second opinion on messages that the native filters pass.

Avanan fits teams that want inline protection without rerouting mail and run several cloud apps at once. The limit is dependence on cloud APIs. If an API is slow or a permission is revoked, scanning can lag, and the product does not add archiving or continuity. Pricing is quote only, so ask which apps and protections are included, and confirm the cost as user count grows.

Pros:

  • API-based inline protection with no change to mail flow
  • covers mail, files, and links across cloud apps

Cons:

  • Depends on cloud APIs, so scanning can lag if an API is slow or a permission is revoked
  • no archiving or continuity

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: avanan.com

Best for: Inline email security in cloud mail

6

Phishing defense and response

Cofense

Cofense builds its email security around phishing defense and response. Cofense PhishMe runs phishing simulations and training so staff learn to report suspicious mail, while Cofense Triage clusters user-reported messages and helps analysts remove real threats from every mailbox at once. Its phishing defense center is staffed by analysts who review reported mail around the clock and share findings with customers.

The strength of Cofense is the loop between people and technology. Simulations show which teams click, training targets the staff who need it, and Triage turns reports into action. Admins can search mailboxes for a malicious message and delete it from all of them in one step, which cuts the time a phishing mail stays live after the first report.

Cofense fits teams that want to cut phishing risk through reporting and fast response. The limit is that it is not a full gateway on its own. Most buyers run Cofense beside a gateway or beside Defender for Office 365, and the simulation and Triage products are licensed separately. Pricing is quote only, so ask for the combined cost of the products you plan to run and the cost of the analyst service.

Pros:

  • Phishing simulation and training tied to fast triage and removal
  • analyst-reviewed threat intelligence

Cons:

  • Not a full gateway on its own, so most buyers run it beside a gateway or Defender
  • simulation and triage are licensed separately

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: cofense.com

Best for: Phishing defense and response

7

AI phishing detection with self-learning

IRONSCALES

IRONSCALES protects Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace mailboxes with AI phishing detection that learns from each mailbox. Its self-learning engine studies how people in your company write and which senders they trust, then flags anomalies such as a supplier writing from a new domain or a request that breaks the usual pattern. It also runs phishing simulation and security awareness training, and it can remove a malicious message from every mailbox once one user reports it.

Themis AI, the product assistant, explains why a message was flagged and drafts the reply to the user who reported it. Admins can run simulations, track who clicks, and assign training to the staff who need it most. Because the product works through APIs, there is no gateway to configure and no change to mail routing.

IRONSCALES fits small and mid-size teams that want AI-led phishing detection plus simulation in one product with less administration than a gateway. The limit is vendor scale. IRONSCALES is smaller than Mimecast or Microsoft, and some advanced reporting and training content sit in higher tiers. Pricing is quote only, so ask which tiers include simulation, training, and Themis AI, and confirm the cost at your user count.

Pros:

  • Self-learning AI that adapts to how your people write
  • simulation and training in the same product

Cons:

  • Smaller vendor than Mimecast or Microsoft
  • some advanced reporting and training content sit in higher tiers

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ironscales.com

Best for: AI phishing detection with self-learning

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and plan pages, and we checked which features sit in the base tier and which need a higher tier. We looked at deployment style, gateway or API based, and coverage for phishing, business email compromise, archiving, continuity, and incident response. We did not claim hands-on testing, and we did not use customer counts, awards, or review scores to rank the tools. Prices in this article come from the vendor pricing page named in Sources. Where a vendor publishes no list price, we wrote quote only instead of repeating a third-party estimate.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Start with your mail platform and user count, then ask each vendor for a quote on the same scope. Confirm which tier includes archiving, continuity, incident response, and simulation, because those features move between tiers more often than the core filter. Ask how long a trial runs, what happens to quarantine and archive data when a contract ends, and who responds when a phishing mail reaches an inbox. Check that the tool supports your mail platform, your identity provider, and your reporting needs before you sign.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Proofpoint alternative for a small business?

Mimecast is the best fit for a small business that wants a gateway, archiving, and continuity from one vendor. If the business already runs Microsoft 365, Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 is the cheaper start, since it is already included in Business Premium and E3, and the Defender Suite at $12.00 per user per month includes Plan 2. IRONSCALES is a sound third choice for a small team that wants AI phishing detection with simulation and little administration.

How much does Microsoft Defender for Office 365 cost?

Microsoft no longer publishes standalone add-on prices for Plan 1 and Plan 2. Plan 1 is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and in Microsoft 365 E3 and Office 365 E3. Plan 2 is included in Microsoft 365 E5 and in the Defender Suite at $12.00 per user per month, billed annually. Microsoft also offers a 90-day trial of Plan 2 through the Microsoft Defender portal.

Do I still need a gateway if I use Microsoft Defender for Office 365?

Many Microsoft 365 teams run Defender for Office 365 alone and find Plan 1 covers the core phishing and malware risk. A gateway or an API-based layer adds value when you need archiving, continuity, post-delivery incident response, or stronger business email compromise defense. A team on Google Workspace still needs a gateway or an API-based tool, because Defender for Office 365 does not protect Google Workspace mail.

What is the difference between a gateway and an API-based email security tool?

A gateway reroutes mail through the vendor cloud before delivery, so it can block a message before it reaches the inbox. An API-based tool reads mail inside the mailbox after the native filters have run, so it can catch business email compromise and remove a message after delivery. Gateways add archiving and continuity more often, while API tools deploy faster and add a second opinion on social engineering.

Can I replace Proofpoint with one tool?

Yes, for most teams. Mimecast replaces the gateway, archiving, and continuity in one contract, while Defender for Office 365 replaces the core filtering for a Microsoft 365 shop. Teams that also need phishing simulation should add Cofense or IRONSCALES, and teams that need stronger business email compromise defense should add Abnormal Security. Run a trial on your own mail before you sign.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides