Researched comparison

Top Email Security Software for Law Firms

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

Mimecast Advanced Email Security is the top pick for most law firms because it combines gateway filtering, archiving and continuity in one contract, which matches a firm retention duty. Firms already on Microsoft 365 can start with Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 at $2 per user each month.

Key takeaways

  • A law firm needs email security that protects privilege and client confidentiality, not just spam filtering, so archiving, encryption and BEC defense matter as much as malware blocking.
  • Mimecast leads because archiving, continuity and gateway security sit in one contract, which fits retention duties and keeps mail running during an outage.
  • Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 at $2 per user each month is the lowest cost start for firms already on Microsoft 365, while Hornetsecurity starts at 2.75 euros per user each month.
  • Five of the eight tools publish no list price, so ask each vendor for a written quote that covers archiving, retention length, litigation hold and data residency before signing.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
Mimecast Advanced Email SecurityArchiving, continuity and gateway securityquote onlyNo
Proofpoint EssentialsBEC and phishing defense, tiered plansquote onlyFree trial (30 days)
Microsoft Defender for Office 365Firms already on Microsoft 365$2 per user/month (billed annually)No
Barracuda Email ProtectionMulti-tenant management for small firmsquote onlyFree trial (30 days)
Hornetsecurity 365 Total ProtectionMicrosoft 365 security, clear euro pricing2.75 euros per user/monthFree trial (30 days)
Abnormal SecurityBehavioural AI against BEC and vendor fraudquote onlyNo
IRONSCALESPhishing response, simulation and trainingquote onlyNo
PauboxEncrypted email with no recipient portal$29 per month (up to 5 senders, billed annually)Free trial (14 days)

Ranked by tier

1

Archiving, continuity and gateway security in one contract

Mimecast Advanced Email Security

Mimecast Advanced Email Security sits in front of a firm mail system and checks every inbound and outbound message for phishing links, malicious attachments and impersonation before delivery. Its URL rewriting and attachment sandboxing catch threats that change after delivery. Archiving is built into the same platform, so every message is stored in a tamper evident archive with search and legal hold, and continuity keeps mail flowing during an outage.

For a firm, the value is the single contract that covers security, archiving and continuity together, which simplifies vendor review and gives one place to prove retention. A firm that loses a message thread or cannot produce it in discovery faces real risk. Mimecast fits firms that want that coverage from one vendor, and its admin console gives one place to set policy, run archive searches and place holds across the firm.

Pros:

  • Gateway filtering, archiving and continuity in one contract
  • strong URL rewriting and attachment sandboxing

Cons:

  • No public per-user price, so a firm must request a quote to budget the contract

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: mimecast.com

Best for: Archiving, continuity and gateway security in one contract

2

BEC and phishing defense with tiered plans

Proofpoint Essentials

Proofpoint Essentials gives a law firm layered protection against the attacks that target lawyers most often, including business email compromise, credential phishing and invoice fraud. Its tiered plans let a firm start with filtering and add data loss prevention, encryption and archiving as needs grow. The platform checks sender reputation, message content and links, and it can quarantine suspect mail before it reaches a partner inbox.

A firm that handles wire instructions, settlement funds or trust account transfers needs BEC defense more than most businesses, because one redirected payment can trigger a claim and a bar complaint. Proofpoint has spent years building detection for exactly that kind of impersonation, including display name spoofing. The trade off is price opacity, so a firm should ask for a quote that names each tier, the archiving retention period, and any per user minimums.

Pros:

  • Long track record against BEC and phishing
  • tiered plans from basic filtering to DLP and archiving

Cons:

  • No list price on the vendor site, so costs only appear in a written quote

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: BEC and phishing defense with tiered plans

3

Firms already on Microsoft 365

Microsoft Defender for Office 365

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is the natural starting point for a firm that already runs on Microsoft 365, because it adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments and anti-phishing policies on top of the Exchange Online Protection that comes with every subscription. Safe Links rewrites URLs and checks them at click time, while Safe Attachments opens files in a sandbox before delivery, which protects lawyers who open attachments all day.

The $2 per user each month Plan 1 price makes Defender the cheapest entry point in this list, and Plan 1 is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and Microsoft 365 E3. The limit is scope, because Plan 1 does not include archiving or the Threat Explorer and automated investigation tools that arrive in Plan 2 at $5 per user each month. A firm that needs long retention or deep BEC investigation should pair Defender with a dedicated archiving layer.

Pros:

  • Native in Microsoft 365 with no extra gateway to manage
  • Plan 1 includes Safe Links and Safe Attachments

Cons:

  • Plan 2 investigation tools cost more, at $5 per user each month

Price: $2 per user/month (billed annually)

Free plan: No

Website: microsoft.com

Best for: Firms already on Microsoft 365

4

Multi-tenant management for small firms

Barracuda Email Protection

Barracuda Email Protection gives a small firm gateway filtering, account takeover detection and automated remediation in a console built for lean teams. It connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through an API, so deployment takes minutes and there is no mail routing change to plan around. When a message turns malicious after delivery, the platform can pull it from every mailbox at once, which limits how far a phishing campaign spreads inside a firm.

The multi-tenant portal suits firms that run several offices or that outsource IT to a managed provider, because policy and quarantine can be managed from one view. Archiving is available in higher tiers, with tamper proof archiving and point in time restore in the wider platform, but those tiers are quote based. A firm should confirm in writing which tier includes archiving and what the retention limit is, because filtering alone does not cover a retention duty.

Pros:

  • Multi-tenant portal for small firms and managed providers
  • connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace without MX changes

Cons:

  • Premium tiers with backup and archiving are quote based, so the full cost is unclear until a quote arrives

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: barracuda.com

Best for: Multi-tenant management for small firms

5

Microsoft 365 security with clear euro pricing

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection

Hornetsecurity 365 Total Protection is a suite for Microsoft 365 that starts with spam, malware and phishing filtering and adds advanced threat protection, sandboxing, URL rewriting and BEC detection. Higher plans add email archiving, backup for mailboxes and OneDrive, permission audits and security awareness training, which lets a firm build one Microsoft 365 security stack from a single vendor. The platform also handles DMARC reporting, which helps a firm protect its domain from spoofing.

The published entry price of 2.75 euros per user each month makes budgeting simple for a firm that bills in euros. The trade off is that the entry tier does not include the backup and compliance features a firm needs for retention, so the real comparison price is the higher tier that includes archiving. A firm should ask which plan covers email archiving, how long archived mail is kept, and where data is stored.

Pros:

  • Clear published pricing in euros for Microsoft 365
  • plans add backup, compliance and awareness training

Cons:

  • Prices are in euros, and backup and compliance sit in higher tiers

Price: 2.75 euros per user/month

Free plan: Free trial (30 days)

Website: hornetsecurity.com

Best for: Microsoft 365 security with clear euro pricing

6

Behavioural AI against BEC and vendor fraud

Abnormal Security

Abnormal Security connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace through an API and studies how each person in a firm normally writes, who they write to, and what kinds of requests they usually make. That behavioural baseline lets it flag the subtle attacks that pass a gateway, such as a message that looks like a partner asking an associate to wire settlement funds. Because it works inside the mailbox, it can find and remove malicious messages after delivery.

For a law firm, the main draw is protection against BEC and vendor fraud, which can cause a direct financial loss and a client claim. A firm that moves client funds, handles escrow, or pays expert witnesses by wire is a natural target, and one successful impersonation can cost far more than a year of cover. The limit is that Abnormal is not a full gateway replacement, and its quote only pricing means a small firm should ask whether there is a minimum user count.

Pros:

  • API based deployment with no MX change
  • behavioural AI that learns normal communication patterns

Cons:

  • No public price and no free tier, so a small firm cannot test cost without a sales conversation

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: abnormal.ai

Best for: Behavioural AI against BEC and vendor fraud

7

Phishing response, simulation and training

IRONSCALES

IRONSCALES is an AI email security platform that works inside Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace through a native API, learning how a firm actually communicates and then flagging targeted phishing, BEC, account takeover and deepfake attempts. Its Phishing SOC Agent investigates messages that staff report with one click, attaches the evidence, and removes the same threat from other mailboxes. Simulation and training are built in, so the firm can test staff with realistic lures.

That incident response loop is the reason a firm with a small IT team should look at IRONSCALES, because phishing reports that sit in an inbox for hours are the ones that cause damage. The platform also supports multi-tenant management, which helps firms using a managed provider. The limit is scope, since IRONSCALES describes itself as an addition to native Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace security rather than a replacement gateway, and pricing is quote only.

Pros:

  • One-click phishing incident response with simulation and training included
  • API deployment with no MX change

Cons:

  • No public price, and the focus on phishing means it is not a full gateway replacement

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ironscales.com

Best for: Phishing response, simulation and training

8

Encrypted email with no recipient portal

Paubox

Paubox encrypts outbound email automatically, so a lawyer can send a message with client details to a client, a court or opposing counsel without asking the recipient to log into a portal, create a password or take extra steps. That matters because clients often ignore portal invitations. Paubox works with Google Workspace, Microsoft 365 and Exchange, and every plan includes a business associate agreement, which shows the vendor is built for regulated senders.

The starting price of $29 per month covers up to 5 senders on annual billing, which makes Paubox the simplest option for a solo lawyer or a very small firm that needs encryption first and gateway filtering second. The limit is that Paubox is an encryption product with inbound security as a companion, not a full gateway replacement, so a firm still needs filtering from another layer. A firm with more than 5 senders should ask for a quote and confirm what is included.

Pros:

  • Email encryption with no portal or extra steps for recipients
  • works with Gmail, Outlook and Exchange

Cons:

  • Encryption focus means it is not a full gateway replacement, and the price comes from a quote for larger sender counts

Price: $29 per month (up to 5 senders, billed annually)

Free plan: Free trial (14 days)

Website: paubox.com

Best for: Encrypted email with no recipient portal

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation and feature lists for eight email security tools, and we checked each starting price on the vendor site on 15 November 2026. Where a vendor publishes no list price, we record quote only rather than repeating a third party listing, because a firm cannot budget from a reseller figure. We weighed archiving and litigation hold, BEC defense, encryption, continuity during an outage, and admin effort for a small team. We did not run hands-on tests.

Our full method

Buyers guide

  • Ask for the retention period in writing, and confirm that archiving covers every mailbox, including shared mailboxes and leavers, with litigation hold a partner can place.
  • Confirm where email and archives are stored, which data residency options exist, and whether the vendor will sign a data processing addendum.
  • Check how BEC is handled, including display name spoofing, lookalike domains and wire instruction changes, because those attacks cause the largest losses for firms.
  • Ask whether the price covers every user or only mailboxes, whether there is a minimum user count, and what the renewal price will be.
  • Test the quarantine and release workflow with real lawyers, because a tool that blocks client mail or court filings will be bypassed.
  • Confirm the exit terms, including how the firm exports its archive and how long the vendor keeps data after the contract ends.

Frequently asked questions

Do law firms need email archiving as well as spam filtering?

Yes, because a firm retention duty covers client mail, and a spam filter alone does not keep a searchable record of what was sent and received. Archiving stores every message in a tamper evident store with search and legal hold, so the firm can answer a discovery request, a bar inquiry or a client dispute with the actual message thread.

What is business email compromise and why does it hit law firms?

Business email compromise is an attack where a criminal impersonates a partner, a client or a vendor and asks for a wire transfer, a change of bank details or sensitive matter information. Law firms are targets because they move settlement funds, hold client money and send wire instructions by email, so one successful impersonation can cause a direct financial loss and a client claim.

Can a firm rely on Microsoft 365 built-in protection alone?

It can be a starting point, but built-in Exchange Online Protection covers baseline spam and malware filtering, not the advanced phishing and BEC attacks that target firms. Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 at $2 per user each month adds Safe Links, Safe Attachments and anti-phishing policies, and many firms also add archiving or an API based layer for BEC and post-delivery removal.

How long should a firm retain client email?

The right period depends on the jurisdiction, the matter type and the firm policy, and many firms keep client mail for several years after a matter closes. The key point is to set the period in writing, apply it to every mailbox, and choose a tool that enforces it with archiving and litigation hold, then confirm the tool can hold mail for that full period without extra storage fees.

Does email encryption replace a secure email gateway?

No, because encryption protects a message in transit and at rest, while a gateway blocks phishing, malware and impersonation before delivery. A firm needs both, since an encrypted phishing message is still a phishing message. Paubox covers the encryption side with no recipient portal, while Mimecast, Proofpoint, Defender and the other gateway tools in this list cover filtering.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides