Researched comparison
Top NYDFS Compliance Software for Startups
Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.
Vanta is the top pick for startups working toward NYDFS compliance, because it maps 23 NYCRR 500 controls to the cloud and identity systems a startup already runs, tests those controls continuously, and keeps the evidence behind the annual certification in one place.
Key takeaways
- Vanta leads for startups because it pairs 23 NYCRR 500 coverage with continuous control testing and a 7-day trial.
- NYDFS requires an annual certification, a risk assessment, multi-factor authentication, and incident notification within 72 hours.
- Secureframe starts at $7,500 per year and suits teams that want a fixed starting price and guided onboarding.
- 6clicks starts at $4,800 per year and fits teams that need a risk register and third-party vendor checks in one tool.
- No tool files the annual certification for you, so a named person must still own the program and sign the filing.
Contents
Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.
Comparison at a glance
Comparison
| Tool | Best for | Price range | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vanta | Continuous testing across cloud and identity | quote only | Free trial (7 days) |
| Drata | Continuous monitoring for NYDFS controls | quote only | No |
| Secureframe | A published price and a fast first certification | $7,500 per year | No |
| 6clicks | Risk registers and third-party risk in one tool | $4,800 per year | Free trial |
| Strike Graph | Audit-ready evidence for a fixed scope | $21,500 per year | No |
| Thoropass | An audit package with a set price | $8,995 per year | No |
| Hyperproof | Control tracking across many frameworks | quote only | No |
| LogicGate | Risk workflows built around your own process | quote only | No |
Ranked by tier
Continuous testing across cloud and identity
Vanta
Vanta connects to the cloud services, code repositories, and identity tools a startup already runs, then tests controls continuously and flags gaps before an auditor does. For NYDFS work, its framework library includes 23 NYCRR 500, so a team can map each control to the regulation, attach evidence, and track the multi-factor authentication and access review duties the regulation requires. The platform keeps evidence in one place for the whole team, which matters when the annual certification asks for proof across many controls.
Vanta does not file the annual certification, and it does not replace legal advice on which NYDFS duties apply to a particular license. A startup still needs a person who owns the risk assessment and signs off on the certification. Pricing is quote only, so check current price before budgeting, and the 7-day trial gives a short window to test the integrations. Teams that need a published starting price will find the quote-only model a drawback, since planning a first-year budget takes an extra sales call.
Pros:
- Continuous control testing across more than 300 integrations
- framework library covers NYDFS alongside ISO 27001 and SOC 2
Cons:
- No published starting price, so budgeting needs a sales call
Price: quote only
Free plan: Free trial (7 days)
Website: vanta.com
Best for: Continuous testing across cloud and identity
Continuous monitoring for NYDFS controls
Drata
Drata watches the systems a startup already uses and tests controls around the clock, so a team sees a failing control the day it breaks rather than at certification time. For NYDFS work, Drata maps controls to 23 NYCRR 500 alongside the frameworks a startup already tracks, which keeps the risk assessment, the evidence trail, and the control tests in one system. The control library covers the access, encryption, and third-party duties the regulation calls out, so a team preparing for certification can reuse the same evidence it uses for SOC 2.
Drata does not file the annual certification, and it does not draft the risk assessment or the incident response plan the regulation requires. A startup still needs someone who understands its own systems to write those records and own the program. Pricing is quote only, so check current price before budgeting, and the absence of a free plan or trial means a team commits before testing the platform in its own stack.
Pros:
- Strong continuous monitoring across cloud and identity systems
- control mapping across many frameworks at once
Cons:
- No published starting price and no free plan or trial
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: drata.com
Best for: Continuous monitoring for NYDFS controls
A published price and a fast first certification
Secureframe
Secureframe starts at $7,500 per year for its Fundamentals package, which gives a startup a published price to put in a budget without a sales call. The platform automates evidence collection, maps controls across frameworks, and includes policy templates that cover the NYDFS duties a startup faces, including risk assessment records, access controls, and incident response plans. Expert support is part of the package, so a small team gets help scoping its first certification cycle and setting up its control set.
Secureframe does not file the annual NYDFS certification for a team, and it does not replace a lawyer for interpreting 23 NYCRR 500. A startup still needs a person who owns the cybersecurity program and signs the filing. The $7,500 starting price covers the Fundamentals tier only, and teams that need advanced risk management or questionnaire automation move to higher tiers that are quote only. Check current price before budgeting, since plan names and included features change.
Pros:
- Published starting price of $7,500 per year
- framework library covers 23 NYCRR 500 with guided onboarding
Cons:
- No free plan or trial, and higher tiers need a quote
Price: $7,500 per year
Free plan: No
Website: secureframe.com
Best for: A published price and a fast first certification
Risk registers and third-party risk in one tool
6clicks
6clicks starts at $4,800 per year and gives a startup a risk register, assessment templates, and third-party risk checks in a single workspace. For NYDFS work, the risk register is the natural home for the annual risk assessment, since each risk can carry its owner, its controls, and its mitigation actions in one record. The assessment module lets a team run the same questionnaire across internal systems and third-party service providers, which matters because the regulation requires a written third-party service provider security policy.
6clicks does not automate evidence collection as deeply as Vanta or Drata, and it does not connect to as many cloud and identity tools, so a team may still collect some evidence by hand. It also does not draft the incident response plan or file the annual certification, so a person on the team still owns those duties. Pricing is $4,800 per year at the entry tier, so check current price before budgeting, and confirm which modules the entry tier includes, since risk and vendor features can sit in higher tiers.
Pros:
- Published starting price of $4,800 per year
- risk registers, assessments, and vendor checks in one place
Cons:
- Smaller integration library than the larger compliance platforms
Price: $4,800 per year
Free plan: Free trial
Website: 6clicks.com
Best for: Risk registers and third-party risk in one tool
Audit-ready evidence for a fixed scope
Strike Graph
Strike Graph sells a fixed Certify scope at $21,500 per year, which gives a startup a clear price for a defined set of controls and evidence. For NYDFS work, the platform maps controls across frameworks, so evidence collected for ISO 27001 or SOC 2 can also support the NYDFS control set, which saves repeat work when certification season arrives. The fixed scope suits a team that wants to know exactly what is covered before it signs, rather than discovering gaps during an audit.
Strike Graph does not fit a pre-seed budget, and the fixed scope means a team with unusual systems may need extra work outside the platform. It also does not file the annual certification or draft the risk assessment, so a person on the team still owns those duties. The $21,500 starting price is the highest in this list, so check current price before budgeting and confirm exactly which frameworks the Certify scope covers.
Pros:
- Fixed Certify scope with a set price
- control mapping across frameworks saves repeat work
Cons:
- The $21,500 starting price is high for an early-stage startup
Price: $21,500 per year
Free plan: No
Website: strikegraph.com
Best for: Audit-ready evidence for a fixed scope
An audit package with a set price
Thoropass
Thoropass pairs its compliance platform with an audit package, and the Launch package costs $8,995 per year for teams of 1 to 10 employees. That bundle suits a startup that wants one vendor to handle both the software and the audit, since the same team that sets up the controls also guides the audit. For NYDFS work, Thoropass maps controls across frameworks and tracks the evidence an auditor will ask for, including risk assessments and policy acceptance records that support the annual certification.
Thoropass does not file the annual certification, and the Launch audit package is sized for teams of 1 to 10 employees, so a startup that grows past that headcount needs a larger package at a higher price. It also does not draft the risk assessment or the incident response plan, so a person on the team still owns that writing. The $8,995 starting price is published, so check current price before budgeting and confirm the audit scope, since the Launch package covers a defined set of frameworks.
Pros:
- Launch audit package at $8,995 per year for teams of 1 to 10 employees
- audit support bundled in
Cons:
- No free plan or trial, and the audit package suits small teams only
Price: $8,995 per year
Free plan: No
Website: thoropass.com
Best for: An audit package with a set price
Control tracking across many frameworks
Hyperproof
Hyperproof tracks controls across many frameworks at once, so a startup can manage NYDFS duties alongside SOC 2, ISO 27001, and other frameworks in one workspace. Each control carries its owner, its evidence, and its test history, which gives an auditor a clear trail from the regulation to the proof. The platform supports risk assessments and control testing in the same place, so a team can run its annual risk assessment and its control tests without moving between tools.
Hyperproof does not automate evidence collection from cloud systems as deeply as Vanta or Drata, so a team may still collect some evidence by hand. It also does not file the annual certification or draft the risk assessment, so a person on the team still owns those duties. Pricing is quote only, so check current price before budgeting, and confirm which frameworks the quote covers, since framework counts can change the price.
Pros:
- Strong control tracking with evidence linked to each control
- framework library covers many regulations at once
Cons:
- No published price, and setup takes time for a small team
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: hyperproof.io
Best for: Control tracking across many frameworks
Risk workflows built around your own process
LogicGate
LogicGate lets a startup build risk workflows that match its own process, rather than forcing the team into a fixed template. For NYDFS work, that flexibility helps a team model its annual risk assessment, its control tests, and its vendor reviews in one system, with each workflow carrying its own owners, due dates, and evidence links. The risk register tracks each risk with its controls and mitigation actions, which gives an auditor a clear view of how the program runs.
LogicGate takes more configuration than a template-driven tool, so a small team should budget setup time before the first certification cycle. It does not automate evidence collection from cloud systems, and it does not file the annual certification or draft the risk assessment. Pricing is quote only, so check current price before budgeting, and confirm the scope of the quote, since workflow counts and user counts can change the price.
Pros:
- Flexible workflows that match a startup's own risk process
- strong risk register and control tracking
Cons:
- No published price, and setup takes more configuration than a template-driven tool
Price: quote only
Free plan: No
Website: logicgate.com
Best for: Risk workflows built around your own process
How we choose
How we choose
We compared vendor pricing pages, documentation, and feature lists for eight tools that cover 23 NYCRR 500, risk management, or third-party risk. Every price in this article comes from a vendor pricing page opened on 14 November 2026, and tools that hide their price are listed as quote only. We did not test any tool hands-on and we did not run a trial, so this comparison reflects what vendors publish, not a lab test. We weighted NYDFS framework coverage, risk assessment support, third-party vendor checks, and published pricing, since those are the duties a startup faces first under the regulation.
Buyers guide
- Confirm the tool covers 23 NYCRR 500 in the tier you are quoted, since some vendors charge extra for additional frameworks.
- Confirm whether the tool tracks multi-factor authentication coverage, since the regulation requires it for remote access and privileged accounts.
- Ask who owns the risk assessment inside the tool, since no platform in this list writes it or files the annual certification for you.
- Check whether evidence collection is automated for the cloud and identity systems you run, or whether your team will collect some evidence by hand.
- Confirm trial length and what happens to your data if you do not renew, since Vanta offers 7 days and most others offer no trial.
- Confirm the audit scope before you buy an audit bundle, since Thoropass Launch covers teams of 1 to 10 employees and Strike Graph Certify covers a fixed scope.
- Budget for legal review separately, since no tool replaces a lawyer for interpreting the regulation.
- Ask for the price in writing, since five tools in this list are quote only and their prices vary by team size and scope.
Frequently asked questions
What does NYDFS require from a startup?
The New York Department of Financial Services cybersecurity regulation, 23 NYCRR 500, requires a cybersecurity program, a risk assessment, a written incident response plan, multi-factor authentication, and an annual certification to the department. Covered entities must also notify the department within 72 hours of a cybersecurity event. A startup should confirm with counsel whether its license makes it a covered entity.
How much does NYDFS compliance software cost?
Published starting prices in this list run from $4,800 per year for 6clicks to $21,500 per year for Strike Graph, with Secureframe at $7,500 and Thoropass at $8,995 in between. Five tools are quote only, so their prices vary by team size and scope. Add legal review and audit fees on top, since software alone does not cover those costs.
Does NYDFS apply to a startup outside New York?
The regulation applies to entities licensed by the New York Department of Financial Services, including banks, insurers, and other financial services firms operating under its authority. A startup outside New York that holds such a license is still covered. A firm with no New York license should confirm its status with counsel before assuming it is exempt.
Can a startup handle NYDFS compliance without a consultant?
A small team can handle the first steps, such as setting up controls and running a risk assessment, with a compliance platform and clear internal ownership. Most startups still need a lawyer for regulatory interpretation and an auditor for certification support. Thoropass bundles audit support, which suits teams that want one vendor for software and audit.
What is the NYDFS annual certification?
Covered entities must certify each year that they complied with 23 NYCRR 500 during the prior year, or identify areas of noncompliance and remediation plans. The certification is filed with the department and signed by a senior officer or the board. Software can track the evidence behind the certification, but the filing itself remains a human responsibility.