Researched comparison

Top Phishing Simulation Software for Startups

Tierlyn may earn a fee from some links on this page, and some placements are paid and labelled. Neither one decides the order. See our disclosure.

The short answer

KnowBe4 is the top pick for startups with 25 or more staff because its Foundation plan starts at $2.40 per user per month and pairs simulations with the largest training library in the category. Startups under 25 users should use Microsoft Attack Simulation Training instead, since Defender Plan 2 costs $5 per user per month and has no seat minimum.

Key takeaways

  • KnowBe4 leads for startups with 25 or more staff, with Foundation pricing from $2.40 per user per month on a 3-year term.
  • Microsoft Attack Simulation Training suits startups under 25 users, at $5 per user per month with no seat minimum.
  • Hoxhunt, Proofpoint, Infosec IQ, Cofense, Curricula, and NINJIO do not publish prices, so budget a sales conversation.
  • A startup without a security hire needs a platform that runs with an hour a week, not a tool that needs a full-time owner.
  • Measure click rates and report rates together, since a team that clicks less but never reports is still exposed.
Contents

Tier labels are an editorial grouping, not a number and not a rating out of any total. S means a top tier pick for most readers. A means a strong choice with a clear strength. B means a solid option for a specific need.

S A B

Comparison at a glance

Comparison

How these compare
ToolBest forPrice rangeFree plan
KnowBe4Largest training library$2.40 per user per monthNo
Microsoft Attack Simulation TrainingNo seat minimum$5 per user per monthNo
HoxhuntAdaptive gamified trainingquote onlyFree trial
Proofpoint Security AwarenessThreat-led simulationsquote onlyNo
Infosec IQTraining plus simulationsquote onlyNo
Cofense PhishMeSimulation and reportingquote onlyNo
CurriculaStory-led short trainingquote onlyNo
NINJIOShort animated episodesquote onlyNo

Ranked by tier

1

Largest training library with phishing simulations

KnowBe4

KnowBe4 is the market leader in security awareness training and simulated phishing, and its SAT Foundation plan starts at $2.40 per user per month for 25 to 50 seats on a 3-year term, with an Advanced plan at $3.75 per user per month at the same seat count. The platform pairs phishing simulations with a training library of interactive modules, videos, games, posters, and newsletters in more than 34 languages, and its four tiers, Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Diamond, scale from core training to advanced analytics and AI defense features. List pricing for smaller deployments runs roughly $20 to $30 per user per year on Silver, with volume and longer terms lowering the rate.

The 25-user minimum is the real constraint for a startup. A team of 10 or 15 people cannot buy KnowBe4 at all, and the four optional add-ons each cost extra, so the headline per-user price can grow once you add the features a growing team wants. KnowBe4 also needs someone to run the program, though an hour a week is enough for a small team once templates and landing pages are set. It fits a startup that has passed 25 staff and wants the deepest content library available.

Pros:

  • Four tiers from Silver to Diamond
  • training content in more than 34 languages

Cons:

  • A 25-user minimum applies, which rules out the smallest startups

Price: $2.40 per user per month

Free plan: No

Website: knowbe4.com

Best for: Largest training library with phishing simulations

2

Startups on Microsoft 365 with no seat minimum

Microsoft Attack Simulation Training

Microsoft Attack Simulation Training is part of Defender for Office 365 Plan 2, which costs $5 per user per month billed annually as an add-on, and it is included with Microsoft 365 E5. It lets your team send simulated phishing emails using real techniques, including credential harvest, malware attachment, and link to a fake site, and it tracks who clicked, who entered credentials, and who reported the message. Because it runs inside your own Microsoft 365 tenant, there is no separate console to learn, no extra data leaving your environment, and no seat minimum to clear.

The drawback is depth. Attack Simulation Training is a solid simulation tool, but its training content and reporting are thinner than a dedicated platform such as KnowBe4, and it needs a Microsoft 365 E3 base subscription or the Plan 2 add-on, which adds cost on top of the base license. It also works best when someone runs campaigns regularly and follows up with the users who click. It fits a startup already on Microsoft 365 that wants simulations without a second vendor or a minimum seat count.

Pros:

  • Included with Microsoft 365 E5
  • simulations use real phish techniques in your tenant

Cons:

  • Needs a Microsoft 365 E3 base or an add-on, and reporting is thinner than a dedicated platform

Price: $5 per user per month

Free plan: No

Website: microsoft.com

Best for: Startups on Microsoft 365 with no seat minimum

3

Adaptive gamified training that changes behavior

Hoxhunt

Hoxhunt is a human risk management platform that combines AI with behavioral science to send each user phishing simulations matched to their skill level, then follows up with short micro-training the moment they click or report. The platform is gamified, which keeps users engaged without long courses, and it measures behavior change over time rather than just completion rates. Its simulations cover advanced phishing and social engineering, and the reporting button training teaches users to flag real phish, not just avoid fake ones. For a startup, that engagement matters because a small team cannot afford training that people ignore.

The main problem is price transparency. Hoxhunt does not publish prices, and third-party figures conflict, with one guide citing about 4.85 euros per user per month for a 2-year term at 100 users and another listing $4.50 per user per month. Neither figure is a vendor price, so a startup should get a written quote before budgeting. Hoxhunt fits a team that wants adaptive, engaging training and is ready to negotiate a contract.

Pros:

  • AI-driven adaptive simulations matched to each user
  • strong focus on reporting behavior

Cons:

  • No published price, and third-party figures conflict, so the real cost needs a quote

Price: quote only

Free plan: Free trial

Website: hoxhunt.com

Best for: Adaptive gamified training that changes behavior

4

Threat-led simulations tied to real attacks

Proofpoint Security Awareness

Proofpoint Security Awareness builds phishing simulations from the same threat intelligence that powers its email security products, so the simulations reflect the attacks actually hitting your industry. That threat-led approach matters because generic templates teach users to spot yesterday's phish, while Proofpoint templates mirror the lures attackers are using now. The platform includes training modules, reporting, and analytics, and it integrates with Proofpoint email protection so a user who clicks a real phish can be enrolled in training automatically.

The drawback is commercial. Proofpoint does not publish prices for Security Awareness, and third-party guides place it near $18 to $38 per user per year as part of bundled enterprise licensing, which is not a vendor figure. The best value comes when it is bundled with other Proofpoint products, so a startup buying it alone may pay more. Proofpoint fits a startup that already runs Proofpoint email security and wants simulations tied to live threat data.

Pros:

  • Simulations draw on Proofpoint threat intelligence
  • strong fit with Proofpoint email security

Cons:

  • No published price, and the best value comes when bundled with other Proofpoint products

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: proofpoint.com

Best for: Threat-led simulations tied to real attacks

5

Training plus simulations with compliance content

Infosec IQ

Infosec IQ, from Infosec Institute, combines phishing simulations with security awareness training and compliance content in one platform. It offers a large library of training modules, including compliance topics that a startup needs as it grows into regulated customers, and its simulations include templates, landing pages, and reporting that show who clicked and who reported. The platform suits a team that wants one vendor for both phishing simulations and the compliance training that customers and auditors ask about.

The limit is price transparency and focus. Infosec IQ does not publish prices, so a startup must go through a sales cycle to learn the cost, and the platform covers more than phishing, which means some of what you pay for is content your team may never use. It fits a startup that wants training and simulations together with compliance coverage, and it is less useful for a team that only needs phishing simulations.

Pros:

  • Large training library with compliance modules
  • simulations and training in one console

Cons:

  • No published price, and the platform is broader than phishing alone

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: infosecinstitute.com

Best for: Training plus simulations with compliance content

6

Simulation and reporting with a focus on the report button

Cofense PhishMe

Cofense PhishMe sends simulated phishing emails and measures how users respond, with a strong focus on the report button: users who report a simulation are coached, and the platform tracks report rates alongside click rates. That matters because a team that reports real phish quickly gives the security team time to act, and PhishMe is built around that behavior. The platform includes mature templates, landing pages, and reporting, and it connects to the wider Cofense platform for email incident response.

The drawback is price and scope. Cofense does not publish prices for PhishMe, and the full value of the reporting workflow comes when it is paired with Cofense Triage and other modules, which adds cost. A startup buying PhishMe alone gets solid simulations but misses the incident response loop that makes reporting pay off. PhishMe fits a team that values reporting behavior and is ready to build a triage step around user reports.

Pros:

  • Strong reporting workflow that turns user reports into triage
  • mature simulation templates

Cons:

  • No published price, and the full value needs the wider Cofense platform

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: cofense.com

Best for: Simulation and reporting with a focus on the report button

7

Story-led short training for busy teams

Curricula

Curricula delivers security awareness training as short, story-led episodes with characters and humor, which suits a startup where nobody has time for hour-long courses. Its phishing simulations test whether staff apply what the episodes teach, and the admin console is simple enough for a founder or operations lead to run without security experience. The content covers phishing, social engineering, and safe habits in plain language, and the reporting shows who finished training and who clicked.

The limit is price and simulation depth. Curricula does not publish prices, so a startup must get a quote, and its simulations are lighter than those of a dedicated platform such as KnowBe4 or Cofense, with fewer template options and less reporting depth. It fits a startup that wants training people will finish and a simple program to run, and it is less useful for a team that needs advanced simulation features or deep analytics.

Pros:

  • Short story-based episodes that staff actually finish
  • simple admin for small teams

Cons:

  • No published price, and the simulation side is lighter than dedicated platforms

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: curricula.com

Best for: Story-led short training for busy teams

8

Short animated episodes that teach phishing defense

NINJIO

NINJIO delivers security awareness training as short animated episodes of 3 to 4 minutes, each telling a real-world story about a phishing attack or social engineering trick, and its PHISH3D simulations test whether staff spot the tricks the episodes teach. The format suits a startup because episodes are short enough to watch between tasks, and completion rates run higher than long courses. The platform includes reporting on training completion and simulation results, and it covers phishing, ransomware, and safe behavior in plain terms.

The drawback is price transparency and focus. NINJIO does not publish prices, so a startup must go through a sales cycle, and the platform is training-led rather than simulation-led, which means its simulation features are simpler than those of a dedicated platform. It fits a startup that wants engaging training with simulations attached, and it is less useful for a team that needs advanced simulation templates or deep reporting.

Pros:

  • Animated 3 to 4 minute episodes with high completion rates
  • PHISH3D simulations included

Cons:

  • No published price, and the platform is training-led rather than simulation-led

Price: quote only

Free plan: No

Website: ninjio.com

Best for: Short animated episodes that teach phishing defense

How we choose

How we choose

We compared vendor pricing pages, product documentation, and plan limits, and we checked each published price against the vendor page on 15 November 2026. We favored tools with a published price or a clear per-user rate, because a startup should be able to budget before a sales call. We did not run hands-on tests, and we did not accept vendor claims about click-rate reduction without a published source. Quote-only tools stayed on the list where their capability is distinct, but they are marked clearly so you can plan for a sales conversation.

Our full method

Buyers guide

Confirm the minimum seat count, since several platforms start at 25 users and a smaller startup cannot buy them at all. Ask whether the price includes training content or only simulations, and get the cost of add-ons in writing. Check which languages the training covers and whether templates match the phishing your team actually receives. Confirm how the report button works and where user reports go, and test a campaign with a small group before rolling it out to the whole team.

Frequently asked questions

How often should a startup run phishing simulations?

Run a simulation at least once a month, with short training immediately after a user clicks. Monthly cadence keeps the lesson fresh without turning simulations into background noise, and it gives you a trend line for click rates and report rates. A single annual test tells you almost nothing, since one result cannot show whether behavior is improving.

What is a good click rate for phishing simulations?

A good click rate is under 5 percent, and a strong program pairs that with a report rate above 50 percent. The click rate alone is misleading, since a team that never clicks but never reports is still exposed when a real phish arrives. Track both numbers together, and focus on the users who click more than once, since repeat clickers carry the most risk.

Can a startup under 25 people buy KnowBe4?

No, KnowBe4 applies a 25-user minimum, so a team under 25 users cannot buy it at any tier. Startups below that size should use Microsoft Attack Simulation Training at $5 per user per month if they run Microsoft 365, or a tool with no seat minimum. Revisit KnowBe4 once the team passes 25 staff, since its Foundation plan starts at $2.40 per user per month.

Do phishing simulations work without training?

Simulations alone change little, because a user who clicks and hears nothing will click again. A simulation works when a click triggers short training at once, and when a report earns a quick thank you. The training is the lesson, the simulation is the test, and a program that runs one without the other wastes the budget. Pair every campaign with follow-up.

What should I do when someone clicks a simulation?

Send short training at once, not a lecture weeks later, and keep the tone helpful rather than punitive. A user who fears punishment will stop reporting real phish, which is worse than a click. Record the click, the training delivered, and the next result, so you can show improvement over time and spot the users who need extra help.

Sources

About the team

Tierlyn Editorial Team

Tierlyn sorts security, identity and backup tools into tiers instead of a single ranked list, because a top pick for a five-person startup can sit lower for a regulated enterprise. Every tier states the team size and risk level it was built for, and lists the price we saw on the vendor page with the date attached. We update a tier the moment a vendor changes a plan or drops a feature we relied on.

Related guides